Castell's

Name: Castell's
Address: 222 Avenue U, Brooklyn, New York, 11223, US
Telephone: (718) 908-0060
Rating: 4.3

Kosher

Hours:
222 Avenue U, Brooklyn
(718) 908-0060

About Castell's

Castell’s is a kosher restaurant that offers a unique and upscale dining experience reminiscent of a 1950’s Italian supper club. The decor features old-fashioned wood paneling, mirrors, and wall art, creating a classic and inviting atmosphere. The restaurant is located in a discreet, residential neighborhood, with a security guard opening the door, and a non-descript storefront that requires a keen eye to find. Seating is available for about 150 people, and reservations are highly recommended, especially since the place tends to be packed, even on a Tuesday night. Parking can be challenging due to its location.

The service at Castell’s is attentive and professional, with waiters in white suits catering to guests’ needs. Notably, staff members like Giulia are praised for their warm and attentive hospitality, making guests feel well cared for. The food is prepared with care and high-quality ingredients, with dishes that are flavorful and well-presented. A standout is the focaccia bread basket, which is thick and rich, almost a meal on its own. The menu is small, featuring around 30 items, and includes pizza, pasta, and desserts. The pizza is highly recommended, while pasta can be hit or miss—some dishes, like the ravioli, may lack enough cheese or have burnt bottoms. Desserts such as tiramisu received mixed reviews, with some finding it bland or poorly executed.

While the atmosphere is comfortable and the food generally tasty, the restaurant can be loud when busy, with close seating that makes conversation difficult. The prices are elevated, reflecting the upscale nature of the place. Castell’s is not recommended for children, and parking in the neighborhood can be difficult. Overall, it is considered a local gem for those seeking a high-quality, kosher dining experience, with excellent service and a classy ambiance.