New American Restaurants near Canastota, NY

Johnnie's Pier 31 Seafood • $$
3653 NY-31, Canastota

Customers` Favorites

New England Clam Chowder
Fresh Bullhead Dinner
Fried Seafood Platter
Blackened Haddock
Haddock Sandwich
Mashed Potatoes
Chicken Riggies
Scallop Dinner
Shrimp Basket
Steak Fries

“Our first visit tonight, we were greeted by the most kindest women. She was so knowledgeable and told us all her specials and recommendations. We had the best soup and meal. Very tasty. We then went to the bar and met John, we were able to sit on the deck with a perfect view and our greeter(John’s wife)came out and talked to us several times made us feel right at home. Very comfortable setting amazing view and food. If you have not stopped at this amazing gem you need to.“

4.6 Superb72 Reviews
Theodore's Restaurant Family • $$
3231 Seneca Turnpike, Canastota

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Riggies with Jalapeños
Seafood Alfredo Pasta
French Onion Soup
Theodore's Burger
Chicken Fricassee
Seafood Platter
Stuffed Haddock
Turkey Sandwich
Fish and Chips

“had 21 adults attend a mini reunion. the service and food were great!! Theodore's provided us with separate checks. the waitress never missed a beat!! and we only had one waitress. we had such a great time.“

4.4 Superb80 Reviews
Lakeport Inn American • $
1859 NY-31, Chittenango - 7.61 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Cheeseburger Deluxe
Tartar Sauce
Fish Fry

“Went to Lakeport Inn for their haddock dinner. Hubby and I shared and we still could not eat it all. The baked beans are outstanding, haddock was perfectly fried and the onion rings were abundant and done to perfection. Our server - Tara - was on point with all she had going on as they had just been slammed with customers and she was doing it all with a smile and good attitude. Not fancy by any means but you will leave feeling like they will know your name next time you stop in.“

4.6 Superb48 Reviews
The Bistro at Villa Verona Vineyard Bistros • $$
4914 NY-365, Oneida - 7.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fireman's Burger and Fries
NYS Artisan Cheeses for 2
Crispy Honey Chicken
Chicken Alfredo
Bistro Burger
Bistro Steak
Pretzel
Menu

“We had the Best Time and Delicious Night Out❤️Mary C was so knowledgeable about the Wine choices for Our tastings and Very Accommodating to Our Needs with Joy and Friendliness❤️We Loved the Elderberry Wine and the Wing Flight different flavor Options, Our Pizza was Amazing I've never had Shrimp on Pizza before so Yum❤️Perfect Date Night, We Will return❤️❤️❤️“

4.5 Superb41 Reviews
The Lake House at Sylvan Beach New American • $$
301 Park Ave, Sylvan Beach - 8.2 miles

“We went on a Tuesday for lunch. Loved the stylish eating area and decor. Our waitress was friendly and efficient. The Fish Fry was delicious! 😋“

4.2 Good224 Reviews
Villa Verona Vineyard Wineries • $$
4914 NY-365, Oneida - 7.03 miles

“We've been completely pleased with everything about this place since discovering it a year ago. It's been worth the 20+ minute drive every time. Really nice hostesses, and a surprisingly cute interior for such an out-of-the-way location.“

4 Good31 Reviews
Origlio’s Wagon Wheel Restaurant Italian • $
212 Main St, Oneida - 5.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Small Deep Fried Haddock Sandwich with Fries
Chicken Parmigiana with Spaghetti
Rigatoni with Mushrooms
Linguine with Mushrooms
Linguine with Meatballs
Chicken Parmigiana Sub
Hofman with Spaghetti
Breaded Cauliflower
Sicilian Salad
Shrimp Platter

“I Love Origlio"s food, everything is so good.“

3.8 Good59 Reviews
Gary's Restaurant American • $
6367 Lakeshore Rd S, Canastota - 6.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

Everything Chicken Wings
Scallops Parmesan
Blackened Grouper
Potato Skins
Sausage Soup
Seafood Combo
Frog Legs

“Love it there. Food is great, Service is great, prices great and the view is great“

3.7 Good58 Reviews