New American Restaurants near Canastota, NY

Johnnie's Pier 31 Seafood • $$
3653 NY-31, Canastota

Customers` Favorites

New England Clam Chowder
Fresh Bullhead Dinner
Blackened Haddock
Mashed Potatoes
Haddock Sandwich
Shrimp Basket
Lake Perch

“Outstanding service and great selection of food. I had the fish which was absolutely it was grouper and paired to perfection staff. Very attentive and menu varied in wide depending on specials. Great view of the lake. You can be indoors or outdoors. Fun place to go ?Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair access is straight from the parking lot into the first store. Takes you right into the main dining room“

4.4 Superb31 Reviews
Theodore's Restaurant Family • $
3231 Seneca Turnpike, Canastota

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Riggies with Jalapeños
Seafood Alfredo Pasta
French Onion Soup
Fish and Chips
Theodore

“I truly appreciate a place you can feel right at home. I have yet to have any bad service or food. Good Portions and offerings. Have seen owners take great care that the whole experience is a positive one for all. I am a creature of habit and when I find a place I feel at home I am very loyal. I would recommend topping off a great meal off with Raisin Bread Pudding with Whiskey Sauce. I actually enjoy the sauce over Ice Cream. Hey do not trust me, go and give them a try. I am sure you will appreciate the fine dining. Enjoy!“

4.3 Superb48 Reviews
Lakeport Inn American • $
1859 NY-31, Chittenango - 7.61 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Cheeseburger Deluxe
Fish Fry

“I was a bit skeptical about trying this place because every time I've driven by, it looks dead and there's not much to read online about it. I went in with low expectations but left very satisfied. It's a nice small townie bar/restaurant. The waitress was very nice and said that it gets busy for calm night. They have weekly specials and they freshly make most of the food. She said all the soups and mashed potatoes are homemade. They are reasonably priced and have large portions. It is well worth it. The food was delicious and I would definitely come back here!“

4.5 Superb31 Reviews
The Bistro at Villa Verona Vineyard Bistros • $$
4914 NY-365, Oneida - 7.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Alfredo
Bistro Burger
Bistro Steak
Menu

“Overall i was really excited about the expirence here. It’s a cozy little restaurant with a wine tasting room next door, it has something to offer for everyone. I was impressed with all the food, we had a party of 8 an only one person complained of the salmon being undercooked, which was immediately rectified. I ordered the chicken bacon ranch pizza which was loaded with toppings and a nice thick crust. The side of wings were just incredible. The server forgot to replenish our water for the whole night, forgot some orders and a few other minor details, but she was really sweet and was attentive still. They have a extensive wine list with a variety of options for every palette. Definitely would revisit.“

4.1 Good33 Reviews
The Lake House at Sylvan Beach New American • $$
301 Park Ave, Sylvan Beach - 8.2 miles

“We had an Incredible Dinner at the Lakehouse Tonight❤️Jessica, and Rose were Welcoming, attentive, and knowledgeable about the Delicious food on the Menu❤️. The Atmosphere was warm and inviting and We had lots of room to eat and enjoy Ourselves❤️The Bang Bang Shrimp We Love and it Def didn't disappoint tonight❤️I had the Fish Fry and it Covered the Plate and was absolutely Appetizing and Filling❤️We Love the Lakehouse and Will return Always❤️“

3.9 Good107 Reviews
Villa Verona Vineyard Wineries • $$
4914 NY-365, Oneida - 7.03 miles

“A must try if you haven't already!! Food was delicious, service was great, and the atmosphere was perfect. Oh, and the wine was the icing on the cake. We had a party of 8 and every single one of us loved our meal as well as the appetizers that we all shared!! I will be back!!“

3.8 Good23 Reviews
Origlio’s Wagon Wheel Restaurant Italian • $
212 Main St, Oneida - 5.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Small Deep Fried Haddock Sandwich with Fries
Chicken Parmigiana with Spaghetti
Rigatoni with Mushrooms
Linguine with Mushrooms
Linguine with Meatballs
Chicken Parmigiana Sub
Hofman with Spaghetti
Breaded Cauliflower
Shrimp Platter
Garlic Bread

“Don't go there without cash.Got blindsided with a no card bill.Food is standard issue sit-down Italian.Wife loved the eggplant parmesan.Staff was great and I'm sure they get tired of people crabbing about cash only - we thought it was weird.“

3.8 Good34 Reviews
Gary's Restaurant American • $
6367 Lakeshore Rd S, Canastota - 6.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

Everything Chicken Wings
Scallops Parmesan
Potato Skins
Sausage Soup
Seafood Combo
Frog Legs

“Gary's is a perfect spot for anyone looking to enjoy the view of the lake. The Buffalo wings were amazing and Linda was very informative about the area as my family and I are from out of state.The atmosphere is very homey and I would highly reccomend this place to anyone.“

3.6 Good34 Reviews
Loading...
map Map