26 Best American Restaurants near Canastota

“Great homemade food and experience , very clean“

“Three pines was a lovely little bar restaurant. The front was the typical bar feel while the back was the restaurant. It is a simple menu so it is easy to pick what you want. The staff was amazing in every way. The food was delicious and I would recommend especially if you are passing through the area.

Parking: There was plenty of parking on the street but some people might be turned off by street parking. There was a public lot a little down the way though so it appears there are options. We went around 2pm on a friday and there were a lot of spots i'm unsure how parking is other times during the day and week.“

“highly recommend, the food was great. can't wait to go back.“

“Such a great place to be, I highly recommend it to all parties!“

“had 21 adults attend a mini reunion. the service and food were great!! Theodore's provided us with separate checks. the waitress never missed a beat!! and we only had one waitress. we had such a great time.“

“Bought a carving today it was really nice work at a reasonable price. So many things in the store!!! Will have to come back. The woman was very nice“

“We visited with a party of 6 on a Saturday evening, and there was a decent crowd, but we were able to be seated right away. Our server, Jackie, was friendly and attentive. The atmosphere was very inviting and very clean. The food was fantastic! Four of us had burgers. The flavor of the beef (from O'Mara Farms, I believe) was excellent, the rolls toasted just right. The toppings were plentiful. The fries were awesome, too. The NY strip steak was very tender and flavorful. I highly recommend Madison Bistro!! This was our first time and we will definitely be back!!!“

“The chef here should be cooking to a full house every night! His food is absolutely delicious and he knows what to do as far as flavoring and cooking it to perfection. The portions are absolutely huge and the prices are very fair. Everyone talks about the scallops and I can see why, they're amazing and plentiful!! The Waitresses are very attentive and friendly, go there you won't be disappointed.“

“Hosted a bridal shower there recently. Food was great and Megan was wonderful in the planning and day of event. Would absolutely recommend Lakeside!!“

“Could not recommend this place enough. Went with my boyfriend’s parents a few months ago and has been a hit ever since. Brought my own family and friends back. Best garlic parm wings EVER!!! Haven’t had a bad thing yet!“

“Went there for the first time today. My family and I really enjoyed it because not only was the food amazing but the atmosphere was inviting pleasant and clean. Not to mention our superb server Eliza. Who wasn't only friendly and polite but very knowledgeable worth every penny“

“I miss the days of greasy spoons on weekends. This was a nice treat as I stopped by passing through town. The diner had a nice homey feel, and the food was good. I had a sausage, peppers, and onion omelet with Itlaian toast and coffee. Food was up in about 10 minutes. The waitress was kind and attentive.If I lived in town, that would be a place I would frequent most weekends.“

“I just ordered a sub from DoorDash from this place & let me tell you no complaints, I got a Italian herb and cheese sub roll with turkey as a meat and let me tell you omg it was so good, the bread was so fresh and everything about it was so good, definitely gonna have to come in and order more“

“Good food and prices, along with extremely quick and friendly service.“

“The place was very nice. Was there at lunch and wasn't very busy. We ordered pizza flights. They were delicious and the server was friendly. It's a little more upscale, so not a "quick lunch" place.Would recommend for a date“

“It was so good I went two days in a row!“

“One of my favorite place to eat the menu is awesome the food is delicious beautiful scenery of Oneida lake“

“2 visits to this bar and I have an OFFICIAL REVIEW!!!!!The first night I had a few beers with my buddy and some homemade wings. The sauces and wings themselves were made to perfection. Service was on point and definitely there when needed. The second visit I ate a burger and fries with a few more beers. GET THIS.... the bartender both times (thursday) did it all!!!! She's amazing!!!I've gotta recommend this bar because of service, football / ufc / soccer / baseball on the tvs at all times, nice dart boards, super clean and modern bathrooms, beautiful spacious outdoor enclosed patio that can seat probably 80 people including a band, very clean kitchen, outside appearance is clean as well, and the hospitality is 'Best In Class!!!'Go. Go tonight. Your gonna have a great time, great food, great conversation and meat great people. Enjoy and have fun!“

“This is such a great place!! Every one that works there is fantastic,, along with the food and desserts!!!!! While staying at the beach we stopped in for dinner with friends and we were met with such a great staff. Kristie went out of her way to make our experience amazing,,, she did just that!!! The real story here is the owner who is the most pleasant, sincere person. 47 years of success proves she is devoted and loves what she does… the food is excellent!!! The desserts are fantastic!! We ended up eating there 3 of the 4 nights we were in town!!!
Jeannie, you are one in a million!!
We will be back in2 weeks for the chicken run,,, and you are our first,,, and last stop while we’re there!!5 stars for sure!!!
See you soon!!“

“Best place to eat at Sylvan beach. We looked at the Cove and are considering staying there in the near future. I have to say from my experience that anything the Oneida Nation puts their hand to turns out to be “excellance”. Great Vision. Thank you Steven And Diane Rockwell“

“I Love Origlio"s food, everything is so good.“

“We've been completely pleased with everything about this place since discovering it a year ago. It's been worth the 20+ minute drive every time. Really nice hostesses, and a surprisingly cute interior for such an out-of-the-way location.“

“Excellent service. Server was amazing and very attentive to all of our needs. The food was amazing and cooked to perfection. I have eaten at several fine dining establishments and Captain Johns atmosphere, employees and service leaves nothing to be desired. I will definitely will be back.“

“Went today for Mother's day brunch .Didn't stay at hotel. Food,service, atmosphere just everything was FABULOUS. Owner greeted us went over and beyond to make us feel important and valued for being there!!!!! Highly recommend, and definitely will return often ? Great job guysNearby activities: The beach is close shops amusement park .Lots to see and do.“

“Excellent find! Prime a rib sandwich was amazing! Prices are so reasonable that families can ACTUALLY afford it. Thank you so much! Everything we had was great! We went back for dessert.“

“We go to the oneida dennys every Sunday..we search out Sherry Lewis ..she is a extra special waitress ..so kind and always on the go ...efficient..all around nice person ..wish more would take after her there..

Parking: Huge space to park

Kid-friendliness: Always kind to kids way of ordering“