Shuga Pie Shop

Name: Shuga Pie Shop
Address: 135 Deer Pk Ave Unit 3, Babylon, New York, 11702, US
Telephone: (631) 669-1069
Rating: 4.9

Bakery

Hours:
135 Deer Pk Ave Unit 3, Babylon
(631) 669-1069

Order Online

Take-Out/Delivery Options

delivery

Customers' Favorites

Italian Cream Cake Shuga Pie

Cookies & Cream Shuga Pie

Rainbow Cookie Shuga Pie

Vanilla Crumb Shuga Pie

Raspberry Macaroon

Funfetti Shuga Pie

Death by Chocolate

Strawberry Crunch

Blueberry Muffin

Red Velvet Cake

Shuga Pie Shop Reviews

4.9 (36)

Write a review

February 2024

Finally got to stop here today. And let me say…What a treat!!! Taking something classic like a “whoopie pie” and just re-inventing it so damn well!! Moist Cake, creamy delicious filling, not over filled and hard to eat either.! Service was great and fast. It’s just a walk up window with the list of flavors. And as we were leaving with our order more and more people were lining up. Can’t wait to try the other flavors!!!Pictured : funfetti, choc peanut butter and cookies...read full review

January 2024

Stopped by, they do not have a shop it is just a walk up window. The cakes were very good, texture and flavor were good and they have a wide selection. They are basically a flat cupcake. Something different and fun to give as gifts. I will say that I wish that they had bite size options but maybe in the future? They should do well.

January 2024

The absolute best take on a whoopie pie I’ve ever had! Incredible rotating flavors that include seasonal options like pumpkin or smores. Every flavor I’ve had has been delicious. Fresh fruit and crumb topped are some of my favorites. Chocolate Whiskey espresso was pretty amazing. The owners are so kind and inventive. Love stopping anytime we’re in the area. We buy extra and freeze them same day. They stay fluffy when defrosted. Pro tip: You can order bigger ones to replace...read full review

More Reviews(36)