21 Best Caterers in Brooklyn

Just a Nibble NYC Caterers • $$$
46 Prospect Pl, Brooklyn

“I used Just a Nibble for an engagement party at our house in Brooklyn for about 60 people. They EXCEEDED my expectations. Nick was wonderful to work with, flexible and took the stress out of the situation. He sent out a great team of two servers - Alexa and Xander - and a chef, Pablo. They worked hard, were polite and gracias to our guests, and cleaned up well. The appetizers we ordered were delicious and I had leftovers for days. I will definitely use this team again and recommend them highly.“

5 Superb46 Reviews
Deity Weddings and Events Caterers
368 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn

“Our friends hosted their wedding at Deity this last weekend and if I had one word to sum up the experience, I would say it was magical! The venue itself is absolutely stunning and beautifully unique! There are multiple levels that can host an array of different settings and vibes, which I loved! We started our day on the fourth level in the bridal suite, which was spacious enough for 14 of us to get ready. We then moved on to the fifth level, which is a beautiful rooftop terrace for photos. Moving on to the third floor, we attended the wedding ceremony in a room that had been beautifully decorated to suit the tastes of the bride and groom. This room was flipped over for dinner as we had cocktail hour and hors d'oeuvres on the second level bar area, which was adorned with soft lighting and an intimate seating area. Finally, we moved downstairs to the first level, which was a room with beautiful art deco ceilings, to dance the night away for the reception. Although the venue itself was a gem, what impressed me the most was the staff and service. The food was absolutely delicious, but more than that, they seemed to think of every single detail to make it an unforgettable experience. The owners were personally involved in the process from beginning to end, which made me feel confident in knowing someone had such a personal investment in the event. I’d highly recommend Deity for a wedding or other special social or corporate event.“

4.8 Superb72 Reviews
Bassett Caterers Caterers • $$
1404 Avenue X, Brooklyn

“Hire Frank and the crew at Bassett Caterers today! Bassett does things old school, and it was SO refreshing to be met with real customer service. From day 1, Frank was so friendly and offered utmost flexibility in every aspect. We booked Bassett and then 6+ months later when we called to talk through details, Frank was able to repeat back to me all the specifics we had mentioned on our first call! Bassett offered so much variety for our buffet, and Frank kindly added extra flare to side dishes, making it so much more than we imagined. He and his crew were efficient and set up our tables exactly as we requested, and kept snacks in the bridal suite all night. They even put together an ice cream sundae bar for us! The presentation is no frills but still elegant, just like we hoped. Everything was reasonably priced and everyone had plenty to eat, and all Frank's suggestions were worth it. They are real pros!“

4.7 Superb94 Reviews
The Sweet Tooth & Catering Bakery • $$
376 Marcus Garvey Blvd, Brooklyn

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp PO Boy Cabbage Potato Salad with Garlic Bread
Jerl Chicken Potato Salad Mac and Cheese
Signature Sweet Potato Cheesecake
Sweet Potato Pound Cake Loaf
Pulled Jerk Chicken Sandwich
Raspberry Swirl Cheesecake
Red Velvet Cake Slice
Red Velvet Cheesecake
Strawberry Cheesecake
Key Lime Cheesecake

“Wow this was incredible, there service was amazing. After getting a free sample of the coffee cheese cake a day before we knew we had to come back and try the food and it didn’t disappoint. Make sure to try a slice of the best cheesecake when your in town you won’t be “

4.8 Superb56 Reviews
Meats Supreme Caterers •
181 Avenue U, Brooklyn

“Meat, chicken selection is in abundance and fresh. A beautiful selection of freshly made salads cold cuts and various cheeses is sliced to order. Prices are a little high but worth every penny. They take phone orders for delivery in a timely fashion. Avenue U location is pristine clean, cashiers and other workers are very nice and helpful. Freshly made Italian breads and rolls every few hours. They offer catered dishes for large gatherings, corporate & private parties.“

4.7 Superb62 Reviews
Shelsky's Of Brooklyn Appetizing and Delicatessen Sandwich Shop • $
141 Court St, Brooklyn

Customers` Favorites

Toasted Everything Bagel with Smoked Salmon Cream Cheese Red Onion and Capers
Scallion Cream Cheese
Matzo Ball Soup
Whitefish Salad
Knish
Lox

“Their Gluten Free Bagels are amazing. I ordered online which was a mistake - it said it would take 45 minutes to be ready but when I walked over there 5 minutes later it was ready (phew!) and I think I was charge a fee. So ORDER but not online!Love love love the bagels.“

4.2 Good76 Reviews
El Caribe Country Club Caterers Caterers • $$
5945 Strickland Ave, Brooklyn

“It’s been a pleasure transporting a large percentage of our limousine clients to El Caribe for their special occasions and events. As a neighboring vendor it has been a seamless experience providing services as we are conveniently located only 10 minutes away (Avenue D/Utica Ave). The valet attendant is always most helpful and courteous when directing our limousine drivers with parking. If you or someone you know is thinking about booking El Caribe as your venue for celebration we highly recommend them and if you are looking for a limousine or party bus to transport you in style and luxury we can help you as well give us a call at 718-629-2540 and we will help you with booking or providing a price quote. We have limousines that fit as small as a party of 8 to as big as a party of 35 people.“

4.7 Superb52 Reviews
Pheasant Catering New American • $$$
57 Driggs Ave, Brooklyn

“We recently had our wedding catered by Pheasant and they are truly the absolute best. Lola and Cat were wonderful during the entire planning process - so communicative, easy to talk to, and thoughtful with all their ideas. They helped us with planning our menu, handled all our rentals for furniture, linens, and serve wear, and worked with our planner to create a timeline for cocktails and dinner that flowed perfectly. We were blown away on wedding day - our tables turned out so beautiful and everything that was served was absolutely delicious. We even had many guests tell us it was the best wedding food they've had! We loved that everything was served family style and featured gorgeous, in-season produce. We are so thrilled with our experience with Pheasant and cannot recommend them enough!“

4.5 Superb22 Reviews
Seuda Foods Inc Caterers •
705 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn

“I recently worked with Nathan at Seuda to arrange kosher catering for a friend that was sitting Shiva, even though I was out of state. Nathan's professionalism, empathy, and careful planning were truly outstanding.He coordinated everything, from meal planning to delivery, and made a difficult time much easier for everyone involved. Although I didn't personally taste the food, the feedback from the family was overwhelmingly positive.Seuda's dedication to customer care is unmatched. I highly recommend them for anyone in need of kosher catering. A big thank you to Nathan and the team for their exceptional service!“

4.8 Superb28 Reviews
The Liberty Warehouse Caterers • $$$
260 Conover St, Brooklyn

“It's impossible to sum up into a concise review how spectacular The Liberty Warehouse is. From the breathtaking views, the absolutely top tier staff, and incredible food selection - the LW was by far our favorite wedding vendor (& that says a lot because our day was perfect!)Jeff, we are forever grateful for your guidance and vision aiding us in perfecting our wedding day. Your vendor recommendations, food suggestions, timeline, etc. - I'd trust you with any choice! Hugging you right before walking down the aisle with my father was the cherry on top of being a Liberty Warehouse bride. Andrea - thank you for also always being so comforting, welcome and kind. You answered EVERY silly little email or question we had - big or small. Your energy is contagious and seeing your smiling face the morning of my wedding was all I needed to know our day was going to be perfect. My bridal attendant Alexandra ... where do I begin?! She was absolutely phenomenal. She anticipated my needs, made sure I ate and drank (both water and champagne), removed random stains that appeared throughout the day, bustled my dress in what felt like 30 seconds, and made sure everything was perfect.We knew the food and drinks were going to be fantastic from the raving reviews we heard through family and friends - but the LW blew us away. People STILL talk about how good the food was and I'm sure they will for years to come. From the tasting 2-3 months before, you are hidden on-site and try everything that couple is having that wedding night. Most of the options we ended up choosing for our own wedding, too! (pro tip- get the beef lo mein station!!!) Having our cocktail hour food set up for us with our signature drinks the moment our ceremony ended was such a blessing. We ate and giggled and we were simply in awe at how perfect it all was just before freshening up and entering our reception.The staff at the LW executed an absolutely perfect evening and timeline. They coordinated dances and dinner with our band, ensured the bridal party was where they needed to be and when, and took care of our parents, grandparents, etc. all day long. From the valet and bathroom attendants, to the coordinators and management, and whoever helped gather my belongings at the end of the night - thank you, THANK YOU, thank you. From the bottom of our hearts, our wedding day was absolutely, undeniably perfect. I'd recommend the Liberty Warehouse for any upscale event and can chat about it for hours on end.“

4.7 Superb38 Reviews
Meal Mart Caterers •
1920 Avenue M, Brooklyn

“Fast and great service plus the food is always fantastic. It is also a very convenient area. They have a lot of variety of different things that you can buy from their takeout as well as make a party together with your family and friends. If you need a kiddush, Sheva Brachos, or any other thing they're the people to go to for their prices, it happens to be unbelievably great.“

5 Superb17 Reviews
Puerto Plata Fish Market Seafood Markets • $$
391 Arlington Ave, Brooklyn

“This is my absolute favorite seafood place of all time! The food is always amazing. The staff are so friendly and the prices are extremely reasonable. My entire family orders from here whenever we have get togethers now. Couldn’t recommend it more!“

4.7 Superb33 Reviews
Pure Green - Juice Bar Greenpoint Juice • $
5 Commercial St, Brooklyn

Customers` Favorites

Pure Green Smoothie
Avocado Toast

“Rarely do I feel compelled to leave a review, but I came into this store recently and received outstanding service. Melinda was so kind and cheerful - it really made my day. It’s rare to have such an encounter and she was truly a gem that made me want to become a regular. Not to mention the smoothie was delicious and the store extremely clean.“

4.6 Superb48 Reviews
Mandys Lasagna witha TwiisT Caterers • $$
1140 Utica Ave, Brooklyn

Customers` Favorites

Jumbo Shrimp
Salmon Bites
Lasagna
Rolls

“Always fresh and tummy! Made to order! Yes please! Choice to mix and match salad and bread included with wonderfully reasonable prices. Great food well seasoned, awesome flavors! My tummy is happy!!. Give time your order will be slow but made with love.“

4.7 Superb32 Reviews
Olivia Cooks For You | Meal Prep and Delivery Caterers •
294 3rd avenue ground floor, Brooklyn

“Olivia's food is amazing - delicious, healthy, fresh, and a HUGE helper for busy people. She is the consummate pro, and wonderfully attuned to the needs of her clients. Her meals are truly fabulous self-care and also make wonderful gifts. Cannot recommend her highly enough!“

4.7 Superb28 Reviews
Pistache NYC Caterers • $$
630 Flushing Ave Suite 806, Brooklyn

“I had to write about Pistache NY because I have never ever met someone as incredible as Yvan Bedouet. I was planning to have Pistache NYC cater my New Year's Eve party since he came so so highly recommended. I spoke to Yvan multiple times with many changes, where he had to draw up new menus which he did without any objection. It turned out I had to cancel due to medical reasons. He was so gracious, not only refunded all the money although I had insisted he keep a portion since I had to cancel, HE ASKED FOR MY ADDRESS AND DROPPED OFF A BOUCHE NOEL!!!!!I am in awe of Pistache NYC and Yvan Bedouet and can not wait to have them cater my next party.Thank you“

4.8 Superb17 Reviews
Latifa's Kosher Kitchen Caterers •
707 Avenue U, Brooklyn

“Latif Restaurant & Catering is a true culinary gem! Whether you're dining in restaurant or enjoying their catering services for a special event, you're in for a treat. The food is absolutely delicious, with each dish expertly prepared using the freshest ingredients and bursting with flavor. From their tender kebabs to their fragrant biryanis, every bite is a delight for the taste buds. What truly sets Latif apart, however, is their exceptional service. The staff are attentive,“

5 Superb11 Reviews
Empanada Papa Street Vendors • $$
34 35th St 6th floor, Brooklyn

“Very Delicious. I attended a Mix & Mingle event at Bklyn Commons and my Business Partners had the Beef and I had the Corn Empanada. We loved it and highly recommend for your future events. I didn’t even miss having meat cause the Corn was so delicious.“

4.7 Superb15 Reviews
Meisners Catering Caterers •
2924 Avenue I, Brooklyn

“Very nice and incredibly prepared traditional and modern kosher catering with an extremely friendly, accommodating and understanding staff that is always helpful in getting wait staff assistance as well! Great takeout food with a perfect convenient location, plus they do simchas like aufruf, kiddush, sheva brachos and more! Awesome. Just did my food and waiting staff for aufruf and sheva brachos and I have hakaras hatov for their help!“

4.9 Superb7 Reviews
Meal Mart Kosher • $
4521 Fort Hamilton Pkwy, Brooklyn

Customers` Favorites

Grill BBQ Chicken
Pastrami Sandwich
Chicken Liver
Cholent

“The owner is friendly and provides great service. The place is clean. The food is great and tasty. Price is not cheap but I do not mind paying more for good food. It is kosher but you don't have to be Jewish to enjoy. Everything is great about this place except the price. The price is good.“

4.8 Superb8 Reviews
Mermelstein Takeout Caterers • $
351 Kingston Ave, Brooklyn

“Time for a recent review. Been here several times over the last few year. Always ordered the same: 8 dozen meat kreplach - frozen, to go of course. (lol!). Why 8? Price = $15 per dozen for a total of $120. Anyway, they are totally delicious. We put them in soup or air fry them and serve with duck sauce or chili sauce for a quick snack at home. Note- they are closed on Sundays in the Summer. Call ahead to check hours.“

4.5 Superb8 Reviews
Loading...
map Map