14 Best Pizza Restaurants near Colliersville

“Friendly staff :) quick and so tasty!“

“We had a full meat pizza and it was delicious 😋 The guys are super sweet,very helpful, and the atmosphere is great. They're even open until 3am!!!We're saving their info for our next visit into New York 🍕“

“One of the better Pizza places in Oneonta. Large menu, a bit dated on the inside, but worth trying if you're near.“

“one of the best pizzerias in Oneonta. the owner clearly cares about the quality of his food, and cares about his customers.“

“While driving from Kansas City to Maine, my son and I stopped in by happenstance. Absolutely one of the tastiest and most memorable stops we made. Ordered the white pizza, wings, and pesto garlic fries. Everything was a 10/10.“

“A Hidden Gem in Meredith! My wife and I were fortunate enough to be invited by Ron to his unique restaurant tucked away in Meredith, and what a fantastic find! The atmosphere was warm and inviting, perfect for a cozy meal. The food was outstanding, with everything locally sourced and prepared with care. The braised meats, in particular, were off the charts—absolutely worth trying! The pricing is very reasonable and thoughtfully aligned with the local community, which makes it even more appealing. This spot is a must-visit if you’re looking for first-class food and a welcoming vibe. Don’t miss out on this local treasure!“

“When you walk into Nina's Oneonta, you walk in as family. The quality and comfort of the food and service is Best in Class☆ Owners Fred & Aleathea take great pride in their business. You can see and feel this from the time you enter until the time you leave! Thank you and your wonderful team/family for your years of dedication to awesome food and top notch service in our community!“

“Went in after a baseball game. We were able to be seated right away, service & food took longer than it should have but it wasn't too bad, food was good and the only downside was we were double charged for an item, that was eventually taken off the final bill, but needed to explain that we didnt order 2 of the items. I'd recommend this place if you are able to make it.“

“We ordered takeout from here last night. We haven't ordered anything from them for probably two years prior. It was honestly the "under new management" sign that prompted us to try it again as we weren't thrilled with things prior to that. Well, the new management only needs to keep doing what they did last night and they should be a great success! The pizza and wings were excellent. Pizza was authentically NY style and the wings would have fit in well in Western NY (we are originally from South of Buffalo). Keep up the great work!!“

“What a pleasantly delicious surprise!! Our first time here and will definitely be back!! Outstanding!“

“This place is a gem! the garlic eggplant pizza is absolutely delicious (and thats coming from a pizza snob from NYC)! The sauce is flavorful, the crust is perfection! This is a family owned business open for over 20 years, the children of the original owner now run the place, so its a delicious way to support local businesses!“

“Their food is amazing. I am gluten free due to celiac and have a hard time finding something in the area worth getting. This place is definitely the place if you are looking for good gluten free options.“

“Delicious food & yummy desserts!“

“Fantastic Experience Fantastic Food“