Pizza Restaurants near Hamilton

Oliveri's Pizzeria Pizza • $
14 Lebanon St, Hamilton

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Fries
Lupo Panini
Greek Salad
Meatballs
Baklava
Ravioli
Wings
Large

“It's my goal to try out all the pizza places in Central NY. Oliveri's is a stand out - friendly staff and a warm little cozy place probably does a lot of business in takeout. They do a good crust here - crispy thinner crust is key. Sauce and cheese are decent too. I will return. Prices are the fairest I have seen in the area.“

4.1 Good44 Reviews
New York Pizzeria aka Slices Pizza • $
39 Lebanon St, Hamilton

Customers` Favorites

Wings and Pizza Slice
Plain Cheese Pizza
Cheese Pizza Slice
Medium Wings
Mild Wings

“Great wings with just the right amount of crisp, not soggy and chewy, and not fried to a crisp - just right and medium of delicious, even for the spice wimps like me. Slight kick, but not enough to break a sweat. The pizza is pretty good, too! I ordered two days in a row, and the second day, I asked for it to be left in for an extra 2-3min and it was PERFECT! Crispy bottom that stood straight out, and gooey cheese oozing all over. It was like a taste of home made by friendly, hard-working people.“

4.1 Good28 Reviews
Ye Olde Pizza Pub Pizza • $$
2528 NY-12B, Hamilton

Customers` Favorites

Wings and Taters
Antipasto
Salad Bar
Pizzas
Soda
Boss

“The chicken wings you remember from college are the same and still delicious! We ordered wings and potato logs, both were fresh and flavorful. It was not very busy on a Saturday night late dinner eat in so I hope they are doing better on take outs.“

3.2 Average41 Reviews
Peterboro General Store Deli • $$
4571 Peterboro Rd, Peterboro - 12.03 miles

“Chill out relax and enjoy great food in the Deli on the Green. This is where your favorite grandma and grandpa would go. Everyone smiling full deli salads pies pizza and fair priced with some groceries too. Hours vary with seasons . Great ice cream !!!“

4.7 Superb20 Reviews
Mario's Pizzeria Pizza • $
184 Main St, Oriskany Falls - 8.87 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni and Meatball Calzone
Everyday Pizza Display
Tenders and Fries
Everything Wings
Chicken Riggies
Chicken Parm
Cheese Fries
Garlic Knots
Cheese Pizza
Real Salad

“Happened to run into this pizzeria while traveling and decided to stop in to grab a slice to go. I had a buffalo chicken slice as well as a pepperoni slice, thin crust and absolutely delicious. My boyfriend got a slice of chicken Parm and he just raved about it. He's not a huge fan of thin pizza but really enjoyed the crust. Soft and chewy. Didn't spend time looking over menu but I certainly can vouch for their pizza. Prices were normal for today's pizzerias.“

4 Good25 Reviews
New York Pizzeria Pizza • $
28 Main St, Morrisville - 7.07 miles

Customers` Favorites

The Italian Mixed
Garlic Knots
Panini
Wings
Sauce
Pizza
Roll

“My family ordered pizza, I had a Turkey sub. The pizza was delicious and the sub was AMAZING! The bread is made in house and it's so fresh. Ask for Italian dressing to go with the sub, so good! Inside is small and dated. Service was fast and friendly!“

3.8 Good31 Reviews
Loading...
map Map