Papa Johns Pizza
$ • Pizza, Chicken Wings, Fast FoodAbout Papa John's
Customers' Favorites
Medium Original Crust Cheese Pizza
Extra Cheesy Alfredo
Chocolate Brownie
Chicken Wings
Dipping Sauce
Garlic Knots
Cheese Sticks
Papa John's Reviews
117 ratings
Share your opinion about Papa Johns Pizza
Ordered a spicy italian sausage pizza last night. There were two pizzas in the box. I think the driver handed me the wrong one, because it was a ham, pepperoni and jalepeno pizza. 🤣🤣 It was a good pizza so thanks to whoever ordered it. Also....sorry I ate your pizza, but admit it: You also ate mine 🙃
Food is good but this the second time they have given me the wrong sauce. I expect to get my money’s worth & be able to enjoy my food but I can’t unfortunately. Situations like this make me want to go back dominoes smh
Son adores it
Hours
| Monday | 10:45AM - 12AM |
| Tuesday | 10:45AM - 12:45AM |
| Wednesday | 10:45AM - 12AM |
| Thursday | 10:45AM - 1AM |
| Friday | 10:45AM - 1AM |
| Saturday | 10:45AM - 1AM |
| Sunday | 10:45AM - 12AM |
Papa Johns Pizza offers a hit or miss experience at the Nostrand location. Some days the service is friendly and helpful, informing customers about promotions. However, other times, the staff can be rude and unprofessional. Despite inconsistencies, the young kid working alone in the morning provides great service, handling walk-ins and online orders efficiently. The pizzas are hot and fresh, with the works pizza being a standout with generous toppings. A minor critique is that the crust could be thinner and crispier, although the garlic butter sauce compensates for it.