15 Best Pizza Restaurants in Watertown

“If cocktail magic had a home address, it would be The Craft 836, where the bartender wasn’t just a drink-slinger—oh no—this professional mixology wizard seemed to craft beverages with the finesse of someone who may or may not have trained with celestial beings. Every glass that left the bar glowed with the promise of happiness, good decisions, and possibly better posture. And then… the Craft and Jamaican dry rub chicken wings. Scrumptious doesn’t even begin to describe them. These wings strutted onto the table like they knew they were the star of the show—juicy, spicy, and seasoned so perfectly you’d swear they had their own PR team. Meanwhile, everything coming out of the kitchen looked so jaw-droppingly delicious it made me question every life choice that led me to not ordering that, that, and definitely that. Even the ordering app was a delight. A simple QR scan and—voilà!—this sixty-something woman was tapping, selecting, and paying with the grace of a digital native. No confusion. No panic. No accidentally ordering seventeen sides of fries. (Though honestly, that might not have been the worst fate.) Kudos to the staff and management—this place runs like a well–garlic-oiled machine: smooth, flavorful, and leaving you wanting more. Five stars, a happy belly, and a newfound confidence in QR codes. Cheers!“

“Favorite pizza place! We typically go once a week and never have any issues.“

“Art's Jug has been has been one of Watertown New York's go to spots for dining for at least 50 years. Eat in or take out the food is always above par. One of their famous dishes is the anti pasta salad, you will see one on almost every table when you enter the establishment. They specialize in Italian dishes. Sit down, order up and enjoy, you will not be disappointed!“

“This was a very nice place for dinner. Our waiter was prompt, considerate, and helpful. Dinner was delicious. We will definitely be back when we return to the area.“

“Stopped for some slices of pizza as a date and it was great. Slices were huge, sauce was well seasoned and not overly sweet like other places up here, dough is thin while still having a nice chew, and it had a great sauce to cheese ratio. Will definitely be adding this to our list of pizza places we love!“

“I’ve been dying to try this place since they opened and holy cow I wish I tried them sooner. DELICIOUS pizza! Finally a really good pizza place for Princeton. The service was wonderful and the owner is beyond nice and incredibly friendly. You can 100% tell he absolutely loves what he does! Definitely going back for more!“

“Was in Watertown for a little getaway with my family and decided to try out Cams and it's a 10/10!!! I'm 100% it's the best pizza I've had in my life, made fresh right in front of you. it's delicious!!“

“servers are absolutely great.“

“Finally got some gelato this week and it was so worth it! We tried Pumpkin Pie and Fior Di Latte. Both equally delicious, the perfect sweet treat! I will definitely be stopping in for more!“

“Alteri’s is absolutely amazing!!! So many delicious foods to choose from!!! Breads, desserts, and meats!! The service is outstanding!! We always feel like family when we visit!! They truly value their customers!!! Don is the best!!! Thank you so much!!“

“Hands down my most favorite pizza in the world!!!!“

“fresh ingredients 😋 😋 yummy“

“We have traveled in for work and asked the front desk staff for a recommendation for dinner which lead us to Paddock’s Club! The atmosphere was incredible but more than anything, the service is what we won’t forget! Mary Jo provided an experience like no other sharing facts and recommendations while bringing a fun personality. We got to meet Chef Mike who we asked to make whichever meals he wanted for us and we were not disappointed! Mike is a man that puts his heart and soul into the food he makes and we had a delicious prime rib sandwich, sweet and spicy chicken and loaded potato skins. All were incredible! Then we finished the meal with the best bread pudding either of us had ever had. As someone who doesn’t traditionally enjoy bread pudding because of its soggy nature, I LOVED this one. We will definitely be back next time we are in town!“

“Amazing food anytime I get it. Love the calzones and wings! Will be getting their super bowl deals this weekend so very excited to try it and share with my friend and family! Anytime I go in to pickup they are very nice, good customers service and good atmosphere.“

“My boyfriend and I stopped here for a very enjoyable lunch after a doctor’s appointment. We did not notice until we were at home two hours away that we were accidentally charged for a bottle of wine instead of a glass. Due to the distance, we did not notify the brewery. Two days later, my boyfriend was not only compensated for the difference, he was also refunded part of the tip. This brewery not only has delicious food, but also integrity. Thanks for the great meal and honesty. We will definitely be back.“