17 Best American Restaurants near Allegany

“Love the atmosphere,best burgers anywhere!!!“

“Veggie wontons were light and super crispy with just the right amount of sweet and spice with the dipping sauce. The fish tacos and the pork tacos were perfect, and we especially liked the tang of that pickled cabbage with the fish. The staff was attentive and the atmosphere was really nice! We will be back.“

“best steaks in the area, and the fact that they have Jameson black barrel is a plus!!“

“My husband and I went there this evening to celebrate our 25th wedding anniversary and had the NY strip dinners, an appetizer and brought home a slice of the brown butter pecan cheesecake, everything was delicious! Our server was wonderful as well! We highly recommend J-Allen’s.“

“Olean, NY's favorite steakhouse.. We were at the casino about 30 minutes down the road and we wanted a good steak for our anniversary and I didn't want to pay the crazy prices at the steak restaurant in the casino.. The two brothers that run the family restaurant are pretty awesome!! The food was delicious and we got free desserts because it was our anniversary! The porterhouse steak was huge it took me 4 meals to finally finish it off. The dessert took it over the top!! Thanks for being so friendly!! We definitely recommend this place if you're in the area... Get there about 5pm if you wait until 6pm the line could be down the street.. Margaritas were good to...“

“👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍“

“My friend and I went here today, what a gem! The menu size was perfect, not too big or too small and beverage list was fantastic! We had a pizza and a sandwich to split between us, everything was wonderful! The service was great, the wait wasn’t long at all even with a busier afternoon and our bill was LESS than it is when we go to Chipotle, Applebees, or Pizza Hut. And the food was so much better! We will definitely be back! Has anyone noticed that we seem to be more dissatisfied with the bigger chain restaurants than we are over our locally owned businesses? 🤔 SUPPORT LOCAL!“

“Depends on my mood for the fish or meatloaf but both are delicious. They have the best French onion soup in the area! Can't go wrong eating here..oh wait ..forgot to mention how delicious their wings are too!!“

“One of the best kept secrets in the area! Beautiful venue. Amazing team to work with. Awesome food! Such a great time!! We love it here!“

“Best pizza around! Highly recommend.“

“Just wanted to Thank You for hosting the Lighter Palooza group Saturday night . The staff was awesome and the food was Top Notch. Thank you and hope to see you soon .“

“Best grilled prime rib I've ever had in my life. Everything was wonderful thank you Sam.“

“Great place friendly workers“

“Great atmosphere, friendly staff, and always excellent food! The Manhattan clam chowder was crazy good.“

“The food was absolutely amazing! Bourbon wings, Ruben with Cajun fries and the fried pickles are the best! The spicy ranch dressing puts the pickles over the edge! We will be back!“

“We came for an enjoyable birthday dinner. Got our first drinks at the bar. Change was given back wrong (shorted us.) ordered our dinner and never received our vegetables ( side dish.) didn't receive our toppings that went on the steak but eventually the waitress brought those out to us.
My husband decided to talk to the manager who we were very grateful to for making the night a success.“

“Great food! Stopped there on a whim and what a pleasant surprise. Staff was fun, food was great (try the chocolate cake) and atmosphere was cool! I can always tell when a restaurant has a real chef, and the quality of food and presentation said it all. Go there, you'll love it!“