New American Restaurants near Big Indian, NY

Peekamoose Restaurant American • $$$
8373 NY-28, Big Indian

Customers` Favorites

Oven Roasted Wild Striped Bass
Roasted Butternut Squash Soup
Slow Braised Beef Short Ribs
Warm Chocolate Chip Cookies
Fruition Chocolate Pudding
Wood Grilled Sirloin Steak
Pan Roasted Arctic Char
Roasted Beet 'Tartare'
Buttermilk Panna Cotta
Caramelized Onion Tart

“Came here for my birthday dinner on monday night with two friends. Having a culinary background. I always enjoy trying places with fresh, unique, seasonal menus. Not only was this restaurant all of the above but they actually changed their menu daily. The flavor profile of each dish was perfectly balanced and unique. Everything was cooked to absolute perfection. The service was also top notch. Our server, the hostess and everyone who passed our table was extremely accommodating. This was an amazing experience and I'm so happy I got to do it for my birthday. I highly, highly recommend going here.“

4.6 Superb100 Reviews
Pine Hill Arms Hotel | The Arms Restaurant and Saloon Bar • $$
286 Main St #288, Pine Hill - 5.84 miles

“My wife and I loved an affordable, comfy, and clean place to stay while we skied at Belleayre. Coffee in the AM was great and were total coffee snobs! We used to frequent this area several years ago and a few things have since closed down, meaning you’ll need to drive over to Arkville for general supplies. Most places nearby seemed to open around 8am and close on the earlier side. Although we visited during the week and saw that they would make you breakfast on the weekend.Expect traditional Catskills lodging.We’ve eaten at the tavern in the past and it was great. Didn’t make it on our last visit.“

4.2 Good22 Reviews

Taste More In Big Indian