35 Best Pizza Restaurants near West Cape May

“I challenge you to find better pizza anywhere in Cape May County. Jake’s is 10/10. His Bianca is what dreams are made of.“

“We were in Cape May for one night and just wanted a pizza and a quiet night. Brothers II was a great choice. Mozzarella sticks were great and the half and half pizza we got was exactly what we wanted. Very friendly service too. Next time we’re in Cape May, we’ll be back.“

“Had the Philly wrap it was amazing great customer service on a very busy night“

“We went to Wildwood Beach and stopped at Dominos for lunch. Ordered cheese & veggie delight pizzas 🍕 along with bread bites and twists. It took around 15-20 mins for our pizza to come on our table. Cheese pizza was good but delight wasn't that great. There was too much of sauce and it wasn't baked to perfection. In the mean time we enjoyed fire truck 🚒 parade from tbe windows. There's parking in front of the store for 3-4 cars. Restroom 🚻 is inside the store which is Neat and clean. Overall good 👍

Vegetarian options: You get a lot of veggie varieties here or simply order a cheese pizza

Parking: There are 3-4 general parking slots, 1 disability parking slot, 3 of them were 15-min parking for curbside pick up“

“Awesome restaurant. I’m in town for the Elks convention and staying in a hotel right next door. I kept walking by and smelling the food and seeing the meals. Me and my friends stopped by today. I got the sushi which was fabulous. The drinks were awesome also. Great time. I’ll be back!“

“Don’t let the off island location fool you, Mangia is a great spot!! Great food. Great service!! Highly recommended! I had the lasagna and it was awesome. Abby was our A+ server! Huge portions… we left with enough for lunch tomorrow! We’ll be back again!!“

“Excellent pizza! I have been in cape may a lot this is the best pizza I have found! My family’s go to for pizza!“

“We had just eaten at Sam's Pizza. As we were walking back to our hotel, XO Pizza was offering samples. OMG the Grandmother's pizza was delicious. The crust was crispy on the bottom and it was light and airy. The toppings were perfect, just a hint of basil. I highly recommend stopping by to try their pizza. It was so good, I went back the following day for lunch. If you haven't tried their pizza, you're missing out!“

“Everything we ordered was amazing! Fresh and delicious! 🥰“

“Had an away HS match in Wildwood. Instead of going to Wawa again to get a bite before the bus ride home, I took the team to Crazy Junky. 14 of us were accommodated for pizza, salads, and cheesesteaks. All reviews from the team were excellent. The pizza was delicious and the service was friendly. Would recommend other HS teams traveling to Wildwood to stop by for a visit too.“

“First off extremely friendly owner, owner and a couple locals were very nice to my son n I, as for the pizza, hands down one of the best pizza’s I’ve ever had, sauce was a little sweet, great tasting and even the crust was great!! Very reasonable prices as well, lived up to its reputation as one of the best in Wildwood, if you’re looking for the best in Wildwood I highly recommend!!!! 10 outta 10!!!!!!“

“We ordered pizzas and Stromboli, it was really good . We will def. Be ordering again !“

“Listen up Kingdom!!! We got a new wing king in town. I grew up in Wildwood. Home of some of the best pizza in South Jersey and some would argue the East Coast. So please understand the gravity of this statement: Bruni’s has the best pizza and wings in the Rio Grande area and it’s open year round. Bruni's Pizzeria Let’s break this down. I had to survey the food for the my first since ownership changed hands. This has been a go to spot since I’ve moved out to Rio Grande, but hadn’t had a chance to check in for a while. Cheesesteak w/ fried onions & green peppers. Came with a bag of chips and side of crisp pickles. Classy Bruni’s…very classy. Also, banging cheesteak! Bruni’s over here standing on business with a generous portion of steak and cheese. The roll was loaded and every bite was delicious! Pizza: Alwasy amazing, but for some reason it just had a little extra crisp to the crust. Honestly, incredible… from the sauce, to the crust, to the cheese. Barstool Sports should get in on the magic happening in those ovens. Okay, a newer item on the menu. An excellent business decision. The Wings! I need to say this with all respect. These wings reminded me of Bill’s Corner Deli. The wings are phenomenal so if you like the crispy style wings or just a wing lover this is your spot when you’re in town. Also, we got a side of blue cheese and a side of ranch with our order (ranch for the wife, lol). The ranch sauce was next level. Why is this review soooo long? Because Bruni’s is worth it. Speaking of worth it: Reasonable prices and top notch food. Check it out for yourself. I’m not wrong.“

“I ordered a veggie burger & sweet potato fries, pretty much my go-to at a pizza place. It was tasty but better than anywhere else because of the experience. I saw you give away food to someone in need, I saw you show compassion & kindness. I will support this business in the future! “On the way to Cape May” ❤️“

“Went here in the summer of 2021 and by far one of the best made pizzas I have ever had.“

“Pizza is always awesome 😋“

“Best pizza in all of the wildwoodss,,“

“Great family restaurant. Found the sausage sandwich I was searching for here. Outstanding.“

“Got pizza, subs, Stromboli and salad this week at the beach and it didn’t disappoint.
Good dough, fresh ingredients, and I really enjoyed that when I walked in to pick it up, I saw an entire family working as a team and slinging out good eats for south Jersey.

Can’t wait to come back. Excellent for family vacation dinner.“

“Staying in Cape May for 5 weeks had my first cheese steak & I picked up a good one had it tonite ( 7/7/2025 being a Philly guy I know my steaks very good I highly recommend their sandwiches.“

“First time ordering.. Italian Stromboli was very good.. a little too much cheese but very tasty.. dipping sauce was delicious“

“The wait staff needs to get their act together, always miserable & rude.“

“Best pizza around“

“PROs - lots of options , quality was good, good service
CONs- parking

Was in Washington street mall and was looking for a place for lunch - for kids and for us .. lucky to spot JOJOs pizza .. ?. Of course we thought it was just a pizzarea … but they had much more than that . Pizza was good. It was big and nicely done . Very good service . Was quick and we got food really fast .

They also had so many other things . We ordered felafel wrap .. and another veggie wrap. Felafel wrap was my favorite . Was really good. We also had milk shakes and drinks . Mostly good . Priced good . Not too expensive : parking is tough .. wanted to give 4 but they deserved 5 stars ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“The welcoming employees. The feeling u get when u enter the store. The atmosphere is so vibrant and full of kindness. Even the customers are kind and happy. I love that they have a setup for the children.“

“The staff is amazing, their pizza is the best down here. Owners our awesome people. Everything I had was delicious! Highly recommend this place. Glad staying open for the winter .“

“First time customers and could not be happier. Wow, just Wow...... this will be a go to place going forward when we are down the shore“

“The food was delicious.I will make a point to come back next year!“

“Was disappointed in the service of received. I ordered 3 pizzas to be delivered I live down the street from Pizza Hut 🍕. It took over an hour and the pizza was cold 😞. Had to heat it up in the oven. It Was delicious 😋“

“Came to this place all summer long 10 times total, they have the BEST Pitaya (dragonfruit) and Acai Bowels in Wildwood in my opinion. All the fruit was so fresh every time. And the prices are great, cheaper than anywhere else we've seen. I also had their summer salad and they serve breakfast all day long, I loved all that food too“

“I find the food to be very good, wait staff is excellent. I do not find it loud and a sports bar at all, TVs are on but not obnoxious. We’ve had nice meals here!“

“Omg literally the best pizza in the world , and super kind family that make you feel So welcomed !!! Highly recommend!!“

“Great food and service highly recommend“

“Tonight was our first time trying Panico’s. It will definitely not be our last. Everything was delicious. The staff was very friendly and helpful. If you are in Cape May you have to try it. You will not be disappointed.“

“Great people! Very cooperative when my bank locked my card (for my security) and the woman with the beautiful eyes wanted to make sure my young daughter ate either way. Thank you for being so kind to us. The food was excellent. Wish I could leave 6 stars.“