“My partner never had Stefano’s and I hadn’t had it since I was a young adult because I moved from Pulaski, but they have it in Adams now and all I’m saying is…don’t listen to the 1 star reviews on this page. They’re haters and let them hate and order you some Stefano’s because it’s still awesome!“
Breakfast • $
“Love, love, love this place. As We read in another review, this place is a hidden gem! My husband and I had breakfast here a few mornings ago and wow, the food was delicious, portions were huge, coffee was great and our sweet server was amazing and kind!! Such a wonderful and charming place to go! Looking forward to going again soon!!“
“Got pepperoni pizza and wings to go. The pizza tasted great. Got the mild, parmesan garlic, and blue Betty (or whatever their surgical sauce is). The mild has a really great flavor and we're cooked perfectly. The garlic parmesan had a really great flavor too but we're just a tad overcooked. I don't mind that but it made breaking the wings apart a little harder - nothing to deter because the flavor was good. The special sauce were good also.“
“I'll preface with this: not my style of pizza. For round pizza I like napoletena, coal fired NYC, New Haven, etc. This pizza is a totally different product.However, that said, it's pretty tasty. I've tried all of the pizza in Watertown, Carthage and Adams. This may be the best tasting.Pretty heavy on the cheese, but if you like that you'll love this. Nice crunchy cornicione, well cooked and a tasty, light sauce. It's definitely cooked with love.To me this seems suited to children's tastes, so if that's your target audience, I don't think you can go wrong here.“
“I don't mind the original papatinos in watertown but never has been my first pick, however being down camping in sackets harbor where papatinos II is located, we went ahead and ordered pizza and wings from there one night during camping and it was an entirely different experience, cook, seems recipes maybe even because it was phenomenal!! I thought maybe we just got lucky, nope. They are amazing EVERY SINGLE TIME, so much so, that we make the drive to sackets from watertown every single time we order pizza and wings, and for my family, that's at least 3 times a week! We ask for all flats, extra saucy and just a little crisper cooked maybe an xtra minute only for our wings and usually just a simple cheese or cheese and pepperoni pizza, however we are a family of restaurant owners, a cook and server that both work at a fancy brick oven Italian restaurant, we know our stuff, we love food, and I take happiness in letting people know where the GREAT eats are and papatinos II is THE BEST PIZZA AND WING PLACE AROUND HERE PERIOD. watertown sackets harbor all surrounding areas! Trust me I am a pizza addict and loveeeee my flat wings! I've tried every spot around!“
“My favorite dishes weren’t as delicious as they usually are. Still good but pizza was undercooked and bruschetta (their version is my absolute favorite) not as tasty. Service was outstanding as always. It’s still my favorite restaurant in Sackets and I’ll definitely return because 90% of the time, it’s 5 stars. No one can be ‘A game’ every day, especially in winter.“
“From start to finish this was the best experience! The owner was extremely accommodating and so beyond kind each time my husband called. They even decorated, as this was for my son’s 4th birthday celebration with his friends? Our server was gracious, patient, and very very attentive! The food was also absolutely DELICIOUS. Would recommend this over and over again to anyone I know!Kid-friendliness: 10 out of 10!!“
“Tried this place today due to a friend referral and it was good, but not enough to be a regular. The pizza has minimal sauce, light cheese, and thick crust with a little smokiness to it. The sauce is sweet, which I was not expecting. Got a side of celery and standard blue cheese which costs extra. Price is a little bit on the expensive side. Sadly I don’t think I would order again, but the service was really nice.“