11 Best American Restaurants in Alexandria Bay

Gal's Place American • $
42077 NY-12, Alexandria Bay

Customers` Favorites

Peanut Butter Hot Fudge Sundae
Marshmallow Overload
Peanut Butter Sundae
Raspberry Chocolate
Cappuccino Crunch
Large Sundaes
Banana Split
Sub Sandwich
Cookie Dough

“🍦 5 Stars – Amazing Ice Cream & Even Better Service! Gal’s Place Ice Cream is the perfect spot for a sweet treat, but what truly sets it apart is the incredible service from Emmy Claire and Josie. Every time we visit, they go above and beyond—friendly, fast, and always with a smile. They make the experience so enjoyable and memorable. Honestly, they’re the kind of employees any business would be lucky to have… and they definitely deserve a raise for all they do! Thank you, Emmy Claire and Josie—you make Gal’s Place the best around!“

4.9 Superb54 Reviews
River House American • $$
9 Market St, Alexandria Bay

“Best Live Music in town! ☯️“

4.2 Good23 Reviews
Windows on the Bay American • $$
17 Holland St, Alexandria Bay

Customers` Favorites

Calamari

“We chose Windows on the Bay, because it was highly rated and on the water. We were celebrating our 50th Anniversary with our son and his wife. We were able to sit on the deck, look out at the water and the boaters, and enjoyed a fantastic meal with great service. We did not need a reservation. Because other restaurants where we planned to eat on Sunday night were closed, we ate at Windows again and had the same enjoyable meal and service. Both waitresses were very efficient and personable. The food was great. As we are from Long Island, NY, we were used to paying a lot more for that kind of great meal.“

3.6 Good14 Reviews
Riley's by the River American • $
48 James St, Alexandria Bay

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Stuffed French Toast
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
The Spicy Burger
Riley’S Wings
Chicken Riggies
Walleye Nuggets
Eggs Benedict
Bourbon Salmon
Fish Sandwich
Home Fries

“This place turned out to be a blast, Great service from the staff especially our waiter Chris. We were a rowdy crowd and he took it all in stride! A great time was had by all!“

4.1 Good167 Reviews
Wolfes kountry Kottage Diner • $
43641 NY-12, Alexandria Bay

Customers` Favorites

Wolfe's Country Topper with Coffee and Grapefruit Juice
Strawberry Shortcake Pancakes
Roast Beef Hash and Eggs
Wolfe's Kountry Topper
Kountry Fried Steak
blt Turkey Ham Club
Blueberry Pancakes
Biscuits & Gravy
Cheese Omelette
Eggs Benedict

“Amazing food, Real home fries, skins and all!! Great service and friendly staff!“

4.3 Superb51 Reviews
Cavallario's Steak & Seafood Steak House • $$
26 Church St, Alexandria Bay

Customers` Favorites

Crispy Duck with Orange Grand Marnier Sauce
Rack of Lamb with Loaded Mashed Potatoes
Grilled Mahi Mahi with Mango Salsa
12 Oz Prime Rib and Shrimp Scampi
Steamed Fresh Littleneck Clams
Basically Seafood Alfredo
Baked French Onion Soup
Bacon Wrapped Scallops
Filet Mignon Salad
Shrimp Della Casa

“Quality food and excellent service staff. The staff were knowledgable about the menu as well as friendly and engaging. Food was cooked exactly as requested.“

4.1 Good96 Reviews
Dockside Pub Bar • $
17 Market St, Alexandria Bay

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Sandwich
Dockside Burger
Bang Bang Shrimp
Dockside Wings
Buffalo Chicken
Cheeseburger
Roast Beef
Taco Salad
Onion Rings
Pizza Logs

“Theeeee best poutine! OMG, it’s sooooo delicious! 😋 The waitresses/bartenders are super friendly and efficient! I highly recommend this restaurant when you’re in the Alexandria Bay area!“

4 Good81 Reviews
Old Homestead Restaurant American • $
30 James St, Alexandria Bay

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Steamed Clams

“The food is tasty but the portions were small for the price.“

3.3 Good64 Reviews
Lil' River Fudge Co American • $
24 James St A, Alexandria Bay

“1st time there and it was amazing !! The staff were very friendly and accommodating, and the fudge is truly the best I've ever had. Bought the chocolate and the maple both were amazing but I must say that the maple is soooooo good. Thank you again for the great service and absolutely the best fudge. Will definitely be top of the list for go to places in the Bay.“

3.8 Good28 Reviews
Riverboat Bar Bar & Grill • $
15 Church St, Alexandria Bay

Customers` Favorites

Riverboat Burger with Fries
Mushroom Swiss Burger
Peanutbutter & Jelly
Fried Shrimp PO Boy
Hot Italian Sausage
Bruschetta Burger
French Onion Soup
Chicken Parmesan
Meatball Bomber
Teriyaki Burger

“Great food and great service!!“

3.6 Good29 Reviews
Coleman's Dock Of The Bay Barbecue • $
2 James St, Alexandria Bay

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Mac and Cheese
Smoked Chicken Wings
Smokehouse Nachos
Half Rack of Ribs
Bang Bang Shrimp
Mahi Mahi Tacos
Smokehouse Wings
Mashed Potatoes
Barbecue Wings
Steamed Clams

“The Food is Amazing! The price is fair (better than average for Alex-Bay), the service is great, and the atmosphere is perfect! This is the best place to eat in A-Bay!“

3.4 Good69 Reviews

You May Also Like