I Knead Sugar

$$$ • Custom Cakes

118 Boardman Dr, Gallup
(505) 488-2447


Take-Out/Delivery Options

Reviews for I Knead Sugar

Avoid this place!! Complete waste of money!! The cake was not even close to what we ordered…different color, bubble on the cake, poor presentation. We waited 2 1/2 hours past the pick up time, as result, it didn’t make the baby shower…good thing though because it would’ve been embarrassing to show. When we asked for a refund of the $150, the owner was extremely unprofessional and rude!! She didn’t care about her poorly made product and literally blamed us.BASHAS and...read full review

Absolutely disappointing.I’ve placed orders before with no issues but this last time was inexcusable. My order was forgotten, rushed, had lower than usual presentation, and was only half correct in the end. I was willing to overlook it all until I had guests come to me with various complaints and even saw a few spit their cupcakes back out.Based on complaints, it was obvious the order was rushed. Will no longer recommend or place any future orders.

Cake was delicious but waited around in town 3 hours to be completed. Luckily our dinner was way later in the evening. Placed another order of cookies for a different event and yet wasn’t ready and was told I didn’t request individually wrapped when I specifically said individually wrap for a drive thru shower. So apparently I wasn’t charged for the service of individually wrapped. Lastly, I recommend this to another person and they had to wait for the cake as well for...read full review

More Reviews(46)


Monday Closed
Tuesday 10AM - 5PM
Wednesday 10AM - 5PM
Thursday 10AM - 5PM
Friday 10AM - 5PM
Saturday 10AM - 3PM
Sunday Closed

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.