“These guys are bringing the long Island Diner Back!Food is always goodService is fast and friendly. Owners are great and support the USA and ?♀️,s. Enjoy when we get the waiter with the tattoos on his arm. First you’ll hate him but he’s only playing around.Atmosphere is incredible you have to go on each holiday to see what they do!Passionate business owners!“
“Fantastic service. Beautiful French toast with grilled ham along with an egg white omelet with mushrooms spinach and ham delicious and let's not forget the Delicious Bloody Mary made by Sara .. great service and we were passing through and because of Yelp and its reviews we went .. enjoy !!!“
“Before or after dance class in the morning or early afternoon, the Farmingdale Diner is our 'go to' spot for great food and friendly service! The staff and the owners are amazing. Try their freshly squeezed OJ it is a lovely addition to almost any breakfast.“
“Looks like an older diner, that's been there for yrs. The restaurant was clean and had an old fashion vibe. The waitress was friendly and the food was amazing. Oh and they put a macaroni salad on the table for you to enjoy while waiting for your food. It was so delicious. Not sure what was on the pasta but it was so good. The burgers were huge and the sweet potato fries were also like a double portion in other dinners. Then the dessert was rice pudding, the waitress said that everyone raves about it. Well they were right, it was so creamy.. delish!!! Prices were very reasonable. The only challenging part is the parking lot. It's not very big. But it is so worth a visit. Everything was A++++++“
“For a Long Island diner, it lived up to its expectations. Chef was able to make do with all of my adjustments/substitutions, for example changing an omelette to an egg white omelette. Food came out rather quick. Service was attentive. Very welcoming wait staff as well.“
“First time coming here. Their breakfast was truly great. The Hershey pancakes hit the spot and it was perfectly done. Huevos rancheros burrito and the breakfast dish (eggs/cornbeef hash/home fries) were delicious. We also purchase their peanut butter cheesecake and rainbow cake to take home. I’m not a fan of cheesecake and when I tried it, it blew my mind. (Tasted great!) Rainbow cake was delicious as well! Definitely going back to try out their lunch dishes.“
“I had the pleasure of visiting this diner and was delighted to be greeted warmly upon my arrival. The ambiance was inviting and cheerful, creating a sense of familiarity. The coffee was exceptional, which is uncommon. I typically do not have two cups, but I made an exception here. I ordered the cornbread hash and was thoroughly pleased with its remarkable flavor. My husband had the challah french toast and thoroughly enjoyed it, finishing it entirely. We are eagerly looking forward to our next visit very soon! This diner is so worth it!“
“I live in Brooklyn, NY. However, periodically I will drive 55 minutes just to eat at Nautilus Diner. The food is always delicious, and the service is great. The apple crumb cheesecake is an absolute must. I always feel right at home whenever I'm there.“
“I've been coming here for more than I want to admit and makes me feel old. I'm going to keep this very honest in respect to using common sense/speculation/as well as responding to some of the comments on here. We haven't been there in quite some time...surprised to see the place redecorated. My wife loved it...I understand it. I'm one of those people that walk into a pizzeria and see faded red Formica tables, benches and dated dingy decor as a good thing. I was never bothered by aesthetics as it seems seasoned and perfected like the food im about to indulge in. The old international cafe had a plethora of food, nothing that wow'd you BUT was consistently good even though they had a great variety. The freshly made waffles, variety of gelato and fresh whip cream needs no review. People who complain about noise should just stay home with their mask on. You are talking about an open place restaurant that is a staple of a community for decades. Why in 2024 are people so miserable to see others so happy. Place is jammed back...what do you expect it to sound like? People complaining about kids are the same $hit parents who rather hand their kid a iPad instead of letting them socialize. When we go there we expect it to be busy, loud, kids be kids, great food, great service and pay cash. With new owner ship comes many things and one them was the menu. We were thrown off since we were expecting our usual order. A lot of their items on the menu can be easily replicated at home. When we go out to eat we only order what we don't make for the most part. My wife ordered their Chicken Tenders which was made fresh as they were chicken cutlets cut down. I thought it was OK my wife was not happy bc the crispy bread outside came off the chicken itself. We also got wings and beer battered onion rings. Onion rings were great and wings are wings. We don't deep fry in the house for many reasons...we never ordered anything deep fried at the old spot either. Got their loaded potato skins which my wife enjoyed as well. Reviews about the new whip cream being OFF in taste is correct. Gelato tasted the same to us which was good. Price seemed fair for what we got compared to others places we have gone too. Best of luck to the new owners and staff. I honestly don't think we will be back bc happy wife happy life Our waitress was PHENOMENAL“
“One of my favorite diners on LI and the best in Plainview. Never have been disappointed with any order. Omelettes, paninis, and burgers have all been amazing and are a good portion size. The waiters and staff are always very friendly and welcoming.“
“Awesome diner !! Friendly staff, great service , great food. ! Nice atmosphere. Very clean. Large parking lot. Large menu. I am quite impressed. It’s now my favorite diner !! Highly recommended !!Parking: Large parking lotWheelchair accessibility: There is a ramp for wheelchairs.“
“Went with my gf when we were visiting her parents. I had a turkey club sandwich with fries and she had the Pueblo burrito with homemade chips.Everything was delicious and the server was very pleasant.Parking: More than enough spots for cars“
“Our 1st visit was a pleasant experience doing breakfast. Had the big breakfast ??. My better 1/2 had eggs Benedict & we were very satisfied with the food, service, staff & waitress. Has that classic old school late 80's early 90's diner look with the stainless & mirrors. Some seats have that classic pvt. table jukebox.Parking: Convenient corner diner on Sunrise hwy. svc. Rd.Kid-friendliness: Crayons & pics for the kids to color with. (Upon request)Wheelchair accessibility: Ramp & stairs leading to the main entrance.“
“My favorite diner! Great food at a good price. I have never been disappointed with the food, service, and quality of both. It's very hard to find these things in one place nowadays! Kudos to them for surpassing the traditional standard of diners.“
“We absolutely love the food here. One of the best diner foods you can get. Their seafood is amazing. Their specialty meals come with a soup, salad, two sides, a main course and a dessert usually all for under $35. You can't beat that price and quality of food. They also very fast with pick-up orders. The staff is also supper friendly. Highly recommend“
“Usually the food is pretty good here. The eggs Benedict for breakfast are very good as are the shell steaks for dinner. I was disappointed when I ordered a Ceasar Salad to go. When I opened it there was no cheese. Just a bunch of lettuce and croutons, Not a true Caesar Salad but it was fresh. So many other things to try. Will definitely go back.“
“We live not too far from this diner. I'm originally from NJ so, I when I say I know diners, I mean it! This diner has it all~ fresh baked goods, soups, dinner specials, all day breakfast and assorted platters ranging from gyros, paninis, brick-sized sandwiches and a bunch of seafood dishes also. My husband and I came here for a quick bite after a long day of running errands. He had the bacon, mushroom, jalepenos and cheese burger with a side of huge onion rings. The onion rings, I mean, look at them, they're HUGE, crispy and the onions are fresh. The burger was cooked to order, and they did not skimp on the toppings. There were loads of mushroom, bacon strips and cheese. It was greasy, hot and seasoned perfectly. I, on the other hand, opted for the reuben and it was uh-mazing. Pastrami was not dry, just the right amount of saurkraut, a mountain of yellow mustard (my favorite) accompanied with crispy, salty fries, pickle and creamy coleslaw. Our server was attentive, checked on us to make sure we didn't need anything and service was quick and great every time we've gone. We also regularly order delivery via GH and food always comes piping hot, fresh and delicious. We have relatives that live in Nassau County but they make their way to Suffolk just to go to this diner. They have great breakfast specials that won't be on those delivery apps so, swing by in the morning and check them out. Yelp Elite approved!“
“Been doing food to stomach deposits since I was a child at this great and wonderful establishment ... Pete's is family and actually knows my family... Keep up the amazing work ? with that smiling staff and keep shining on em ?? ... Passing gradeWheelchair accessibility: Definitely wheel chair accessible“