The Sweet Tooth & Catering
$ • Bakery, Caterers, DessertAbout The Sweet Tooth & Catering
Customers' Favorites
The Sweet Tooth & Catering Reviews
Share your opinion about The Sweet Tooth & Catering
Went on sunday and got the banana pudding meringue, banana pudding cake, and key lime cheesecake. All of it was really good but 2 days later im dreaming about another slice of that banana pudding cake lol. These are not the soulless desserts you find everywhere in the city. Im surprised this place doesnt have a line out the door
Absolutely incredible cheesecakes! I would venture to say best in NYC. Stopped by after reading reviews and this place is worth the hype. Locally owned (17 years), friendly service, great prices, and delicious desserts. You can really tell that everything is made with care and quality ingredients. Can’t wait to go back and try the banana pudding and various pies!
Used this company for Teacher Appreciation Week!
It was amazing !!!!
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 12 - 6:30PM |
| Friday | 12 - 6:30PM |
| Saturday | 12 - 6:30PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 5PM |
The Sweet Tooth & Catering is a delightful spot, offering a range of treats that are sure to please. Their shrimp po'boy and desserts are standouts, while their cakes are also a highlight—the strawberry cake is a particular favorite. The shrimp po'boy is especially praised for its crispy, perfectly breaded shrimp and the fresh, tangy-sweet coleslaw that complements it well. Guests have raved about the juicy shrimp and flounder topped with a secret sauce, all toasted to perfection. The owner and cook, Shakoor, is known for his friendliness and passion for baking, creating a warm atmosphere filled with positive energy. Customers appreciate that if they are out of something, the staff calls to let them know and offers a replacement, ensuring consistent quality. The menu features a variety of options, including pork-free soul food and chopped chicken barbecue sandwiches. Desserts like sweet potato cheesecake and dough-apple pie are also popular, and some customers plan to order the pies for special occasions like Thanksgiving. Whether seeking comfort food or something to satisfy a sweet tooth, The Sweet Tooth & Catering has been a reliable neighborhood spot for 17 years, with high praise for its delicious food and friendly service.