26 Best Italian Restaurants near Baldwinsville

Fireside By The River Italian • $$$
2347 W Genesee Rd, Baldwinsville

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Scallops with Pork Belly
Flourless Chocolate Cake
Steamed Clams
Caesar Salad

“Dined here last evening. The warm brie appetizer was very good and a nice change from ordinary appetizers. The steak was very tender and cooked to perfection. For dessert I had the chocolate torte which came with raspberry sauce. The combination of the chocolate and raspberry....yum! The staff were all nice, friendly, and informative. I'll definitely be back!“

4.6 Superb117 Reviews
Tassone's Wine Garden Italian • $$
8113 Dexter Pkwy, Baldwinsville

Customers` Favorites

Black and Blue Shrimp and Scallops
White Clam Sauce over Linguini
Italian Platter with Chianti
Fried Haddock Sandwich
Spaghetti with Meatball
Crab Stuffed Mushrooms
Chicken Caesar Salad
Chicken Parmigiana
Mozzarella Sticks
Italian Platter

“We were very fortunate to have our Rehearsal Dinner at Tassone’s on 4/11/25. I never did get to thank the owners properly for such a wonderful dinner service. We had 20 people total and not one complaint (even from the 5 young children). The food was exceptional and the portions were huge. Half of us left with leftovers. The staff were so friendly and helped set up a table for us for dessert which they allowed us to bring in. The best part was at the end of service our waitress insisted that she took a picture of all of us before we left. I can’t thank the Tassones enough for such a wonderful experience.“

4.2 Good82 Reviews
Olives Eatery and Two Twisted Sisters American • $
25 Syracuse St, Baldwinsville

Customers` Favorites

Chef's House Made French Onion Gratinee
Italiano and French Onion Soup
Soup of the Day
Chicken Caesar
Mediterranean
Cole Slaw
Warm Orzo
Summer
Hummus
Salad

“I ate there while I visited my son for Thanksgiving. I had a hard time choosing because everything sounded so good. I ended up choosing the Cubby and boy was I happy that I did. It was amazing......no kidding! If I lived there It would be my go to favorite.“

4.9 Superb22 Reviews
Twin Trees Baldwinsville Pizza • $
111 Syracuse St, Baldwinsville

Customers` Favorites

Gourmet Pizza with Garlic Sauce 2 Cheese Mushrooms Roasted Peppers Broccoli
Mozzarella Sticks
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Pizza

“love their pizza. great staff and very kind, great customer service. the best fish. I have tried Atlantic, fish cove, and even the new place in big m mall no place beats twin trees fish for me“

4.6 Superb26 Reviews
Mohegan Manor Restaurant And Banquet Facility American • $$
58 Oswego St, Baldwinsville

Customers` Favorites

Half Rack Lamb Lollipop with a Chimi Churri Sauce or Naked with Potato and Vegetables
Sushi- Rock and Roll California Orange
Caesar or Traditional Salad
Petite Filet Surf N Turf
Manor Burger and Fries
Beef or Chicken Nachos
Chocolate Mousse Cake
Warm Mushroom Salad
Coppola Pinot Noir
Roasted Sea Bass

“Great dinner on Thursday night with my wife. The food is aways excellant and the bar tender Shaun Preble always has excellent menu and drink suggestions.“

4.4 Superb69 Reviews
Pasta's on the Green American • $
1 Village Blvd N, Baldwinsville

Customers` Favorites

Supreme Personal Pizza Rolls
Personal Supreme Pizza Roll
Chicken Wings
Buffalo Wings
Utica Greens
Fish Special

“I had Pasta’s cater a luncheon for my son’s graduation from the police academy and the food was absolutely delicious…. The chicken parm was amazing. I will definitely order from them again! Thank you!“

4.2 Good47 Reviews
Sal's Pizzeria Pizza • $
41 E Genesee St, Baldwinsville

Customers` Favorites

Honey Chipotle Bacon Pizza and Buffalo Wings with Bleu Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana with Rigatoni Pasta
Tortellini Alla Vodka with Chicken
Chicken Wings with Bleu Cheese
12 Weekly Special Pizza
Lasagna & Meatballs
Chicken Wing Pizza
Chicken Sorrentino
Stuffed Meatballs
Wings Were Great

“Crispy crust yet just the right thickness and soft in the middle. Really great pizza. First time we had it. The buffalo chicken wings were absolutely perfect too. Great service and they brought these great big delicious garlic rolls out at the beginning lol. We left stuffed and happy with leftovers for tomorrow. Thank you.“

3.8 Good98 Reviews
Avicolli's Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria Italian • $
7839 Oswego Rd, Liverpool - 5.2 miles

Customers` Favorites

Char Grilled Chicken Wings
Chicken Riggies Alla Vodka
Chicken Riggies Ala Vodka
NY Style Cheese Pizza
Garlic Parmesan Wings
Italian Wedding Soup
Utica Greens Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
French Onion Soup
Tuscan Onion Soup

“Delicious gluten free options. I strongly recommend their gluten free baked ziti (ask for extra cheese) and their gluten free ziti alfredo with chicken.“

4.4 Superb217 Reviews
Santangelo's Restaurant Italian • $$
673 Old Liverpool Rd, Liverpool - 8.23 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Marsala with Sauteed Mushrooms - Choice of Side Dish
Lamb Chops over Burgundy Vine Souce
Veal Parmigiano with Pasta
Amanda-Rin Orange Salad
Grandma's Chicken Soup
Addie Ala Vodka Sauce
Chicken Parmigiano
Eggplant Parmesan
Chicken Abruzzi
Chicken Riggies

“had the seafood boulabaise....nice amount of scallops shrimp and clams...not enough sauce...tasteless couldnt finish leftovers the next day... very nice atmosphere and great service....everyone else in our 10 party group appeared to enjoy their meal.“

4.5 Superb98 Reviews
Rinaldo's Pizzeria & Catering Pizza • $
235 E Main St, Elbridge - 9.99 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Riggies w Garlic Knots & Salad
Nonna's Chicken & Eggplant Parm
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Fried Mushrooms
Chicken Piccata
Chicken Parm
French Fries
Cannoli

“This place is a little hidden gem in Elbridge, NY. If you are a local, I am sure you have tried it and already know how awesome their food is! If you're traveling, make sure to venture over and check them out; you won't be disappointed. Fast, friendly service,, and they prepare some awesome food! The chicken parm is my "go to". Prices are very reasonable, portions are HUGE, all home- made ingredients. You can't go wrong! Delicious!!“

4.8 Superb29 Reviews
Twin Trees Restaurant Italian • $
1100 Avery Ave, Syracuse - 9.78 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sausage and Roasted Red Peppers
Chicken Rigatoni
Pepperoni Pizza
Mushroom Pizza
Buffalo Wings
Stuffed Shells
French Onion
Garlic Pizza
Antipasto
Lasagna

“Always a great choice 👍👍“

4.5 Superb40 Reviews
Mona Lisas Ristorante Italian • $$
Recommended
329 Fay Rd, Syracuse - 10.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken or Veal Parmigiana
Italian Wedding Soup
Mashed Potatoes
Chicken Marsala
Chicken Riggies
Chicken Piccata
Vodka Gnocchi
Eggplant Parm
Baked Ziti
Calamari

“I highly recommend Mona Lisa’s! Service was excellent! We had the meatball riggies, chicken parm and Utica greens. Everything was very flavorful and delicious. It was cooked and prepared perfectly. Their red sauce is wonderful. Would definitely recommend this restaurant to everyone!“

3.7 Good57 Reviews
Amore Pizza & More Pizza • $
659 Old Liverpool Rd, Liverpool - 8.29 miles

Customers` Favorites

Calzone with Extra Ricotta Peppers and Onions Don't Hesitate
NY Style Pizza with Olives Peppers and Onions Perfection
Jumbo Wings with Honey Barbeque Enough Said
Sausage Roll with Peppers and Onions
Cheese Pizza and Buffalo Wings
Bang Bang Chicken Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Logs
Loaded French Fries
Traditional Wings

“Highly recommend, great food and accidentally put wrong topping on my pizza had a new one ready before i could even drive back. Offered me free cooler items for the mishap, new repeat customer now“

4.7 Superb55 Reviews
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Italian • $
4125 NY-31, Clay - 5.58 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken & Shrimp Carbonara
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Stuffed Chicken Marsala
Salad and Breadsticks
Chicken Parmigiana
Eggplant Parmesan
Chicken Alfredo
Minestrone Soup
Seafood Alfredo
Unlimited Soup

“The wait time was over double the estimate, but the wait staff were attentive and met all our needs. The food was good, but I should have stuck to my favorites instead of experimenting. My risk. Overall, it was a good, enjoyable dining experience.

Dietary restrictions: There was a separate gluten free menu which made ordering easy.

Kid-friendliness: There is a children's menu, but the choices are limited in my opinion.“

3.8 Good128 Reviews
Francescas Pizza Pizza • $
207 Oswego St, Liverpool - 7.78 miles

Customers` Favorites

Peter Luger Steak & Cheese Pizza
Fran’S Famous Chicken Riggies
Buffalo Chicken Wing Hawaiian
Margarita and Mushroom Slices
Buffalo Chicken Wing Pizza
Specialty Gourmet Pizzas
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Chicken Riggies Medium
Chicken Parmesan Sub
Chicken Riggie Pizza

“WOW!! what a great surprise. We were getting hail damage repair done next door at Chuck Taylor's Body shop and decided to try Francescas while we waited! Excellent!! Crust is fabulous and they could teach a few places in Utica a thing or too for quality 🍕. Also had teriyaki wings so big and juicy. If you haven't yet, give them a try! Waitstaff super friendly, great food! What are you waiting for???“

4.3 Superb136 Reviews
Il Limone Restaurant Pizzeria Pizza • $$
7421 Oswego Rd, Liverpool - 6.05 miles

Customers` Favorites

Claudio's Classic Lasagna
Eggplant Parmigiana
Shrimp Fra Diavolo
Eggplant Rollatini
Homemade Meatball
Chicken Parm Sub
Fried Mozzarella
Margherita Pizza
Chicken Riggies
Chicken Francese

“I can't say enough about how much we enjoy this restaurant.“

4.3 Superb135 Reviews
Daniella's Fresh Seafood and Pasta House Seafood • $$$
581 State Fair Blvd, Syracuse - 8.47 miles

Customers` Favorites

Surf and Turf with Loaded Potatoes and Delmonico Steak
Stuff 3 Shrimp Stuff with Horseradish & Bacon
Shrimp Scampi Pasta Garlic Cream Sauce
Raw Oysters 1 00 Each on Thursdays
U10 Scallops with Garlic Sauce
French Onion Soup
Divers Scallops
Dynamite Shrimp
Chicken Riggies
Lobster Tail

“So we tried to get crab legs last week (not here) and had one of the absolute worst experiences I've ever had as a guest at a restaurant. Decided to try them at Daniella's this time and they were awesome! We told our waitress about our experience last week and just like we were, she was shocked by how we were treated. She went above and beyond to make our night a great one. At one point her and I were joking about her helping crack them open with me because this girl can out eat the guys when it comes to crab legs 🤷🏻‍♀️ lol and a few minutes later she actually pulled up a chair, put on some gloves and said let's do this!! Amanda at Daniella's seafood, you were absolutely amazing!! Thanks for making our night a fantastic one!!“

4.2 Good177 Reviews
Bianchi's Catering & Pizza Pizza • $
2623 Milton Ave, Syracuse - 8.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

Breafast Pizza Half Bacon and Sausage Pizza
Caprese Skewer with Balsamic Pipette
Garlic Pizza Pick-Up Only
Chicken Wings by 10's
Family Lasagna Dinner
Honey Fried Chicken
Chicken Francaise
Breakfast Pizza
Antipasto Salad
Pizza and Wings

“We used Bianchi's Catering for our Holiday Party and we couldn't have asked for anything more. Everything was hot and delicious or cold and delicious. Our menu was varied and everyone was happy. We would recommend Bianchi's Catering to anyone who'll listen!“

4.1 Good67 Reviews
OIP-Original Italian Pizza Pizza • $
408 Oswego St, Liverpool - 7.57 miles

Customers` Favorites

Honey Garlic Chicken Wings
Charbroiled Chicken Wings
Pepperoni Pizza

“Spent 3o.oo for pizza and wings.The pizza bottom was burnt to the point that it couldn't be eaten The wings were also so well done couldn't eat them.It was like some one forgot about them.Last chance for this place been burned too many times.“

4 Good42 Reviews
Cam's Pizza Camillus NY Pizza Delivery • $
112 Kasson Rd Unit 50, Camillus - 8.74 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pizza Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza
Half Pepperoni and Cheese Pizza
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Cannoli Siciliani
Chicken Tenders
Garlic Bread

“Friends...Fun.....Feasting...Za!!!“

4 Good47 Reviews
Twin Trees 57 Pizza • $
7608 Oswego Rd, Liverpool - 5.59 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Riggies
Antipasto Salad
Chicken Wings
Boneless Wings
French Onion
Cheese Pizza
Medium Pizza
EBA Pizza
Sausage

“The service was incredible, the food was delicious, the atmosphere was ethereal, our server was both caring and hilarious, the owner actually came out to make sure everything was too our liking, and the prices were unbelievably low. I couldn’t recommend it more. Did I mention how great the food was?“

4 Good50 Reviews
Pies Guys Pizza • $$
8075 Oswego Rd, Liverpool - 4.93 miles

Customers` Favorites

Baked Lasagna Pizza
Ten Boneless Wings
Garlic Lovers Pizza
Bread Bowl Salads
5 Chicken Tenders
Grilled Chicken
Pepperoni Pizza
14 Medium Pizza
16 Large Pizza
Haddock Dinner

“This was my first time ordering char grilled wings from here and thought the girl in back who made them did a phenomenal job. Perfect amount of char and the flavor toss was spot on. Please let her know this and to not change a thing, she’s a keeper for sure. I’ll definitely be back for more I just hope it’s a night when she’s there. Good jobs pies guys and way to go wing girl!!!!“

3.8 Good22 Reviews
Euclid Restaurant Family • $
4285 NY-31, Clay - 6.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Broiled Seafood Platter
Bacon Wrapped Scallops
Chicken and Biscuits
Fried Haddock Dinner
Hot Turkey Sandwich
French Onion Soup
Mashed Potatoes
Broiled Haddock
Fried Chicken
Fried Haddock

“Wow! The Chicken Riggies were incredible- I did order standard and they had the perfect kick. Had plenty of chicken and slivers of cherry peppers- loved this. Thank you for a delicious dinner that was also my lunch. Thank you, chef. I’ll be back and will order these again next time. Recommended, great service at the bar- the Genny Citrus Pils was also perfection.“

3.8 Good76 Reviews
Twin Trees Too Family • $
1029 Milton Ave, Syracuse - 9.87 miles

Customers` Favorites

Kid's Mini Cheese Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Wings
Large Cheese Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Antipasto Salad
Chicken Riggies
Gourmet Pizza
Caesar Salad
House Salad
Lasagna

“Rented the party room for a Celebration of Life. The staff (kudos to Jill) was awesome. The food kept coming out for all three hours fresh. They handled everything perfectly and professionally. And the bill was very reasonable. Thanks so much!!!!“

3.6 Good75 Reviews
Gino & Joe's Pizza Liverpool Pizza • $
700 Old Liverpool Rd, Liverpool - 8.15 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Wings with Your Favorite Sauce
Chicken Wings Split Order with 2 Sauces
Gino & Joe's Special Steak Sub
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Spaghetti with Meatballs
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Grandma Deep Dish 16
Cannoli and Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Sicilian Pizza

“We had an event for our HS kids, from our of the area. Gino & Joe's was excellent at accommodating us. 25 delicious pies. Fast service and really nice staff. For an order this size, they did not compromise on quality. Every source was great! Thank you!“

3.5 Good66 Reviews
Gino & Joe's Pizza Pizza • $$
4160 NY-31, Clay - 5.59 miles

Customers` Favorites

Neapolitan Cheese Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Chicken Parmigiana
Eggplant Rollatini
Veggetarian Pizza
Breakfast Pizza
Chicken Riggies
Antipasto Salad
Valentine Pizza
Slices of Pizza

“Just got our first take out large pizza with wings! Pizza was outstanding! We got half cheese and half pepperoni and onion. Cook to perfection and very cheesy which is what we love. Wings were very good as well,. Price was great compared to other places and the food was better so all in all I would strongly recommend anyone that wants pizza and wings to go to Gino and Joe's on Route 31!!!!!“

3.1 Average64 Reviews

You May Also Like