Peter's Diner


236 Broadway, Amityville
(631) 693-9003


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Peter's Diner

We really enjoyed dining at Peter s Bay Village was a friendly atmosphere and the food is really good.The Staff was very Friendly and makes you feel at Home .though it's a small diner ,their menu had a lot to choose from.Honestly Peter s Bay Village Diner will now be added on my favorite list of Diners in Suffolk County NY. And let's not forget that there's ample Parking Space,Looking forward to once again dine at this location .

Stopped in for dinner with the wife and it was a 50/50 experience. Our waitress was fine but the food and "management " was not. She got the stuffed chicken over rice and she loved it. I had a much simpler meal and no bueno. I order the "buffalo" wings aka buffalo sauce ON my wings but they just put it on the side, wasn't a huge deal but the sauce was ice cold so now I have warm wings dipped in ice cold sauce ‍. Then I ordered a chicken Caesar wrap and fries but yet again full review
My hubby and I went to Pete's diner to try it for the first time. We ordered breakfast. I had fried flounder, grits and eggs with toast. My fish was not seasoned and not crispy. The grits were under cooked and grainy. The eggs were ok. The toast was cold. My hubby ordered the "hungry man" he wasn't pleased. We usually eat at MICHELLE's diner which is about a mile away on rt.110. The food is EXCELLENT there so I guess we're spoiled. Her full review

More Reviews(81)


Monday 7AM - 10PM
Tuesday 7AM - 10PM
Wednesday 7AM - 10PM
Thursday 7AM - 10PM
Friday 7AM - 10PM
Saturday 7AM - 10PM
Sunday 7AM - 10PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.