50 Best Pizza Restaurants near West Cape May

“I challenge you to find better pizza anywhere in Cape May County. Jake’s is 10/10. His Bianca is what dreams are made of.“

“So I ordered a Margherita pizza and couldn't wait to eat it. I got half no garlic. Unfortunately when I got back to the place yesterday there was no Basil on the pizza. Im not sure if he forgot or didn't have any? It was a delicious white pizza with tomatoes, just no basil :( good pizza though!“

“I was a die hard Mack’s fan until we decided to try a pizza option that was outside the box in 2023. Crazy Junkie Pizza next to the Boardwalk Chapel is Amazing. The ingredients are so fresh and flavorful. The pizza is a work of art. Taste is one of a kind. Staff is so friendly and welcoming. We were just there this week for the second time while on our yearly vacation to Wildwood. The quality, tastes, and flavor profile was exactly as we remembered from last year. If you are tired of the same old pizza offerings and want an adventurous alternative then Crazy Junkie pizza hits that mark. I never write reviews for things but felt compelled to recommend this amazing hidden gem. You would be crazy to pass up the opportunity while in Wildwood. Thanks for becoming a family tradition when we visit.“

“Awesome restaurant. I’m in town for the Elks convention and staying in a hotel right next door. I kept walking by and smelling the food and seeing the meals. Me and my friends stopped by today. I got the sushi which was fabulous. The drinks were awesome also. Great time. I’ll be back!“

“I've been enjoying Macks Pizza since 1971 when my parents let an 11 year old walk the boardwalk alone for the first time. Mrs T was one of my first memories. we've been several times a year since and each of my children and grandkids have had their first slice of pizza at Macks. Yes, I happily drive 2 and a half hours to load up on the best Pizza ever!!“

“Had the Philly wrap it was amazing great customer service on a very busy night“

“The cleanliness, fast service, excellent staff from front to back, food, and prices are quite excellent. We’ve been going to this particular Hotspot for many years and I don’t ever recall anything that we ever received being anything but excellent. I highly recommend. Some of the reviews on here I find just simply mean spirited.“

“Always a fun time at CView! Great, casual atmosphere with good food. Brianna is a fantastic bartender!“

“the calzones are fantastic!!“

“Let me build the scene: just a family enjoying their vacation, and out of nowhere, BAM! Hanger strikes! What does a guy do when his ladies get hangry? That's when it hit me! They need pizza, and fast! So i called upon the best, i put my faith in Dominos! Before Hanger knew it, Driver Steve rode in upon his glorious chariot, daftly doling out delicious discs! Like some kind of dinner santa claus, and the night was saved! All hail, Steve! Seriously, he's awesome, all you are.. now you keep that up! Love you“

“Everything we ordered was amazing! Fresh and delicious! 🥰“

“Don’t let the off island location fool you, Mangia is a great spot!! Great food. Great service!! Highly recommended! I had the lasagna and it was awesome. Abby was our A+ server! Huge portions… we left with enough for lunch tomorrow! We’ll be back again!!“

“A true Wildwood classic! If you're looking for pizza while down here in Wildwood, Sam's is a must-try. This boardwalk staple Sam's Pizza Palace Official serves up an iconic slice with a perfectly crispy crust and that signature, slightly sweet sauce. The cheese is melted perfectly, and every bite brings back that nostalgic Jersey Shore magic.Even when the summer lines get long, the staff moves incredibly fast, and the service is always friendly. Whether you are a local or just down for the weekend, grab a seat in their dining room or walk the boards with a slice in hand. Highly recommend stopping by for one of the best pies on the boardwalk! 🍕“

“Popped in yesterday because I needed a quick bite while waiting for my daughter to finish up practice for the cheer convention. Ordered 2 cheese and 1 pepperoni. Pizza was made fresh and tasted delicious. Not to mention they were big slices. Thoroughly enjoyed it in the car!“

“I've been enjoying Macks Pizza since 1971 when my parents let an 11 year old walk the boardwalk alone for the first time. Mrs T was one of my first memories. we've been several times a year since and each of my children and grandkids have had their first slice of pizza at Macks. Yes, I happily drive 2 and a half hours to load up on the best Pizza ever!!“

“Pizza is always awesome 😋“

“I ordered a veggie burger & sweet potato fries, pretty much my go-to at a pizza place. It was tasty but better than anywhere else because of the experience. I saw you give away food to someone in need, I saw you show compassion & kindness. I will support this business in the future! “On the way to Cape May” ❤️“

“had lunch and dinner there today....was good and the waitress was very nice.“

“Living in Court house, the choices for pizza were limited and mediocre. Moved to Del Haven (in delivery distance now) we ordered Rino's pizza BEST PIE IN TOWN! Perfect crust, silky cheese, savory sauce & speedy delivery! I'm hooked!“

“We ordered pizzas and Stromboli, it was really good . We will def. Be ordering again !“

“Best pizza in all of the wildwoodss,,“

“Great family restaurant. Found the sausage sandwich I was searching for here. Outstanding.“

“The food was delicious.I will make a point to come back next year!“

“Best pizza around“

“Omg literally the best pizza in the world , and super kind family that make you feel So welcomed !!! Highly recommend!!“

“The staff is amazing, their pizza is the best down here. Owners our awesome people. Everything I had was delicious! Highly recommend this place. Glad staying open for the winter .“

“Food has been amazing!!! Everything we order is delicious! My family and I are on vacation and we have ordered breakfast and dinner, and this place does not disappoint. Highly recommend!!!“

“Staying in Cape May for 5 weeks had my first cheese steak & I picked up a good one had it tonite ( 7/7/2025 being a Philly guy I know my steaks very good I highly recommend their sandwiches.“

“The pizza is amazing! ❤️ so much flavor“

“2nd floor seating overlooking the ocean is cool. The guy who opened the place was cool. Clean establishment. Great location. I'm eating a slice of pie watching rollercoasters, waves and women. Holla at ya boy.

All jokes a side. The place at the end of the day is a domino's, but I've early seen a domino's that you can eat in. I definitely haven't seen one on the boardwalk. Place is great. Perfect weather. Shout out Wildwood.“

“My husband and I come to Cape May every year for our anniversary we have our favorite places that we love to visit this was our first visit to Pacino's bistro and we went back the night after to pick up again!!! The food was phenomenal and the wait staff were very hard working and friendly!!! I am server myself and this not an easy job but they were excellent. The ambiance in restaurant made the experience that much better. Cannot say enough good things about this establishment!“

“Very tasty pizza, and very kind staff who makes you feel welcome, taken care of, and most importantly well fed. We had a great conversation with the workers inside, and everyone had a great time. Thank you to the workers at Jojo's on 11/2/25 for cultivating a great experience!“

“First time customers and could not be happier. Wow, just Wow...... this will be a go to place going forward when we are down the shore“

“5 star! what started out as a bad weekend. We stumbled across this place last day. and we were impressed! Don't second guess . Just go -you will love everything about this place. thank you for your hospitality ♡ # from Baltimore“

“The welcoming employees. The feeling u get when u enter the store. The atmosphere is so vibrant and full of kindness. Even the customers are kind and happy. I love that they have a setup for the children.“

“New air conditioning makes this laundry mat much eiser to handle in the summer. Just got 2 new over sized washers to do extra large quilts or your animals bedding. Cheaper then any other laundry mats in area and staff is even friendlier then other laundry mats. I hate going to laundry mat but staff makes it more pleasant.“

“The cleanliness, fast service, excellent staff from front to back, food, and prices are quite excellent. We’ve been going to this particular Hotspot for many years and I don’t ever recall anything that we ever received being anything but excellent. I highly recommend. Some of the reviews on here I find just simply mean spirited.“

“First time ordering.. Italian Stromboli was very good.. a little too much cheese but very tasty.. dipping sauce was delicious“

“Excellent Food, friendliest staff“

“Alex’s Pizzeria is a great spot for breakfast, lunch, and something quick while you’re in Wildwood. The food is fresh, the service is friendly, and it’s an easy place to stop with family.

Their açaí bowls are especially good fresh, cold, and loaded with great toppings. It’s nice to have a lighter, refreshing option along with pizza, sandwiches, and breakfast items. Definitely worth stopping in if you’re nearby!“

“Just bought some catering platters last night from Italian Affair! The chicken parm, and shrimp scampi were delicious, as were the salad, pasta, and homemade bread! There is plenty leftover for lunch today! Service and delivery were excellent, prompt, and friendly. We will definitely order again!! Thank you, I was able to enjoy my company instead of cooking!! Highly recommended!!“

“Was disappointed in the service of received. I ordered 3 pizzas to be delivered I live down the street from Pizza Hut 🍕. It took over an hour and the pizza was cold 😞. Had to heat it up in the oven. It Was delicious 😋“

“came across this place and wasn’t sure about it but took a gamble and it was best decision ever. place felt very homey and was super delicious and fresh! prices were reasonable, would definitely come back again. i got enchilada tacos, chorizo nachos, and milanesa de pollo torta. all was tasty! they need more recognition“

“We love Erma’s. We’ve had breakfast, lunch, and dinner meals there. The food has always been very good. And the Staff is very friendly.“

“Grandma’s pizza is delicious“

“We visited today first day of the 2025 season. The atmosphere is awesome beach sand with tables and umbrellas, Large fire pits and a large outdoor bar. The weather was 65 and partly cloudy . The host was friendly and welcoming made us feel right at home. Our waiter Jamie was friendly, accommodating and couldn’t do enough for us. He made us laugh and we never felt rushed his personality is on par! We had fried shrimp with sauces, and fried Mac and cheese balls with remoulade sauce and some cocktails. Everything was delicious. Can’t wait to come back later in the summer!“

“Very good food Large variety on the menu Delicious food…I had the wings loved them. Love that they are really meaty and breaded. Everything thing we had was great. Everyone so polite and accommodating!!!“

“If you’re looking for Cape May’s hottest subterranean hotspot, look no further than The Boiler Room. This place has everything: wood-fired pizza, Caesar salads that slap, neon lights, exposed brick, and a sound system that’ll knock your Birkenstocks off. And the staff? Honey. First, let’s talk about Matt, the food and beverage manager. He’s like the Wizard of Oz behind the curtain, pulling levers of flavor and hospitality. Ever had a martini that made you cry from joy? You will. Now add Johnny and Kyle behind the bar—Cape May’s dynamic duo. They pour, they shake, they stir, and they SERVE. Watching them in action is like seeing a choreographed dance, except everyone gets a drink at the end. Now let’s get into the pizza. This pizza? This pizza is like if Naples and Brooklyn had a baby that went to culinary school in Rome. It’s crispy, chewy, saucy perfection. And don’t even get me started on the Caesar salad—it’s crunchy, briny, creamy, and anchovy-whispered. I’d write it a love letter and send it first class. But that’s not all. When the sun goes down, this place transforms. The Boiler Room becomes an underground concert hall of dreams. The live bands? They funk, boogie, and rock ‘n’ roll like it’s their job (because it is). Think Parliament meets Tom Petty in a dance-off judged by Prince. They groove party anthems and timeless classics that’ll have you screaming, “This is MY SONG!” while you dance like it’s 1999. The Boiler Room has everything: brick oven dreams, Caesar epiphanies, killer cocktails, craft beers, sultry lighting, beautiful people, bar legends, and music that hits like a vintage disco ball to the soul. So if you’re in Cape May and you’re not at the Boiler Room, what are you even doing with your life? Sent from my iPhone“