15 Best Italian Restaurants near Catskill

“This place is the best around the owner and Chef are top-notch. I highly recommend this place.“

“Tonight we had a Christmas Party for the Fortnightly Club of Catskill. The food was delicious and everything was so well organized . If you’re looking to have a party or even just dinner this is the place to go. Excellent food and excellent service - Poppy and Alyssa were great tonight . Shawn is the best bartender around . Let’s not forget Cheryl who is the owner/chef! Her food is top notch !“

“I do not like to come on and leave negative reviews because I don't feel a business should suffer over one employee's bad day BUT tonight upon returning home with my pick up order there were half mushrooms and onions and peppers half cheese (which can we talk about how ridiculous it is to charge one dollar for a topping on a basically personal pan (their small 12" 4 slice size pizza). When I said there were mushrooms, but mushrooms were not supposed to be there and we were charged for it. I was told they ordered mushrooms. My intelligence was insulted because I was present when the order was made and in fact no mushrooms were never mentioned (P.S. in 6 years never ever once have mushrooms been ordered nor would they ever be so it's not like oh pepperoni unknowingly slipped out on accident could be my fault) .After calling me a liar I said I was just calling to see if my dollar could be refunded to my card that I didn't want a whole new pizza and that if it couldn't be refunded in the reality, it really was no big deal but it was worth a try. I was met with complete rudeness just a no and I said ok that's OK it's fine don't worry about it. Have a good night. I was pleasant the whole time and all I got was yup and a hang up. You could at least attempt to act halfway cordial after I was pleasant and jovial even after being called a liar and my order being screwed because mushrooms are hated. Working in retail I know how easy it is to refund money to a card. And funny how she didn't know how to do that but she sure did know how to update it to add her tip as I was notified almost 48 hours later that my total had been adjusted and that adjustment was the addition of her tip.“

“😀Great dinner there last night with friends.“

“A very casual restaurant which we like. My wife and I have eaten here 3 times since they opened in the Fall. We have had a Grandma's pizza, Stromboli and Chicken parm dinner 2x for me. Chicken parm dinner is a great deal for $15. It comes with a good size side salad, bread, pasta. Enough food for me to bring home leftovers 2x! I thought the employees were very friendly!“

“Best pizza in Catskill, we stop in every time we visit N.Y“

“had dinner there last night. Great food top of the line service“

“Amazing waiter, atmosphere, and just all around friendly!“

“I just had Mirabella’s cater my husband‘s 70th birthday. Let me tell you the food was so good and very good quality. Brandon did an awesome job price was very reasonable and everybody loved it. We had lots of leftovers so if you were going to have a party, I highly would recommend this place called Mirabella’s and asked for Brandon. He’s a great guy. He will take care of you. I am giving him 5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“We played at Anthony's last night for a private event. If you are looking for a very clean, friendly, great food, and an absolutely beautiful place to have your event, we highly recommend it. Anthony is a great guy, and the staff was amazing too! It's very spacious. Even the restrooms were very big compared to most places. Not to mention there were 3 types of soap in the bathroom. We hope to play there again!“

“Slices is amazing; really delicious food and the staff are beyond awesome. I have to extend a BIG shoutout to your driver Brian, he’s such an asset to Slices. You guys know how to run a business, thank you for ALL that you do 💛.“

“Very friendly staff, wonderful food. Chicken Reggie’s is the tastiest pasta I have ever had!“

“Hands down,best pizza in town. I usually stay away from pizza up here as I come from the land of pizza. This is hands down the best pizza up here by far. They make good hero's too.
Don't forget a Cannoli on the way out.

Parking: Plenty of parking

Kid-friendliness: I believe the owner is a mom so there you go,very kid friendly.

Wheelchair accessibility: Easy to enter & exit. No problems.“

“We ordered a pan of baked ziti, 5 pizza & 2- 3 ft subs for our daughter’s sweet 16 party yesterday. The food was incredible, ready on time & the price was very reasonable. This will be our go-to for family parties.“

“I make it a point to visit every time I’m in the area, and I’ve never been disappointed by the food, the prices, or the service. Recently, I placed a larger order over the phone on a Thursday for delivery the following day. Auna, who took my order, was actually off the next day but went above and beyond by coming into work on Friday just to ensure that my order was perfect. You simply can’t find better customer service anywhere else—this kind of dedication truly sets them apart! Highly recommend this place every time!“