20 Best Pizza Restaurants near Weedsport

1
Arber

Arber Italian •
8889 S Seneca St, Weedsport

“They are always fast and have your order exactly how you want it. We order from here at least once a week as a family .. even the picky little ones like it so we decided that's what we order for family night ... They even know you by name .it makes for a personal experience. I wish I had a photo to share .they have way more than just pizza ... Great food Pleasant people and local“

4.3 Superb7 Reviews
Nino's NY Pizzeria Pizza • $
8889 S Seneca St, Weedsport

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza & Mozzarella Sticks
Grilled Chicken to Any Salad
Jalapeño Cheddar Poppers
Ham & Cheese Calzone
Eggplant Parmigiana
Chicken Parmigiana
Pulled Pork Pizza
Chicken Riggies
Chicken Tenders
Stuffed Shells

“This is your friendly, neighborhood quality pizza shop. Good food, great people -- nothing fancy, and supports local schools and teams.Wheelchair accessibility: No obstacles between the parking lot on the side of the building and the front door. Large open space upon entering and no restricting cordoned areas. In winter, the parking lot was plowed, and the sidewalk was cleared of snow.“

4.2 Good36 Reviews
Empire Eatery Pizza • $
9036 N Seneca St, Weedsport

“As a truck driver I drive the Thruway a lot and with coffee shops not being open late this is one of my go-to stops. Mainly because they actually have cookies there that they bake .in house. If you're looking for a coffee and a treat fix definitely want to make a stop here. It is inside the pit stop gas station. And they also have food that is made to order. I will say I do wish they had some pizza out late at night but otherwise good service good coffee and good cookies“

3.9 Good13 Reviews
New York Pizzeria Pizza • $
11376 Main St, Cato - 8.25 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch
Medium Hot Wings
Specialty Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
New York Pizza
Grilled Wings
Chicken Wings
Veggie Pizza
Wrap
Subs

“The cauliflour pizza blew my freakin mind. It was the first time since being cursed with a gluten intolerance that I've actually had pizza that tasted like pizza. This place is awesome - the staff is always havin' a good time! No wonder it's the most popular spot in town.“

4.7 Superb54 Reviews
Rinaldo's Pizzeria & Catering Pizza • $
235 E Main St, Elbridge - 6.28 miles

Customers` Favorites

Nonna's Chicken & Eggplant Parm
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Garlic Knots
Chicken Parm
French Fries
Cannoli

“Rinaldo’s in Elbridge, NY, is more than just a small casual pizzeria; it's a hidden gem offering both fantastic pizza and delicious Italian cuisine at unbeatable prices.During my visit, I indulged in the Upside Pizza lunch special, which included two monster slices and a drink for just $7! The pizza was outstanding, It was an incredible value, and the portions were extremely generous. After enjoying the pizza, we had the pleasure of speaking with the chef, who recommended trying several amazing dishes and I settled on ordering Nonna’s Eggplant and Chicken Parmesan for dinner. The food was so flavorful and plentiful that we couldn't help but rave about it. Rinaldo’s exceeded our expectations, proving to be more than just a pizzeria; it's a fantastic Italian eatery that I highly recommend to anyone looking for great food and amazing value.“

5 Superb24 Reviews
Dimitris Pizzeria Pizza • $
1124 NY-5, Elbridge - 6.98 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana with Penne Pasta
Chicken Wing Pizza & Greek Salad
Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza
Philly Cheese Steak
Chicken Riggies
Athenian Pizza
Stuffed Shells
Garlic Knots

“Totally AWESOME place. Owners and wait staff were fantastic even though it was packed . Every one was friendly and helpful.The scallops were sweet as they should be,hubby's 2 pc fried fish was really great and plenty,he ended up taking it home and air fried it the next day, potatoes were real mashed potatoes. They also use real butter. We will be going back real soon. I already love that place.❤️?Parking: Handicap parking and ramp“

4.6 Superb71 Reviews
Moro's Kitchen Italian • $$
28 Jordan St, Skaneateles - 9.72 miles

Customers` Favorites

Eggplant Parmigiano
Squash Ravioli
Calamari
Lasagna
Italian

“Stumbled upon this quaint restaurant the other day and I had to leave a review on the best server I’ve ever had the pleasure of meeting, Tony!The one lace was packed but I came alone for a quick bite because I was on my way to a meeting but Tony came up and got me a spot at the bar. As I’m looking at the menu we polite palaver and he suggest a some dishes, listening to him changed my life!!! When my food came out he noticed me about to pray over it and he stops he saying he knew I was in a rush so he blessed it while it was being prepared! This man was a god send. One might call him the Anthony Bourdain of the front of house.“

4.7 Superb46 Reviews
Gilda's Skaneateles Pizza • $$
12 W Genesee St, Skaneateles - 9.78 miles

Customers` Favorites

Spicy Fried Chicken Sandwich
Five-Spiced Fried Calamari
Beet & Burrata Salad
Fried Cauliflower
Mushroom Pizza
Veal Meatballs
Beet Salad
Hamburger
Arancini

“I wish Gilda's were closer to where I lived! There are always two things I always get when I'm there: the beet salad and the burrata pizza. I always think I'll try something new but I end up going back for the same thing because they're just that good. I love the puree and the creamy burrata that goes with the beets, and the arugula on top of the pizza gives it that fresh finishing. I once ordered take out and Gilda's was wise enough to pack the arugula separately.“

4.5 Superb63 Reviews
Rosalie's Cucina Italian • $$
841 W Genesee Street Rd, Skaneateles - 9.35 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cappa Santa Al Prosciutto E Basilico
Scaloppine Di Pollo
Cioccolato Torta
Cannoli Siciliani
Homemade Bread
Banana Budino
Creme Brulee
Braciole

“great meal at a classic joint... their caesar salad with corn, tomato, red onion.. nice twist! braciole with gnocchi, polenta appetizer, super professional friendly service.. nice on the way home after little road trip! always busy always good.. dependable go to when in that area!“

4.4 Superb93 Reviews
Nino's Pizzeria Pizza • $
115 Main St, Port Byron - 3.23 miles

Customers` Favorites

New York Style Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Pepperoni Pizza
Fried Mushrooms
Garlic Bread
Chicken Wing
White Garlic
Sandwiches

“Came to Port Byron for just a quick 24 hours and then back to Indiana . Super excited to have pizza in New York . The pizza was amazing and you were all so kinds . Would 100% recommend. Thank you for your patience and hospitality with tourist? ??“

4.7 Superb21 Reviews
Valentine's Delicatessen Pizza • $
18 W Genesee St, Skaneateles - 9.76 miles

Customers` Favorites

Large Cheese w 12 Wings
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings
Chesse Pizza
Phillysteak

“We stopped into this wonderful place during the Dickens Christmas 2023 festival and could not have left any happier. They have a great selection of pizza slices and side dishes ready to go along with plenty of made to order options. The food was delicious and sampled quite a bit of it. The icing on the cake was our group contained 6 adults and 2 small children and the bill for our feast was LESS than $100! Valentine's was a fun part of our day and will definitely be part of our plans when we return to Skaneateles.“

4.4 Superb34 Reviews
3 C's Pizzeria Pizza •
1579 Clark Street Rd, Auburn - 8.52 miles

Customers` Favorites

Slice of Garlic Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Boneless Wings
Veggie Lover

“Food was absolutely delicious, prices are amazing staff were so nice and sweet, they gave me extra wings because “ they were a little small” they were the biggest boneless wings I have seen. they are amazing here definitely coming back! Pizza was not greasy at all, wings were cooked perfectly and the garlic parm sauce was absolutely delicious!!!!Dietary restrictions: They have so many optionsParking: It’s a mall parking lot, very openKid-friendliness: Staff are amazing and so nice and so many options for the picky eaters!Wheelchair accessibility: Flat ground with easy access“

4.8 Superb12 Reviews
Mr. Pizza Pizza • $
69 Wall St, Auburn - 7.87 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Wings
Cheese Steak
French Fries
Fried Dough
Sub Rolls

“Update 3-28-24 went here again today. Ordered hot wings with Louisiana sauce and a meatball sub. The sauce on the wings was good. It had a underlying vinegary taste with a kick. Only down fall was the wings were not crispy . Next time I will ask for them crispy. My boyfriend liked the meat ball sub. The roll was homemade. The bread absorbed most of the sauce on the sub. Next time we will ask go a side of sauce with the sub. Everything tasted yummy. Will definitely be back ........The restaurant itself definitely has a lack of atmosphere.It's a takeout place. They don't have anywhere to eat inside. They did have a picknick table outside though. They also sell pizza by the slice.The pepperoni pizza we ordered was pretty good. We ordered the Sicilian.I don't normally care for pizza crust. I liked this pizza crust though. The crust was light and crispy not doughy . I didn't get any, but the cookies they had looked delicious. The wings we ordered were pretty good aswell“

4.4 Superb24 Reviews
Amelia's Pizza Pizza • $
250 Genesee St, Auburn - 8.65 miles

Customers` Favorites

2 Specialty Slices & a Can of Soda
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Specialty Calzone
Large French Fry
Chicken Wings
Sausage Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Knots
Onion Rings
Stromboli

“I got Amelia’s for the first time last nigh. My My only regret about ordering from here is that I didn’t do it sooner!!!!!! It was sooooooooooo delicious!!!!!!! And when our food was done early, they called me to let me know, how cool is that?!?! My new favorite pizza place in Auburn, FOR SURE!“

4.3 Superb41 Reviews
Papa Paulie's Pizza Pizza • $
247 Genesee St, Auburn - 8.61 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza

“If there is a heaven I hope it smells like Papa Paulies!!!I used to love Piccirillos pizza and literally cut my first tooth on their crust 59 years ago. When they sold the business I was heart broken but Paulies made the transition with the same recipes, quality and amazing flavor I loved as a child FLAWLESSLY!!Hands down and second to none, they are the very best pizza!I drive in at least once a month from Oswego just to get a pie from them. Crazy? Until you've had one you'll never understand!!!Trish Watkins“

4.5 Superb13 Reviews
Curley's Bar • $
96 State St, Auburn - 7.93 miles

Customers` Favorites

Beef Steak Special Sandwich
Caesar Salad with Steak
Cheeseburger and Fries
blt Club Sandwich
Reuben Sandwich
Wings and Fries
Hamburger Wrap
Chicken Tenders
Chicken Wings
Meatball Sub

“Are waitress was absolutely fantastic.....Steak Sandwich and fries this Sandwich is sliced sirloin or chicken. It's enough for 2 people other sadwich is a BLT with fries very very good..... Hey big pile of fries for both of us.....Parking: A few parking spots on the street ....directly across the street is another parking lot which is very good size......“

4.2 Good69 Reviews
Mamma Maria New York Pizzeria Auburn Pizza • $
217 Grant Ave, Auburn - 6.9 miles

Customers` Favorites

Large Cheese Pizza
Fried Cauliflower
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pizza Rosettes
Garlic Sticks
Garlic Knots
Bread Sticks
Cheese Cake
Calzones
Pizzas

“It's located in a a shopping plaza. They have ample parking.I've walked in here a few times now before and grabbed a slice. They always have a wide variety available to choose from. Everything always looks and tastes so good. Lots of different kinds of toppings on the slices they have available. They heat it up pretty quickly for you. They always seem to have a steady stream of traffic of people dropping in to get a slice to go.You can also it in.“

4.2 Good51 Reviews
Mark's Pizzeria Pizza • $
59 Arterial W, Auburn - 7.73 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Salad
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Chicken Wings
Garlic Bread
Chef Salad

“Mark's has consistently great customer service and whenever I get delivery, the food is hot and fresh (and it arrives fast!). Whoever manages this place is doing something right because every employee I encounter is friendly and efficient. Keep up the good work, Mark's!“

4.3 Superb21 Reviews
DeTomaso's Pizzeria Pizza • $
17 Columbus St, Auburn - 8.28 miles

Customers` Favorites

Arancini Rice Balls
Chargrilled Wings
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Tenders
Pizza & Wings
Fried Dough
Traditional
Grinder

“Oh, talking about pizza just makes me hungry! ? Imagine biting into a slice where the crust is perfectly crispy on the edges but still chewy and soft in the middle. The sauce is a blend of tangy and sweet that just sings with every bite. Then there's the cheese, oh the cheese! It's that gooey, stretchy, melty goodness that pulls away with every slice. Toppings are fresh, vibrant, and they're generous without overwhelming the pizza. It's the kind of pizza that makes you close your eyes and savor each bite. It's not just food; it's an experience! ?Talk about a stand up comedian, Laci can put a smile on anyone’s face and make them laugh! I never have a dull moment when she’s around. Last but not least, let’s talk about Riz. With Riz’s delicious dessert pizzas that sell out just seconds after being put on display, it’s no wonder they have a Riz special on their menu named after her. The Reese’s dessert pizza is off the charts. This family owned business and their amazing menu is what I look forward to every time im visiting Auburn.“

4.2 Good42 Reviews
Towpath Pizza Pizza • $
2 S Main St, Jordan - 4.66 miles

Customers` Favorites

BBQ Chicken Calzone
French Fry

“I’m so glad we have this pizza shop in Jordan! If I could give 10/10 stars I would. I have never had a bad experience here, the staff is super friendly and food always shows up sooner than anticipated. Some of the absolute best pizza and subs I have ever had! I don’t understand the 1 star reviews, are you dealing with the same place that I am or do you just like to complain??“

4.1 Good37 Reviews
Loading...
map Map