Mexican Restaurants near Central Islip

Restaurantji unveils Central Islip's must-visit Mexican dining spots.

Mi pueblo Restaurant 2 Spanish • $$
189 Calebs Path, Central Islip

Customers` Favorites

Salvadorian Breakfast Desayuno Salvadoreño
MI Pueblo Pupusa Shrimp Cheese & Jalapeno
24 Steak Quesadilla Quesadilla De Carne
95 Skirt Steak Churrasco 8oz
Cheese Pupusa Queso
Tostones Tostones
Street Tacos
Lobster

“Nice place and attendants“

4.9 Superb52 Reviews
Viva Mexico Mexican • $$
31 Wheeler Rd, Central Islip

Customers` Favorites

Fajitas De Carne & Pollo Steak & Chicken Fajitas
Bistec Encebollado Steak & Grilled Onions
Tacos De Carne Asada Steak Tacos
Sope Con Carne Beef Sope
Camarones A la Mexicana
Chicken Tostada
Chicken & Beans
Tacos de Birria
Guacamole
Nachos

“Each Mexican restaurant makes their dishes differently. I went with my family and we ordered a Cuban cake. They were different from other cakes I've tried. That's why he said it's different because the tacos are just as great as many I've tried.“

3.8 Good29 Reviews
Órale Güey Taqueria Mexican • $
84 W Suffolk Ave, Central Islip

Customers` Favorites

Carne Al Gusto
Al Pastor
Jarritos
Suadero
Cesina
Birria
Pollo
Asada
Cuban
Queso

“Every time I visit this establishment, Wendy greets me with a smile: her entire team is super friendly, attentive and makes you feel like part of the family. Edwin is hilarious, always makes me laugh and honestly my visit alone deserves a 10/10 with customer service. BUT LET ME TELL YOU ABOUT THE FOOD!! Each dish is an explosion of flavor, truly delicious, and you can tell they put their heart into their food. On the weekends they have an authentic champurrado that I swear is to die for. This establishment is truly a must visit for anyone looking for the ultimate taco experience! But don't just take my word for it, go see for yourself!!
Oh and if you are lucky enough to visit when they have special tamales I IMPLORE YOU TO TRY THEM - but don't take them all, I need at least ten at a time. MINIMUM“

4 Good11 Reviews
Tenampa Mexican food Mexican • $
1553 Islip Ave, Central Islip

Customers` Favorites

Burrito de Carne
Revueltas

“The food here is consistently good. Parking in the lot these days is utter garbage because of the patio dining (NOT dissing them for doing this, everyone is trying their best during Covid times). Try to park on the streets nearby and order togo if you can. We havent tried the soup noodles to go BUT their bosam is TO DIE FOR and we get the medium to split all the time. Its perfect for two people and comes with a delicious assortment of banchan.“

2.7 Average6 Reviews
Deli El Salvadoreño Deli • $
1423a Islip Ave, Central Islip

Customers` Favorites

Chicharron Con Queso
Frijol Con Queso
Mondongo

“This place has good food and very rarely uses salt in their food, very healthy for you . There very nice people and prices are good
The only reason they don't get a five star is because they are often so busy, it worth waiting a little bit if you can for there delicious food.“

3.5 Good4 Reviews
Taco Bell Fast Food • $
16 W Suffolk Ave, Central Islip

Customers` Favorites

Cheesy Gordita Crunch
Cheese Quesadilla
Breakfast Burrito
Mexican Pizza
Guacamole
Soft Taco
Taquito

“I’ve never been here but as someone that’s worked in hospitality I have the upmost respect for the employees. If you are so disgruntled that you feel the need to physically assault an employee then you have no business here. Taco Bell if you’re listening give that fella that got slapped a raise!“

2.3 Poor62 Reviews
Taquero mucho Mexican • $
1654 5th Ave, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Quesadilla Steak Carne Asada
Tortas Sausage Chorizo
Taco Steak Carne Asada
Chicken Quesadilla
Beef Tongue Lengua
Steak Quesadillas
Mulitas Sausage
Side Guacamole
Al Pastor Taco
Taco Al Pastor

“Food is always good but today was one of those days ... tortillas where not the same and pineapples for the al pastor where not grilled as if you guys ran out and just sliced and added at least mix it with the meat ... I own a restaurant so I know how things go sometimes but pls .. consistency is key ...“

4.9 Superb125 Reviews
Fat Boy's Burrito Co. Mexican • $
4097 Jericho Turnpike, East Northport

Customers` Favorites

Korean BBQ Surf N Turf Bang Bang Shrimp Tacos
Mac & Cheese Honey Siracha Chicken Family
Honey Sriracha Chicken Quesadilla
Chicken Bacon Ranch Empanadas
Fat Jack Burrito with Avocado
Bang Bang Shrimp Quesadilla
Chicken & Waffle Quesadilla
Notchos with Chicken
Side of Mac & Cheese
Buffalo Cheesy Fries

“This is my first time ordering food from Fat Boys Burrito for my meetings (grilled chicken burritos, bang ban shrimp tacos, guacamole & chips). Their food is absolutely delicious. The variety of dishes offered, quality service and presentation is exceptional! I will definitely be ordering again. Thanks Tony and team!“

4.6 Superb277 Reviews
Pecado Mexican Mexican • $$$
49 W Main St, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Mexican Chocolate Pavlova
Coconut Tres Leches
Enchiladas De Mole
Chicken Quesadilla
Tostada De Ceviche
Tamal De Carnitas
Enchiladas Suizas
Tres Leches Cake
Huevos Benedict
Churros Waffle

“excelente servicio...la comida riquísima....ambiente muy cálido...buena música. en fin todo es excelente“

4.4 Superb338 Reviews
Right Coast Taqueria Setauket Mexican • $
4088 Nesconset Hwy, Setauket- East Setauket

Customers` Favorites

Tacos Al Pastor Tacos Al Pastor
Extra Birria Consommé 4 Oz
Mix N Match Specialty Tacos
Mix & Match Taco Box
Mongolian Beef Tacos
Mongolian Beef Nacho
Seasonal Vegetables
Thai Chicken Tacos
Birria Taco Order
Mongolian Burrito

“Right Coast Taqueria provided our lunch for our Teacher Appreciation week in Smithtown. The faculty raved about the food and presentation!! They accommodated food allergies. Great business to work with!!“

4.5 Superb141 Reviews

You May Also Like