Pizza Restaurants near Cooperstown

“Every Columbus Day weekend about 30 members of our tractor club goes to Cooperstown for tractor fest. On Friday evening we order pizza and wings and on Saturday we order catered pans of food. From the minute you place the order to the time you pick up the food, all of the employees are very helpful and extremely pleasant to deal with. They are just genuinely nice people, even though they are always extremely busy. The food is always excellent. In a world of short staffed, frazzled restaurant employees, the staff at New Yok Pizzeria of Cooperstown stand out for their awesome attitudes and excellent service.“

“We dropped in for a slice after visiting the Hall on 9/5/25. Excellent East Coast pizza served in a restaurant that’s incredibly clean! We’re from Michigan, where pizza is served by the pound. Sals was a welcome change in both style and quality.“

“Great place, great staff, great location!!! If you need a quick meal between games this is right across the street from Cooperstown Dreams Park! They accept team pins and if you’re lucky you’ll get to trade with the owner but you better bring your best pins! They also have a 5 second grab blind bucket to get a pin. The Sicilian pizza is pretty good stuff!!!“

“Great and reasonably priced of the NY variety. Off of Main Street so you have to look for it.“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“