11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Oswego

“We have tried most pizza joints in Oswego- and none of them quite hit the mark. Cold upon arrival- raw onion tossed on the pizza prior to arrival (oops we meant to cook it) or just crappy pizza! So we decided to try Pizza Villa and we are pretty happy with the pizza. It is on the thicker side which presents a small issue that I will address- but the flavor was great, toppings abundant and the baked wings were delicious. Heading home from Liverpool we called and placed a pickup order. Meat pizza with onions and an order of plain wings- crispy. Staff that answered the phone were great and informative and after a “give us about 30 min” I hung up the phone and headed their way. Arrived to lots of smiles and happy staff making pizzas and wings and told them we had not had great experiences with other places in Oswego- and they said “well we hope you love ours” Got home and dug in. The pizza and sauce (just the right amount) is delicious. I had asked for it to be well done as we generally prefer thin crust, theirs is pretty thick, and they obliged. The wings were really great and fell off the bone. The only criticism I have is that due to the thickness of the crust, it wasn’t cooked through and was doughy. They seem to cook the pizza in a pan in the oven and it doesn’t have direct contact with the oven (that is what I saw) so perhaps the pan is keeping the crust from cooking through? Not sure- but it was the only draw back. It wasn’t horribly undercooked just enough that it was noticeable. Other than that- great taste, great experience and we will be back!!“

“The food is always great, and the service is always friendly. 10 out of 10! I would definitely recommend!“

“Used to order wonzones all the time when I lived on campus because they have a deal with thr school where you can order their food using dining dollars issued by the school with meal plans. It was great every time and 1 canzone was typically filling enough to save for leftovers later.
What ultimately made me write this review was that I no longer live on campus, I live relatively close by and decided to stop in to order. This was my first time not just ordering for delivery and instead dining in. The staff was so friendly and cheerful it made me regret not stopping in sooner!“

“Hands down my favorite Pizza in the area. Second time I’m purchasing 14 Pizzas for my employees and the service, staff and overall atmosphere is outstanding. Beautiful Mom and Pop restaurant!
I’m not Portnoy but I’ll score this establishment an 8.8.“

“Lots of good pizza options in Oswego, but Pies Guys is our go-to. We love the NY style! We have had issues with online ordering through DoorDash once or twice so we always call. We always do pickup with them: YMMV, but for us delivery is usually slow, and the pizza often arrives lukewarm.“

“Perfect ending to a perfect day, Cheeseburger pizza and wings, Dar + Norm 2/14/21“

“They had an abundance of wait staff whom watched for any customer needs without pestering. They also boxed up our leftovers as well. However, I wasn't a fan of the sauce on my lasagna. It tasted like tomato juice or sauce without any other seasonings. The lasagna also fell apart.“

“It was fresh out of the Oven and it was delicious.“

“Great night wine Wednesday with a great singer Eric Ruckus“

“We have hired GJP multiple times to cater our school parties. We have had breakfast, lunches and dinners catered and they are always wonderful!! Larry is top notch and always so easy to work with. Thank you!“

“I order for pickup here late night all the time. Definitely a late night indulgence.Their boneless wings are honestly some of the best. Sweet chili or hot honey are my faves with their jalapeno ranch sauce.They have multiple Calzones for every taste bud as well.“