8 Best Pizza Restaurants near Conewango Valley

“Stopped for their special beef on Weck platters today and it was hands down the best sandwich ever. Highly recommend this place if your in the area.“

“This place looked small on the outside but has quite a large inside with booths and tables and places to eat outside. It is across from where we fish. They have a menu of subs, pizza, chicken fingers and wings, French fries, hot dogs and hamburgers, and specials. I think the owners live next door in the house. And they have all sorts of ice cream! It's nice to go into a place after fishing, and you are kinda sweaty, and so are most of the customers! It's pretty laid back, is what I am getting at! Hot dogs are good! A small fries was HUGE! The food the other customers received looked great! Not very expensive, either! We now stop here after we are done fishing! They take your order, you pay them, they give you a number, when done making your food they bring it out to you and they are onto the next person. It's a great little spot!Kid-friendliness: Lots of kids there eating ice cream.Parking: Parking in front of restaurant and bait shop next door.Wheelchair accessibility: I think a wheelchair can fit thru the doors. I don't think there are any steps to get into the restaurant.“

“Great atmosphere & friendly staff! Comfortable seating, tables & chairs inside as well as outdoor seating. Handicapped accessable & plenty of parking space. Not really kid friendly due to bar & pool table being located in dining area. Large awesome menu! My husband ordered a cheese quesadilla & I ordered the chicken/cheese/bacon quesadilla and we shared the loaded tator tots! Absolutely delicious!! Portions are generous and we love leftovers! Also offered are daily specials! We will definitely be going back again & again & again! We want to try EVERYTHING! Prices are reasonable. Service is worth the small wait!“

“Omg this is the best Pizza in Western New York. You can argue if you want but I'm not lying. We went with some friends and had a really awesome time. Ed is really sweet and every-time I go in to pick up a pizza, I don't even have to say my name because he knows who it's for. If your in this small community, grab a donut from The South Dayton Supermarket and grab a bite at The Cherry Creek Sun Shop!“

“Good food“

“Love love love the atmosphere!! My boyfriend and I went out last night! Had a couple drinks and got a calzone for dinner. The bartender was very friendly and always made sure we have full drinks! Never a dull moment in conversation which is my biggest bet peev when going to a bar! We genuinely can’t wait to come back!! I can’t believe I’ve been in area so long and never discovered this place!Highly recommend the steak and cheese calzone!!“

“We've had the pepperoni pizza, chicken wing pizza, wings, and hot as well as cold subs. Very good food, no skimping on toppings or meats in subs, perfectly cooked wings, and always friendly, fast service. Can't wait to try some of the other menu items!“

“No frills place but with good food. We were passing by the town and spur of the moment decided to stop here. We got a chicken parm sub and raist beef sub. The roast beef sub was extra good and we could tell the beef was really good quality. We'll probably stop by again when we pass back through.“