New American Restaurants near Big Indian, NY

Peekamoose Restaurant American • $$$
8373 NY-28, Big Indian

Customers` Favorites

Catskills Farmers' Vegetable \u0026 Grain Plate
Oven Roasted Wild Striped Bass
Roasted Butternut Squash Soup
Slow Braised Beef Short Ribs
Warm Chocolate Chip Cookies
Wood Grilled Sirloin Steak
Fruition Chocolate Pudding
Pan Roasted Arctic Char
Caramelized Onion Tart
Buttermilk Panna Cotta

“We live about an hour away but it is ALWAYS worth the trip. ALWAYS. Sadly we only get to visit once a year. Great food. Great service. Cool atmosphere. Owners / Managers who “work the room” to ensure satisfaction. Love it!“

4.6 Superb427 Reviews
Dandelion - Restaurant New American • $$$
212 McKenley Hollow Road, Big Indian

Customers` Favorites

Dry Aged Pork Chop
Half Chicken
Salad

“We enjoyed our stay at Eastwind and frequently ordered from Dandelion bar, snack foods, and also had RSVP for dinner.
The bartender and staff are professional, kind, and well trained. Michaela (Mikayla) knew all classic cocktails off the menu and prepared and served them as expected.
This place has best and unique Onion Rings in my opinion as snack. I like the fact that the dinner menu is also short but every thing is healthy, tasty, and well thought.
Although they had ran out of rice and some other vegetables, our server suggestions for substitutes were very helpful and didn’t impact the experience of original dishes.
I observed that Hen dish is most popular and many were ordering this dish, but we had Cucumber Peanut salad, curry style stew (Fish) and Hanger Steak and very content.“

4.2 Good53 Reviews
Pine Hill Arms Hotel Bar • $$
286 Main Street Suite 288, Pine Hill - 2.85 miles

“The restaurant and the comfy bed was the best part of our stay!! I will admit it’s my fault I didn’t notice that it stayed that all room are on the 2nd and 3rd floors but their stairs are insanely narrow. We chose the double room and that’s pretty much what it was…. A double bed with a sink and an end table. Then what looked to be an old closet was the shower and toilet. The whole room was at a slant and to sit on the toilet was very tight to say the least as well as the toilet having the same lean. Again, the bed was super comfy and my hubby and I were forced to chat as there wasn’t a tv in our room oh, and no phone. The walls are paper thin as you could hear the people not only talking next to us but below us too! We are at the restaurant downstairs which was amazing and if you’ve had the fried chicken, I don’t need to say anymore, it’s fantastic! The lady that checked us in was nice also. I will make sure to read all amenities and look more closely at room pictures.“

3.7 Good27 Reviews