29 Best Caterers near Bayville

“We celebrated our daughters quinceañera @soundview caterers and we are so grateful to Diego for his service, support and hospitality. Diego played a key role in making sure everything was taken care of. We are also thankful to Brittany who helped us in the beginning of the process and then to Patricia who helped us at the end. Thank you to all the staff that was so gentle to our guests during the event. I recommend Soundview 100% Thank you!“

“Food is delicious! Would recommend the sautéed chicken, sea scallop risotto, linguine bolognese, marinated skirt steak, homemade mac and cheese or the buttermilk chicken sandwich. Unique dessert option that the kids loved was campsite s'mores where they can roast marshmallows at the table with a personal little fire. Service was friendly and knowledgeable. Overall atmosphere was nice with larger parties able to be accommodated in a larger, brighter room while main dining room was more cozy with smaller booths/tables and darker ambiance. Parking is tight, but there is a larger municipal lot across the street. Can't wait to go back!“

“You won't find a better seafood restaurant on Long Island and you can include the Jersey Shore. Just go down the menu ..... All Fantastic!!! Don't forget to hear the Specials for the Evening. "Over the Top" Dining Experience. You're will LOVE IT !!“

“I went there for my cousin’s wedding. Beautiful venue. Very spacious and on the lake. Very scenic. The food was delicious. The staff was great and friendly.“

“THE Royalton Mansion-- If I could rate them 10 stars I would! The best kept secret on Long Island. The most beautiful venue with such a care for detail with the best bang for your buck with pricing. From the day we had our first meeting with the Royalton they have been fantastic and after my Husband and I walked in the first time we knew it was where we were supposed to be married. Mike T and his entire staff were perfect. Their attention to detail is unmatched. Mike T told me we didn’t need a wedding planner or coordinator with them and he was right. He took his role above and beyond! Every question and pre-wedding concern I had was answered quickly and ever worry I had they calmed my fear. The food was amazing and every aspect of the menu completely customizable. We had so many dietary restrictions and Mike was able to accommodate everyone without any issues. The grounds are beautiful both inside and outside. We planned for our ceremony to be in their beautiful garden but unfortunately mother nature had other plans and the move to inside was still as beautiful. Our family and friends are still raving about how beautiful it was, how amazing the food was and how the staff were phenomenal. Michelle, the bridal attendant was also phenomenal and helped the day run so smoothly! We had an unfortunate incident thar required a guest to be removed from the wedding. The professionalism and approach that Mike T took to handle the situation was perfect to the point that I had no idea of the circumstance and to those involved were blown away on how well it was handled by himself and staff and to ensure all our guests were safe as well. I can not recommend The Royalton enough.“

“Whitby Castle is the absolute best & most perfect place for a wedding & we very highly recommend it as your wedding venue! My partner and I got married in March 2024 on a Saturday afternoon at Whitby Castle in Rye, NY, and it was better than we ever could have imagined thanks to the breathtaking venue and all of the amazing managers and staff at Whitby. My partner and I looked at about 10 wedding venues in the Tri-state area before finding Whitby Castle, and the minute we saw it, we knew we had to get married there. It blew all of the other venues out of the water, in so many distinctive facets. The first thing that brought us to Whitby was the gorgeous castle and grounds (flawlessly manicured lawns right on Rye Golf club and striking views of the Long Island Sound), and how the venue provided a plethora of accommodations for whatever season or weather you may have on your wedding day. The next thing that brought us in was the wedding package they offered for dates outside of the wedding season (ours was the end of March). The wedding package included everything we needed, outside of a few upgrades we added on later, and was the best price for all of the options we got. We could not find a better price anywhere for the number of options, vendors or amenities that their wedding package contained. Before ultimately deciding on Whitby Castle as our wedding venue, we attended their quarterly wedding showcase that provided samplings of all of the cocktail hour foods the venue provides, as well as the ability to meet a ton of potential vendors for all of the other factors of the wedding weekend. The showcase event was excellent and not something we saw any other venue provide. It gave us a one-stop shop to help find our vendors, and even better that it was vendors that work at Whitby on a regular basis. Additionally, the cocktail hour food was delicious, and we knew the entrées and other course options were going to be even better. After we saw all of this, we knew for certain that Whitby was our venue, and it only got better from here. We booked Whitby Castle as our venue over a year before the wedding date and from our first meeting with Niki, the Catering Sales Manager at Whitby, we knew we had without a doubt made the right choice. Niki handled just about everything with the venue throughout the process including catering, vendors, amenities and all of the options available to us through Whitby. Niki took the time to get to know us and offered a wide variety of options for the ceremony, cocktail hour and reception, as well as anything else we were thinking of. Niki thoroughly explained the numerous elements to consider when planning our wedding, what we did or did not need, or what we may have missed or forgot, and she helped us get to where we needed to be in the planning process. Since our first meeting with Niki, she made us feel as if she genuinely cared about us and our wedding (because she did), as well as the different ideas we had. We worked with Niki for over a year and half, and she made everything so easy for us during that time. Niki managed all of these points with us until it was time to meet with the operations manager and maître d', which happens around a month before the wedding day. We would later meet with the Operations Manager, Ralph, about three weeks before the wedding day and he was just as awesome. Ralph had all of the particulars laid out for every aspect of our wedding and provided a comprehensive timeline and wedding plan to us. Niki and Ralph were not only incredibly professional and knowledgeable, but also exceedingly responsive and accommodating to what we needed and wanted for our wedding. Niki and Ralph were both always accessible throughout the entire process when helping us manage, coordinate and deliver our ideal wedding. They also made the process of meeting and maintaining communication with them easy and convenient. Since we booked our wedding 18 months in advance for the end of March, we had no idea what weather we were going to have, but it was honestly not even t“

“El pollito esta muy delicious“

“Great bagels and coffee“

“We had my daughter’s high school graduation party here and it was such a success!! Raj made the party planning process so smooth and easy and we weren’t worried about anything going wrong. He went above and beyond in making everything easier for us in every way. The venue was decorated absolutely beautifully. From the stage setup to the backdrop to the table centerpieces, everything was wonderful. All the guests could not stop commenting upon how gorgeous everything was. The food was also very good! Everyone had such a good time and talked so highly of the event. I can’t recommend Metropolitan Caterers enough; they made our celebration of this event so special!!“

“We recently had team lunch here and everyone enjoyed the authentic Mediterranean food.
All platters were more than enough for 1 person.
Mixed grilled had lots of of meats options.
Special lunch $17 per person.
Includes gyro, salad and a dip with pita.

Chicken Gyro was well seasoned.
Baba ganush was ok
Spicy feta was delicious
Very friendly staff.
Highly recommend!!“

“food is always fresh, great costumer service, and everyone is always so kind. The service is fast and I always get my food order correctly!!“

“We just had Susan and her team cater and plan a family party last weekend. Not only was the food unique, delicious and tasty, but Susan and her team were incredibly professional, responsive, accommodating, and just overall amazing and a pleasure to work with. She was enthusiastic, wonderful, and the menu was perfect. The food was delicious (and I’m a tough critic), her team was wonderful, and it was a fantastic experience. I would recommend her without hesitation. She deserves a special shout out for accommodating our last minute family party and being so attentive and purposeful. The food was fresh, innovation, and delicious. Can’t wait to use Susan again in the future!!“

“Noguet coliflor y las ensaladas“

“my experience has always been satisfying. reasonably priced. always delivered hot . Not a wrong order yet. 🙏😇👣🦅✌️“

“My mom threw my baby shower at her home this past weekend. During the planning process we reached out to the world of Facebook for recommendations. We heard the culinary studio mentioned multiple times so we went with them. We are so glad we did. The food was incredible. The staff was perfect and not overbearing at all. They maybe had one or two questions for us at the beginning and then let my mom and I just enjoy the party. Everyone raved about the quality of the food, and they were right, it was delicious. When they were done the leftovers were packed away and ready for us to continue to enjoy the next day. Thank you for making my shower a day I will never forget.“

“Outstanding - both the food and staff.
Menus - Jonathan, the owner, comes up with perfect menus to fit any occasion.
Staff - incredibly hard working that seamlessly pull of small intimate dinners to large backyard tented events.“

“Amazing, great tasting food....restaurant quality! Ordered catering for our Easter celebration and everything from BelleFair Kitchen was just perfect! Easy to order, great delivery service and again delicious food! Will definitely use again and highly recommend!“

“Sal at Basil and Prime isn’t just making sandwiches—he’s creating edible masterpieces. This man is the heartbeat of Mineola’s finest Italian deli, and let me tell you, his skills in the kitchen and at the counter are unmatched.

From the moment I walked in, Sal’s impeccable customer service made the experience unforgettable. (He’s pretty hot too) (i hope he’s single) He greeted me with the kind of warmth and enthusiasm that instantly made me feel like family. Somehow, he juggled a line of hungry customers, grilled paninis, wrapped sandwiches, and restocked the fresh mozzarella—all while cracking jokes and giving each person his undivided attention. It was like watching a maestro conduct an orchestra of meats, cheeses, and condiments.

Now let’s talk about his sandwiches. Sal doesn’t just layer cold cuts—he builds culinary symphonies. My turkey, provolone, and roasted red pepper wrap was so perfectly balanced, it brought tears to my eyes. The mayo and mustard ratio? Absolute perfection. And don’t even get me started on the crispy chicken cutlets. Every bite was like a love letter to Italian food.

But Sal’s skills don’t stop at sandwiches. His quick wit and humor elevate the experience to another level. One time, after handing me the most beautiful chicken parm hero I’ve ever seen, he said, “Careful—this sandwich might make you come back tomorrow.” Spoiler alert: I couldn’t wait to return.

Sal is a deli icon, a customer service superstar, and the reason I’ll keep coming back to Basil and Prime every chance I get. If you haven’t had the privilege of meeting Sal and tasting his creations, you’re missing out on one of life’s greatest pleasures. Sal, you’re a legend—never change.

Here’s to more Salwiches!“

“1st time going today. It was well worth the stop. I had the half rack will pulled pork and Mac and cheese. It was splendid. Exceeded my expectations. I'm so glad Glen Cove now has our own BBQ spot! I will be a regular“

“Super busy place but so worth it !! So many options, fresh food, tasty food, everything is labeled and easy to order once you have someone helping you. So many different stations to order food from, sandwiches, smoothies, salads, dessert. Small area to eat in and one bathroom. There is always someone cleaning up the tables which is nice.“

“Fantastic from beginning to end! Walked in on a busy night, and was quickly greeted with a smile and positivity. The owner (i believe) was there helping her staff tend to the crowd.
I asked about private catering and she was super helpful and provided me with information during the rush as well. Couldn’t recommend it more, love Ben and Jerry’s and this location!“

“Now they deliver! Check out their website!“

“This place has the best food, period!As good as the food is, nothing compares to their soups. Chicken, Vegetable, Pea, lentil. The soups are the best tasting soup I have ever had. I know that might sound extreme, but it is True!! I hope this review is helpful.“

“There appears to be new management and staff and this represents a major improvement. We stopped going to this eatery a year ago because of how poorly it was run. We finally decided to give it another chance and we're thrilled to see it being run by a new team. Keep up the great work.“

“Wonderful Thanksgiving meal! Thank you !“

“great quality kosher food“

“Best BLT! Super delicious food and great service!“

“In my short experience here, the staff were very kind and patient to recommend their best sellers and the food didn’t disappoint!
I got Danny’s Famous Chicken — this was an interesting combo with ranch, Cajun chicken cutlet and avocado, and bacon that magically worked for my taste“