16 Best Pizza Restaurants in Watertown

“If cocktail magic had a home address, it would be The Craft 836, where the bartender wasn’t just a drink-slinger—oh no—this professional mixology wizard seemed to craft beverages with the finesse of someone who may or may not have trained with celestial beings. Every glass that left the bar glowed with the promise of happiness, good decisions, and possibly better posture. And then… the Craft and Jamaican dry rub chicken wings. Scrumptious doesn’t even begin to describe them. These wings strutted onto the table like they knew they were the star of the show—juicy, spicy, and seasoned so perfectly you’d swear they had their own PR team. Meanwhile, everything coming out of the kitchen looked so jaw-droppingly delicious it made me question every life choice that led me to not ordering that, that, and definitely that. Even the ordering app was a delight. A simple QR scan and—voilà!—this sixty-something woman was tapping, selecting, and paying with the grace of a digital native. No confusion. No panic. No accidentally ordering seventeen sides of fries. (Though honestly, that might not have been the worst fate.) Kudos to the staff and management—this place runs like a well–garlic-oiled machine: smooth, flavorful, and leaving you wanting more. Five stars, a happy belly, and a newfound confidence in QR codes. Cheers!“

“Favorite pizza place! We typically go once a week and never have any issues.“

“I am updating my review from the past from a 3 star to a 5 after deciding to come back and try this place after avoiding it for several years.

I went with my family and we all had a great experience with great food. The host was friendly and attentive along with the server.“

“This was a very nice place for dinner. Our waiter was prompt, considerate, and helpful. Dinner was delicious. We will definitely be back when we return to the area.“

“Stopped for some slices of pizza as a date and it was great. Slices were huge, sauce was well seasoned and not overly sweet like other places up here, dough is thin while still having a nice chew, and it had a great sauce to cheese ratio. Will definitely be adding this to our list of pizza places we love!“

“I’ve been dying to try this place since they opened and holy cow I wish I tried them sooner. DELICIOUS pizza! Finally a really good pizza place for Princeton. The service was wonderful and the owner is beyond nice and incredibly friendly. You can 100% tell he absolutely loves what he does! Definitely going back for more!“

“Was in Watertown for a little getaway with my family and decided to try out Cams and it's a 10/10!!! I'm 100% it's the best pizza I've had in my life, made fresh right in front of you. it's delicious!!“

“servers are absolutely great.“

“Finally got some gelato this week and it was so worth it! We tried Pumpkin Pie and Fior Di Latte. Both equally delicious, the perfect sweet treat! I will definitely be stopping in for more!“

“Alteri’s is absolutely amazing!!! So many delicious foods to choose from!!! Breads, desserts, and meats!! The service is outstanding!! We always feel like family when we visit!! They truly value their customers!!! Don is the best!!! Thank you so much!!“

“Hands down my most favorite pizza in the world!!!!“

“fresh ingredients 😋 😋 yummy“

“Have been to the Paddock for years and it’s always been good but I have to say the service recently has been phenomenal. Ever since bringing in the new bartender Danny I look forward to making the paddock my go to even more. He is by far the best addition to the club in years, and actually knows how to handle the rush and make a drink the way it should be. I will continue to be back if I know he’s tending bar.“

“Amazing food anytime I get it. Love the calzones and wings! Will be getting their super bowl deals this weekend so very excited to try it and share with my friend and family! Anytime I go in to pickup they are very nice, good customers service and good atmosphere.“

“Best restaurant in watertown. Had the Adirondack burger and it was excellent, bacon and patty were especially great. Great selection of beers and will definitely come back to try more. I think the apple cider jerk wings could have been more flavorful but they were still good. The pizza was good too, will definitely be coming back to explore the menu and beer selection.“

“The pizza was amazing , Ordering online is so easy , and collecting points to earn free food for later is awesome ! Domino's is stepping up in the world, we love the Domino's app ,but some times we just go to there web site and order it there, we still receive the online discount without having to download the app, My local Domino's is grate there pizza is so perfect, they cut it so evenly spaced & cooked for just the right amount of time. Muhammad and Brian A, Are wonder Domino's employees and have outstanding customer service always making sure I save money some way some how. All of the employees are really nice that work there they have all.helped me one time or another ,thank you for your help and your kinda services and most of all feeding my family so many times and times again, and more in the future ,
Thank You Domino's“