Restaurants near Big Indian

“Came here for my birthday dinner on monday night with two friends. Having a culinary background. I always enjoy trying places with fresh, unique, seasonal menus. Not only was this restaurant all of the above but they actually changed their menu daily. The flavor profile of each dish was perfectly balanced and unique. Everything was cooked to absolute perfection. The service was also top notch. Our server, the hostess and everyone who passed our table was extremely accommodating. This was an amazing experience and I'm so happy I got to do it for my birthday. I highly, highly recommend going here.”

“This Amazing off the beaten path gem ,With Delicious homemade Food and Desserts , History, Lovely staff , and Fun game room , Epic Historic bowling Alley was the Perfect find to complete our Adventuring ,No run of the mill boring burgers and fries here!!!Just Absolutely Charming in every single way ?”

“Every beer is 10/10 and if you're an ipa fan you can't miss this spot. The food is also very good. Staff are attentive and knowledgeable. Industrial chic ambiance. Great location.”

“Very welcoming diner! The owners run a tight ship, everything seems so organized for a diner. The kitchen is open so you can see through if you sit at the counter and its weirdly quiet and smooth sailing despite the many orders passing through.Overall, the food was good! Some lacked a wow factor in flavor but still good and the serving size is huge! Fresh ingredients, great coffee, the best orange juice! It can get a little pricey but definitely worth it!”

“Where to begin? This spot blew my expectations out of the water. My boyfriend and I shared their broccoli and potato soup, with their house made bread.We also had the infamous roasted eggplants sandwich which melted in your mouth, with the crunch of the bread and the gorgeous San Marzano tomato sauce. Even the salad was perfectly dressed and so fresh.I had their peach fizz mocktail, fresh peach nectar, raspberry juice, so delicious.We will definitely be back and highly recommend this spot to anyone and everyone!”

“WOW! I feel like this pizza spot was transplanted from Brooklyn! Everything we ordered was stellar. The grandma pizza is one of the best I had, exploding with flavor Garlic knots are soft and chewy in the middle. Onteora hot hero with grilled chicken, mozzarella, pesto, pepper with perfectly toasted bread. Loaded waffle fries crispy. I'm shocked this amazing eatery is located in such a remote area. HIGHLY recommend!”

“Great little place. We were there 30 minutes before opening and the lady let us in anyway. She was running back AND front of house. She had the bar, our table, and cooked our food because the server wasn't in yet. We sat by the fireplace. The pizza was delicious. The only thing was the country music. Awful. Lol.”

“Cutest little coffee shop with all day breakfast and amazing lunch options.I literally dream about the chicken sandwich and french fries.My partner and I make a few trips up to the Catskills every year and we cannot pass without stopping. Highly recommend!”

“Tito’s is a good spot! Liam is the man, always helps you quickly. The burrito was delicious, the jalepeno pineapple marg was everyone’s favorite.Unfortunately no coors- but that’s okay.”

“Remains one of our favorites. Generous portions and great quality food at prices that don't insult you. You cannot beat the magical scenic location. Love this place!!!”

“Dropped in for a quick dinner while we’re in town for the weekend and we loved it! Plenty of seating, quick and courteous service, delicious food, and fair pricing. We tried two of their specials and a large tomato garlic basil pizza (added red sauce). Definitely recommend going if in the area!”

“My wife and I loved an affordable, comfy, and clean place to stay while we skied at Belleayre. Coffee in the AM was great and were total coffee snobs! We used to frequent this area several years ago and a few things have since closed down, meaning you’ll need to drive over to Arkville for general supplies. Most places nearby seemed to open around 8am and close on the earlier side. Although we visited during the week and saw that they would make you breakfast on the weekend.Expect traditional Catskills lodging.We’ve eaten at the tavern in the past and it was great. Didn’t make it on our last visit.”

“We has a large thin crust pizza , and a pecan salad ! Absolutely outrageous, the pizza was better then we have ever had ! Peacan salad was fantastic, oh and not to mention the service is impeccable.”

“We were in the area to ski at Belleayre, and there were not a lot of dining options on a Monday night. We chose La Cabana because it has a bar... the classic margarita on the rocks was perfect. We started with chips and salsa, which were very fresh. We both had the same entree, the vegetarian combination. It was tasty, plenty to eat and very reasonable, though I prefer regular beans to refried beans on the side. The ambiance was so-so, kind of a large bland room, but there was a big wood stove cranking out some welcome heat. The server was very pleasant. Happy we found this place and we'd visit again.”

“Visited while on weekend getaway with wife. Atmosphere was great, service was also very good and friendly. I ordered the tomahawk steak cooked rare, it care with broccoli rabe and potatoes. It was one of best steaks I have ever eaten! Drinks were also great and waitress was super friendly. We had a great time and will be back when in area again!”