11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Oswego

“1st time in today and I have to say you folks have a great staff and amazing pizza. Will return.“

“Clean atmosphere, fresh toppings and a hint of smoke from the wood fired oven. Very good. 1 pizza with 4 toppings and 2 drinks $22.03. We would go back and recommend.“

“Hands down my favorite Pizza in the area. Second time I’m purchasing 14 Pizzas for my employees and the service, staff and overall atmosphere is outstanding. Beautiful Mom and Pop restaurant!
I’m not Portnoy but I’ll score this establishment an 8.8.“

“Food is pretty good. Staff is friendly. Your order will probably take a little while to be served. However, that's because it's being made fresh. Decently priced food. When your calzones are ready, they are served approximately the temperature of the sun, which is ideal.

Vegetarian options: Several dairy options.“

“Lots of good pizza options in Oswego, but Pies Guys is our go-to. We love the NY style! We have had issues with online ordering through DoorDash once or twice so we always call. We always do pickup with them: YMMV, but for us delivery is usually slow, and the pizza often arrives lukewarm.“

“Perfect ending to a perfect day, Cheeseburger pizza and wings, Dar + Norm 2/14/21“

“They had an abundance of wait staff whom watched for any customer needs without pestering. They also boxed up our leftovers as well. However, I wasn't a fan of the sauce on my lasagna. It tasted like tomato juice or sauce without any other seasonings. The lasagna also fell apart.“

“Our server was GREAT!
The food was wonderful, but was a little disappointed in the "Fixed Romano Sauce" It was delicious, just not the way I've had it in past times. It seemed heavier, and more ("tomatoey"sp) less butter and Romano? My family said same thing when I brought leftovers home.....Still, all was great...I especially love the provolone, roast pepper, artchoke, pepperoni platter! Thank you, Canale's, for a great meal“

“It was fresh out of the Oven and it was delicious.“

“We have hired GJP multiple times to cater our school parties. We have had breakfast, lunches and dinners catered and they are always wonderful!! Larry is top notch and always so easy to work with. Thank you!“

“I order for pickup here late night all the time. Definitely a late night indulgence.Their boneless wings are honestly some of the best. Sweet chili or hot honey are my faves with their jalapeno ranch sauce.They have multiple Calzones for every taste bud as well.“