16 Best Pizza Restaurants near Allegany

“It's nothing fancy but it's a must stop when you're in the Allegny or Olean area. The Burton Burger has won best burger in the state and it's fantastic. Just a burger on a toasted bun letting the flavor shine. Bring cash. On the tavern side of things, the usual suspects for beer with a few local craft options as well.“

“Boy I don't know about this one because I know these people. But I always tell the truth and that has gotten me into a little trouble before. But I told the truth. It's pretty much the same as all of the rest of your local sub shops It's all good just some items are better than othersEveryone has that 1 favorite idiom they like and order it every time comparing it. I know because that's what I do Human nature“

“Traveled 2 and half hours to visit the zipping museum and stopped in here for dinner, and the service was amazing. And the food was delicious.Never seen a restaurant ever put a peice of bread under the steak, which was a very good idea bcbit soaks up any juices and doesn't make the rest of the plate look bad or mixes with your food. Very nice presentation with it all.Cute, qainte little restaurant .Recommend the food in the pictures I posted.Stuffed mushrooms for an appChicken cor don Bleu sandwichWith French fries.And shrimp scampi and steak and baked potato“

“Best grilled prime rib I've ever had in my life. Everything was wonderful thank you Sam.“

“I grew up on south Clinton Street. When On the side opened . My foster brothers and sisters frequented . The steak and cheese is my favorite. I use to love the meatball subs. Until he changed meatballs. And disappointed that they are closed on weekends now . Been a customer for 49 years. And will always go there. The owner is a nice guy and has worked extremely hard to make on the side what it is. And the staff is friendly and goes out of their way to make sure. You have the best experience“

“This pizza is the best pizza on the planet, and the staff is a great group of people“

“The food here is always amazing. You can see right into the kitchen so you know it is clean. The workers always seem to be having a great time and they are always friendly. Tons of meat and toppings on the subs and wraps. Wings were crispy and had great flavor. We have a camp about 25 minutes away in Shinglehouse PA and it is worth the trip everytime.“

“The scotch ale on tap was fresh/crisp/delicious! I decided on the pizza special, 16" pie with 1 topping for $10. I went with the standard pepperoni. The homemade dough was cooked to perfection. I don't usually eat the crust but this pizza was amazing. Their sauce was just the right amount and homemade as well. So good!! The Broken Wing is the real deal when it comes to pizza!“

“Decided to give Fox's a try for dinner today, as I heard their was a new owner. Hands down the BEST pizza I've had in ages! They obliged our request for a half and half pizza (one half bacon, one half pepperoni). The cheese sticks and garlic sauce were ALSO excellent!“

“The food is great but theres no indoor dining just 2 chairs for people waiting. The service isn't bad they are just so busy and don't have enough staff. There is always a wait.. I still don't blame staff but the lack of staff.Parking: There's about 10-12 spots but it's for 3 stores. Hard to get in and out.Wheelchair accessibility: It is wheel chair accessible but there's no tables inside just 2 chairs for people waiting for their orders.“

“These guys are awesome if you like pizza customize it best I've had is pan pizza double baked with extra sauce all of the above makes the best pizza. The drivers and cooks know what's up and use the coupons best deal on variety is 20% off all. Friendly staff, great food and consistently bringing it and get this they accept cash and open later than DoorDash win win“

“Great service dining in or delivery. Best pizza in the area fresh or leftover. Great subs and chicken wings/ sides. The most recent time I got food was boneless chicken butter garlic Parmesan. It was fantastic, they actually make themselves and use minced garlic.“

“Ordered ONE whole meatball sub over the phone, for pick up. Had to tell the woman on the phone 2 times..provolone, onions, jalapeños. She then asked if I wanted lettuce and tomato. I said no...just the onions and jalapeños..3rd time. Got the sub home. It was good, except..NO peppers or onions. Otherwise it would have been excellent.“

“First time here and it was great. Got a tray pizza for about $30. Ordered it in advance and it was ready when they said it would be. I was assisted immediately after walking in and I had pizza in my hands within a minute.Great service. Great food. Good prices ?“

“Best Food in the area great service great staff. Thank you Tony, Ed, and everyone else y'all Rock“

“OMG this is the best pizza place in all of Olean, this sliced perfection. Every bite is like tasting a little bit of heaven. Dont miss out by considering this place just get there and eat. Save a few bucks and order yourself a whole pie.Parking: You have all the parking in the world.Kid-friendliness: Right outside the shop the mall has all the quarter machines easy for the young ones to kill a few minutes waiting.“