23 Best Ice Cream Shops near Cicero

“Great service!!! So much seating and they offer seating inside and outside. Honestly not sure if there’s an ice cream stand with more seating!!! Perfect for sweet treat with family and friends!!“

“I went to the Diner for ice cream and ordered the orange dole whip and vanilla twist. It was absolutely delicious. The service was fast and polite. It was an excellent experience and I would highly recommend the Diner ice cream.

Kid-friendliness: The Diner ice cream is family friendly and has a welcoming and fun atmosphere. Perfect for families and pet friendly.“

“Love, DQ, and it’s many options of blizzards/Sundays/hamburger items and other yummy delicious things to eat. The people are fantastic that work here. The staff are very friendly, and service is quick, and with a smile. Quite the contrast, from the Dairy Queen in Colonie New York. Totally a big difference night and day. I love the Dairy Queen here in Cicero, New York/Syracuse area. Will be returning soon.“

“It’s great!! Great ice cream and great service. Highly recommend!!“

“I’ve been here several times for the ice cream with toppings. But the last two times I’ve come it’s for a Cotton candy milkshake, I’d rate that shake a one hundred out of ten, absolutely delicious!! The facility is always very clean, and they have wonderful employees. Kind, happy, and clearly love their jobs. I HIGHLY recommend ❤️❤️“

“Best around everything is always fresh and great service!“

“We will definitely be back!! The owner was so helpful and kind. I went there with my infant and she loved the kid’s room in the back - there’s a tv, books, and a train set. It was a perfect little outing. Super clean. Great yogurt.“

“The owners & staff do a fantastic job all season! They have great ice cream and even better milkshakes!“

“very professional and makes amazing Ice cream cakes“

“Crumbl has always been my favorite. Yes it can be a little pricey sometimes but depending on the lineup THEY HIT and totally worth it!!“

“Watermelon Gelati...

Yes, please, and thank you. Their Italian ice flavors include lemon, cherry, blue raspberry and they also had watermelon. Since they do Gelati, I figured why not.

My goodness, it is so refreshing. It makes me think of real watermelon with whipped cream, only better.

I highly recommend trying it. For reference, pictured is a small.“

“AMAZING FIRST EXPERIENCE!! We will definitely make this one of our new favorite shops! My son loved his PB flurry! And they have THE best vegan ice cream and cookies! Something for everyone! Check them out! You won’t regret it!! 10 🌟“

“Had them at a recent food truck gathering. Very good ice cream. I've been trying all the trucks slowly and this may be late review. But well deserving of your money.“

“Great event! No work for us and great turn out. Ice cream and games and music!“

“Impeccable service & tasty treats 👅🍦“

“Been coming here over well over 30 years there's only ice cream stand so so good. Parfaits our favorite grandkids milkshakes. Mmm. See u today!!!!“

“Delicious! Will come again“

“I seen a lot of photo of badly done crumbl cookies. This location smooths all my fears. They're always perfectly done. I have never been disappointed with my order. I love how creative the ideas can be. I have tried them four times since they can be addictive just so I can be picky about the weekly selection. Remember they're sugary so consider your health.“

“The best iced matcha latte I’ve ever had. Large portion and it was blended like a slushie. Deeeelicious.“

“Good food. Friendly server. A bit slow but worth the wait“

“Best sandwich I've ever eaten. Everything is delicious. great prices would recommend for sure“

“Listen, if we could give them 1000 stars we would. They know us by name, Bill and Amanda. We pick up 8 half gallons (aka "everybody) every couple of weeks, sometimes more. I'm not gonna get into specifics as to why we would give them more stars than Google allows because they do things specifically just for us and I dont want to cause an uproar lol. Just know from the owner (in fact, he happen to be there one day talking to us and he went out of his way to make sure we get taken care of everytime we go in there and it's frequently) right down to the everyday staff are absolutely amazing. In our world, it's the little things that make us happy, specifically cold stone ice cream. It's our mom and dad treat after the kiddos go to bed. Our one treat that we can call our own haha. We put in a movie or put on our favorite show and indulge. They have really gone out of there way to show us what true great customer service is. They've done things most places would call "too much". Just this past Sunday, they yet again did something most places wouldn't do just to make sure we got our order, got it when we wanted it and when it was convenient for us to get it. Again, all I can say is no other business I've done business with has done the things they have for us to go above and beyond the "duty" of customer service. We appreciate each and every person that works there. We've never had one bad experience. Not one. They've always stuck by there word and then some. You take care of us and we take care of you. Thanks for all that you do for us. It certainly doesn't go unnoticed. Please don't ever leave this area because we would be heartbroken. Lol“

“Best experience! I have always had issues with other places when trying to place large food orders for my kids’ birthday parties. I only chose Byrne Dairy because it was close to my venue. I was very anxious about what problems would arise per my past troubles. Everything was perfect. Food was ready on time exactly as I ordered it. It was such a relief and made the day so much easier to enjoy.“