Miss American Pie
CLOSED$ •
About Miss American Pie
Miss American Pie Reviews
133 ratings
I had the Signature Pie today at the 5th Avenue fair. Apple, peach and blueberry. Absolutely delicious.
My wife and I have had many banana creme pies. And I would say it is the pie that has the highest hit or miss factor. Either too sweet, too large banana slices, or meh-texture crust. My wife wanted one for her birthday so we rolled the dice and hit Miss American Pie. The banana creme pie we received was what I can only describe as yumtastic. As we are up in years so watching our sugar intake our intention was to only eat a slice a piece. No chance. We were staring at an empty...read full review
I have had many a pastry at Miss American Pie. The staff are always kind, the pies always hit the spot, and the atmosphere is always so lovely! It’s served as a warm, cozy spot for me to sit and do art for an hour or two at a time and it always smells so good.This 5th Ave location is closing at the end of the month, but I look forward to any future endeavors by the Miss American Pie team!
Miss American Pie is a cozy spot with a lovely atmosphere, perfect for a quick sweet treat. The staff are always kind and attentive, making sure customers feel comfortable. The pies are a highlight, with the signature pie featuring multiple fruits being a popular choice. The double chocolate pecan pie with ice cream is also a must-try. Prices are reasonable, with pies around $7 each and drinks like tea available for $3. The 60s diner-themed interior adds to the charm, making Miss American Pie a lovely spot to relax and enjoy a delicious pie.
The banana cream pie is a customer favorite, with the perfect balance of sweetness and texture. The flaky crust and fresh filling are highly praised by customers. The owner and staff are known for their friendly and hard-working customer service, greeting each visitor warmly. While some customers feel the portions could be larger, the overall quality and flavor of the pies are top-notch, with affordable pricing. The nostalgic 1950s-inspired decor creates a cozy and inviting atmosphere for customers to enjoy their sweet treats.