37 Best Pizza Restaurants near West Cape May

“what a great gem near sunset Beach.“

“First timers in cape may and we landed on an awesome pizza spot! The staff are super personable, and the food is super fresh. Can't wait to come back to Cape may because of this great pizza experience!

Kid-friendliness: Friendly staff interaction with our toddler :)“

“I was a die hard Mack’s fan until we decided to try a pizza option that was outside the box in 2023. Crazy Junkie Pizza next to the Boardwalk Chapel is Amazing. The ingredients are so fresh and flavorful. The pizza is a work of art. Taste is one of a kind. Staff is so friendly and welcoming. We were just there this week for the second time while on our yearly vacation to Wildwood. The quality, tastes, and flavor profile was exactly as we remembered from last year. If you are tired of the same old pizza offerings and want an adventurous alternative then Crazy Junkie pizza hits that mark. I never write reviews for things but felt compelled to recommend this amazing hidden gem. You would be crazy to pass up the opportunity while in Wildwood. Thanks for becoming a family tradition when we visit.“

“The Grandmother Pizza was out of this world“

“Had the Philly wrap it was amazing great customer service on a very busy night“

“I just received my order and Steve was my deliver. I must say he was amazing and very funny text. He let me know where he was when he would arrive when he was approaching and hand my order to me with a smile after a stressful day, it really made my night. Thank you Steve.“

“My husband just brought home a pick up order and the food is absolutely delicious. More than anything though, he was struck by the service and thoughtfulness of the cook making sure the order was perfect. We will be making stops here frequently. Great spot!“

“Excellent pizza! I have been in cape may a lot this is the best pizza I have found! My family’s go to for pizza!“

“I try to have some pizza in my refrigerator all the time. I had few issues over the years but they always made it right to my satisfaction.“

“Had an away HS match in Wildwood. Instead of going to Wawa again to get a bite before the bus ride home, I took the team to Crazy Junky. 14 of us were accommodated for pizza, salads, and cheesesteaks. All reviews from the team were excellent. The pizza was delicious and the service was friendly. Would recommend other HS teams traveling to Wildwood to stop by for a visit too.“

“We just went to wildwood for the first time this weekend and had this place two times we have been there, great staff and great food“

“Rino’s pizza was excellent. We were on a weekend trip to Cape May, I tried ordering takeout at 2 other local establishments beforehand and both denied taking a carry out order for 3.

Rino’s was close to the Airbnb and had great reviews.

I ordered a large pepperoni, wings and waffle fries. The food was 10/10 they were the best wings I’ve had in a while. Will definitely be back again!“

“Fast service and best pizza!!“

“had lunch and dinner there today....was good and the waitress was very nice.“

“Not a bad pizza the dough was sweet and fluffy. The cheese was just perfect. Some people might say a little on the heavy side but in my eyes was just perfect. I would order from here again. Cash only establishment which shows awesomeness and old school.“

“We ordered pizzas and Stromboli, it was really good . We will def. Be ordering again !“

“I ordered a veggie burger & sweet potato fries, pretty much my go-to at a pizza place. It was tasty but better than anywhere else because of the experience. I saw you give away food to someone in need, I saw you show compassion & kindness. I will support this business in the future! “On the way to Cape May” ❤️“

“Listen up Kingdom!!! We got a new wing king in town. I grew up in Wildwood. Home of some of the best pizza in South Jersey and some would argue the East Coast. So please understand the gravity of this statement: Bruni’s has the best pizza and wings in the Rio Grande area and it’s open year round. Bruni's Pizzeria Let’s break this down. I had to survey the food for the my first since ownership changed hands. This has been a go to spot since I’ve moved out to Rio Grande, but hadn’t had a chance to check in for a while. Cheesesteak w/ fried onions & green peppers. Came with a bag of chips and side of crisp pickles. Classy Bruni’s…very classy. Also, banging cheesteak! Bruni’s over here standing on business with a generous portion of steak and cheese. The roll was loaded and every bite was delicious! Pizza: Alwasy amazing, but for some reason it just had a little extra crisp to the crust. Honestly, incredible… from the sauce, to the crust, to the cheese. Barstool Sports should get in on the magic happening in those ovens. Okay, a newer item on the menu. An excellent business decision. The Wings! I need to say this with all respect. These wings reminded me of Bill’s Corner Deli. The wings are phenomenal so if you like the crispy style wings or just a wing lover this is your spot when you’re in town. Also, we got a side of blue cheese and a side of ranch with our order (ranch for the wife, lol). The ranch sauce was next level. Why is this review soooo long? Because Bruni’s is worth it. Speaking of worth it: Reasonable prices and top notch food. Check it out for yourself. I’m not wrong.“

“The food is very good. Had the wings and mozzella sticks this time around and i recomend them. Very good!!!“

“Went here in the summer of 2021 and by far one of the best made pizzas I have ever had.“

“I have been eating at this place for years and I have always been happy with the food and how super friendly they are. but on January 13, 24 I ordered a Philly cheese steak and wings. with the sauce on the side. I have ordered this for years I like the sauce on the side so I can put it on as much as I like it. and the cheese steak had nothing but onions no meat I paid 12 bucks for a Fried onion sandwich.i took pictures of all of it. as for the sandwich I CAN'T EAT IT NOT AT ALL. I CALLED AND TOLD THEM ABOUT NO MEAT ON THE SANDWICH. THE PERSON ON THE PHONE SAID OH REALLY. I JUST SAID THANK YOU AFTER THAT RESPONSE. I AM NOT AS MUCH AS I AM PISSED. IT HURT ME CAUSE I AM BEEN GETTING MY PIZZA AND WINGS AND PHILLY CHEESE STEAK AT THIS PLACE FOR OVER 10 YEARS. AM TOTALLY Surprised. THAT THEY DIDN'T EVEN CALL ME BACK TO FIX THE PROBLEM. THESE ARE TRULY GOOD PEOPLE WHO ARE THE Owners. WITH HOW MUCH MONEY IT IS FOR EVERYTHING. NOW AM THROWING AWAY 12 BUCKS. FOR A Fried onion sandwich. AM VERY DISAPPOINTED VERY VERY DISAPPOINTED.“

“Great family restaurant. Found the sausage sandwich I was searching for here. Outstanding.“

“Pizza is great and so was the service. Strongly recommend!“

“PROs - lots of options , quality was good, good service
CONs- parking

Was in Washington street mall and was looking for a place for lunch - for kids and for us .. lucky to spot JOJOs pizza .. ?. Of course we thought it was just a pizzarea … but they had much more than that . Pizza was good. It was big and nicely done . Very good service . Was quick and we got food really fast .

They also had so many other things . We ordered felafel wrap .. and another veggie wrap. Felafel wrap was my favorite . Was really good. We also had milk shakes and drinks . Mostly good . Priced good . Not too expensive : parking is tough .. wanted to give 4 but they deserved 5 stars ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“The welcoming employees. The feeling u get when u enter the store. The atmosphere is so vibrant and full of kindness. Even the customers are kind and happy. I love that they have a setup for the children.“

“One of the hidden gems of the shore. Wings were perfect. Most places here only serve buffalo,surprisingly, and Cappy's had the best garlic sauce! Pizza slices as big as your head! Eat at Cappy's while you're here, you won't regret it!!“

“First time ordering.. Italian Stromboli was very good.. a little too much cheese but very tasty.. dipping sauce was delicious“

“First time customers and could not be happier. Wow, just Wow...... this will be a go to place going forward when we are down the shore“

“The staff is amazing, their pizza is the best down here. Owners our awesome people. Everything I had was delicious! Highly recommend this place. Glad staying open for the winter .“

“The wait staff needs to get their act together, always miserable & rude.“

“Came to this place all summer long 10 times total, they have the BEST Pitaya (dragonfruit) and Acai Bowels in Wildwood in my opinion. All the fruit was so fresh every time. And the prices are great, cheaper than anywhere else we've seen. I also had their summer salad and they serve breakfast all day long, I loved all that food too“

“Best pizza around“

“Great overall, I mean hello it’s Pizza Hut! Ordering was convenient on the app and it was ready in just under 15 mins. However the associate didn’t take a second to look up from her phone to say anything or greet me; I had to announce that I was in the store in front of the register ready for a pick up when she was literally standing at the register, I just thought that was odd.“

“Great food and service highly recommend“

“We love love love Panico's! We use to always go to Sapore but Sapore has gone down hill since new ownership. We love how Panico's doesn't rush you, and you can take your time. The food is also great, I recommend either the 3 cheese chicken or the rigatoni vodka and ask for the chicken breaded! It is also nice that it's a BYOB, so it is inexpensive. If you're looking for good Italian food in Cape May, please go here and AVOID at all costs Andrea Trattoria. 10/10!“

“True brick oven taste Good cheese sauce ratio. Hot & gooy when Larger than Large slices arrived at our table. I've been a Mack's man for years. Joe's might make me reconsider.“

“The food was delicious.I will make a point to come back next year!“