Sergio's Pizza🍕

Name: Sergio's Pizza🍕
Address: 279 Malcolm X Blvd, Brooklyn, New York, 11233, US
Telephone: (718) 513-3300
Price range: $
Rating: 2.7

$ • Pizza, Vegetarian

Hours:
279 Malcolm X Blvd, Brooklyn
(718) 513-3300

Menu Order Online

About Sergio's Pizza🍕

Sergio's Pizza🍕 is a beloved local spot that has been serving the community since 1975. Known for its honest and well‑balanced pizza, it has a simple yet consistent approach that emphasizes quality over trends. The menu offers a variety of options, including a notable chicken and spinach Alfredo slice that is elegantly prepared with restrained creaminess and a well‑distributed topping. The crust is firm yet unobtrusive, providing a comforting bite. Customers often praise the flavorful slices, especially the pepperoni and regular options, with the tomato sauce and cheese capturing a true Italian flavor. The garlic rolls are also highly recommended, described as heavenly.

The atmosphere is casual and cozy, with a quiet rhythm that reflects its role as a neighborhood eatery rather than a destination for tourists or influencers. The clientele mainly consists of local families, couples, and kids enjoying their favorite slices. Service is quick and friendly, with staff members often going above and beyond — as one owner demonstrated by personally resolving an issue with a refund. Prices are considered great for the quality, and there are occasional specials like buy one get one free, making it a good choice for parties or takeout.

While some improvements in the interior and ambiance could elevate the experience, Sergio’s Pizza remains a place that feeds its community with dignity and consistency. Its food, friendly service, and local charm make it a reliable spot for satisfying pizza.