50 Best Mexican Restaurants near Bethpage

“good food , quick service“

“I had a delightful dining experience with a party of seven at a Mexican restaurant in Bethpage. The restaurant's ambiance was exceptional and the food was both delicious and fresh. The service was top-notch, with attentive staff promptly clearing our table and offering us additional drinks. I would highly recommend this restaurant and look forward to visiting again.

Parking: It's a freestanding building with its own parking lot, providing plenty of parking.“

“Food was outstanding, just finished my meal and had to write a review. Hidden gem as another said. Probably ordering again Sunday.“

“Very nice inviting decor. Service was just ok. The server was basic, didn’t tell us it was happy hour? Nor did she mention and food selections. For a new establishment I guess I was expecting a bit more … maybe ask if we had been there before? Check back to see how our food was( it was outstanding), we got more help from the water girl Had to ask to clear table. Had to ask for check from the water girl? The server had much support. Seems she took our order and disappeared. But the server assistants were on point. Dinner was really good. We will go back… because of the food. Even the manager walked pasted us a dozen times. There were 6 tables.. perfect time for manager to mingle… just saying. Place is very nice, great menu too. Just left feeling ignored. Nice music too. Maybe the server was having a bad day? Like I said we will go again !!! Great food.“

“Ordered in and got two avocado bowls. The portions were great and the food was very flavorful. Highly recommend the steak and chicken combo on their avocado bowls. Will definitely be back“

“Amazing and deliciously 🤤 addictive . The fundito with chorizo is so good !!!“

“The food and drinks were delicious! I encourage you to visit and order with an open mind. Don’t expect the flavors to match what you’re used to because they won’t. The service was great, and we truly felt this is a place where we’d love to just relax and hang out.“

“We came here on a thurs even around 6pm...Was pretty crowded but got a table in the middle..The sound level is pretty high at 3/4 capacity but somehow you seem to flow with it because of the atmosphere... People enjoying good mex food are more enjoyable to be around for some reason..anyway...lighting as with most place is difficult to read menu but once the order was in,alot of fun...I noticed the food to be very FRESH...I immediately tasted that in the beans on my Mexican special and the Flautas,chimichanga etc were all delicious stuffed and perfectly cooked!..Fajita steak was so nicely marinated and charred but med inside..Perfect!..Wait staff were all very pleasant....I enjoyed my visit and will defin visit during a slow day,maybe lunch for a lil more quiet....“

“Enjoyed brunch today w/ my daughter we both enjoyed everything!!! Definitely going back the horchata was AMAZING!! So was the service !“

“Have ordered many times from Ole’s. The food is delicious and service friendly and warm. Today, decided to eat in so we could try the nachos crispy and warm in the store. They were amazing!!! The other items were also great, my kids loved all of it. At the end, we had a chance to meet one of the owners, Manny. He was very friendly and warm, chatted with my boys and then surprised them with a warm churro. Needless to say, we’ll be coming back even more frequently now. Yum yum yum.“

“We just ordered here for the first time and the food was amazing ! The grilled buffalo chicken wrap was delicious! The breaded buffalo chicken wrap and avocado corn salad were huge hits as well.“

“great food, fun atmosphere and great music!“

“I wanted to express my sincere appreciation for the wonderful experience I had at your restaurant today.

Our waiter, David, was incredibly attentive and helpful throughout our meal. His drink suggestions were excellent, and he truly enhanced our dining experience.

The food was absolutely delicious and fresh, and the beautiful and welcoming atmosphere of the restaurant made for a truly enjoyable visit. All of your staff were very friendly, contributing to a fantastic experience.

I look forward to dining with you again soon and maybe having a family gathering!“

“If you want authentic great Mexican Food & Drink.. Ruta Oaxaca is the best ! Great service , friendly staff and great variety.“

“Restaurante familiar, Rica comida 🌮“

“awesome menu items great service“

“Right Coast Taqueria provided our lunch for our Teacher Appreciation week in Smithtown. The faculty raved about the food and presentation!! They accommodated food allergies. Great business to work with!!“

“Its not the regular-cheap price Mexican restaurant, but the food is really good and the restaurant is beautiful. The frozen margaritas are excellent! Good portion of food and drink and we had the lucky day of going when the margaritas were buy one and get one free !!!! Wednesdays! Guava and passion fruit were my choices! To eat i had birria quesadilla and sweet plantains. In the picture there's the plantains and my husband's fajitas“

“Went on a Tuesday night and I loved the surf and turf tacos. So much flavor and it was made with steak and shrimp.

Listen the service was so fast. The drinks were great, nice vibe and the music was very mixed and nice from hiphop, reggae and Latin music.

The staff were friendly and attentive. The hookah was so smooth and reasonable price.“

“Great place Gentlemen with glasses and hat backwards was awesome. Great portions very flavorful. Will be back.“

“My family and I went here after going to the LIChildren’s Museum. The food was delicious, the portions were huge, and the prices were fair. The guy taking care of us was super nice to my young kids, and the murals on the walls were fun to talk about. We’ll be back the next time we go to Museum Row!“

“Picked up lunch and it was delish!!! Thank you!!! Queso is fantastic!“

“Buena comida las muchachas muy atentas se los recomiendo“

“Great place Gentlemen with glasses and hat backwards was awesome. Great portions very flavorful. Will be back.“

“Absolutely Outstanding Experience at Fat Boy Burrito Commack! If I could give Fat Boy Burrito in Commack more than five stars, I absolutely would! From the moment my husband and I walked in, we were greeted with the most welcoming and friendly atmosphere. The energy of the place is incredible, and you can tell right away that this is more than just a restaurant—it’s a place where customers truly matter. Now, let’s talk about the food—WOW! Every bite was an explosion of flavor. The burritos were packed with fresh, high-quality ingredients, perfectly seasoned, and crafted with care. You can tell they put real thought into their menu, ensuring every item is packed with bold, delicious flavors. The portions? Generous. The quality? Top-notch. This is hands-down the best burrito spot we’ve ever been to! But what really set this experience apart was the incredible customer service, especially from the owner, Tony. He personally took the time to come over and chat with us, making us feel like family. It’s rare to see an owner so involved and genuinely invested in their customers’ experiences. Tony’s passion for his restaurant and his customers shines through in everything he does. He made sure we were happy with our meal, shared some great conversation, and left a lasting impression that will keep us coming back again and again. If you’re looking for phenomenal food, exceptional service, and an owner who truly cares, look no further than Fat Boy Burrito in Commack. Tony and his team have created something special here, and I can’t recommend it highly enough! We will definitely be back—again and again!“

“Excellent meal and wait staff“

“It’s a small local place for a quick Mexican - no table service, just order at counter and use the table/seating to eat on your own. Not much for ambiance but great for takeouts. Food is fresh and good and reasonable. They have self serve sauces from mild to hot. Horchata is great.“

“Best Delivery Food Around! Food is always hot, delivery is extremely quick, people are great and the food is the BEST!!!!“

“Love the food obviously 🙄 love the location delicious 😋“

“Writing a good review I am running the risk the place will get crowded and I will not be able to get a table. Excellent authentic food, very good cocktails, friendly service, Mexico-like atmosphere, very reasonable prices. The staff makes you feel at home from the minute you walk in. Cannot wait to return.“

“Had amazing cinco de Mayo!! Thanks for the t shirts ! Great service great food best drinks and beyond great dessert.“

“I love this place. The food is so Fresh and Delicious and most importantly consistent. The owner and staff are very accommodating and there are plenty of Veg. Options.“

“#1 most important thing for me is cleanliness if i dont see them using gloves or if they operate the register then serve you the food thats a big no no for me. But none of that was going on they are clean! They have lime and steak, pretty good little spicy. I get the cilantro rice in a bowl 🥣 with toppings extra cilantro steak and some chicken. You know I need me some protein. Children meal includes juicy box and 2 adult bowls like 30 bucks split the boll and you have an awesome deal, lol. Lines are short but when it gets busy it moves fast. Can't tell you the condition of the bathrooms, though never had to use them. You can dine outside they play music . It's safe area and when your done you can hit up Starbucks, it works out. Good management I'm sure.“

“I had stopped coming here for a long time as The kids working here had a very bad habit of shaking all the food off the spoon sort of like chipotle does now. I recently gave it another try, and I have to say the food was prepared Generously, the place was very clean, and the service, unlike before was now friendly. The place is under new management, her name is Vilma and she has turned this place around. Better food, better portions and great service for much less money than lousy Taco Bell.“

“Kitchen open till 2am great eats and atmosphere“

“Went in for the first time on Friday and the food was fresh, homemade and delicious. They were very nice and welcoming. We went back tonight and once again they were helpful in what to order. The food was the same delicious and homemade. The salsa… just yummy!! Highly recommend.“

“This place was great I tried it today and i had no complaints what so ever, I’ve read the reviews and honestly i think it’s the customers who last out on the resturant for not telling the resturant how they want it because the service here is amazing from the cooks down to the front desk workers, when i requested a specific order to be chosen to my liking they went through with it. I would recommend this again and again, Amazing resturant“

“I moved away from LI and I think about this place allllll the time. The tacos are so juicy and delicious. I really miss it and next time I visit I'm def ordering some food from there!! I can't wait 😂“

“Love it there always a good time“

“The food is really 5 star, except that it is a little spicy. Most of the dressings, plus the guac and other items have a touch more jalapeño than I would prefer...but the quality and variety are GREAT!

Vegetarian options: I'm actually vegan and love the options! I just wish they were a smidge less spicy!“

“I’m obsessed with the new team at Nelly’s. Alba and her team are whipping up delicious food that we can’t get enough of. If you’re looking for well made Mexican, you have to give Nelly’s a shot.“

“Excellent service! Welcoming, clean, nice vibe and atmosphere! I will definitely return plenty more times!!!“

“We came for Sunday brunch. The food was delicious. The drinks were just on par and we had to deep fried ice cream for dessert. Everything was great will be back again.“

“1st time at Margaritas, and I loved it. The service was amazing. Staff so friendly and shared jokes with us. I ordered the Jalapeno margarita... My favorite drink, and it was so delicious, and my meal was the 3 tacos platter. The steak was so delicious. We also order the guacamole and it was made to perfection right at our table. I also loved how the staff even came out celebrating a patrons birthday with a song. Definitely coming back. Next time with hubby for date night ? “

“The best place for Mexican food. The guys that run the place are top notch.“

“The food was great. Great seasoning on everything. Mashed yukka was a little salty but very tasty. When I first walked in, I was passed by several people with no acknowledgment, I finally asked someone if I sat myself, and she guided me to a table. After that everything was fine. Waitress was very attentive and personable. The food was awesome. I will definitely return with friends.“

“My burrito was the size of a 10 pound baby. All of the food was delicious! 🤤“

“Been going to Moes on Tuesday nights with the family for a really long time now. My Kids now eat adult meals but it's still a tradition. Great Food, Great Service, and really Great Times. Everything is always fresh and delicious.“

“Great Food, exceptional service and margaritas to die for! Our group of four has been dying to find a good Mexican restaurant (we have tried many)and 5 De Mayo did not disappoint. From our server, to our "Guacamole Girl" to the owner Roberto who came to our table to check in and offer dessert and/or a shot (free of charge), we could not have found a better hidden gem. We will not have to try another Mexican Restaurant as long as 5 De Mayo is around!“

“First time there and the food and the staff were great. Bear tacos and the margaritas were excellent. Definitely will be back.“