Italian Restaurants in Cooperstown

“We live near DC and we traveled to Cooperstown mostly to visit the baseball HOF and, boy were we fortunate to find Toscana's! It was our anniversary night so we had planned on dining at another place that turned out to be closed for the season. We really feel blessed & so thankful that we came across this little gem instead! The service, the food and the lovely ambience were top-notch! Patrick was our greeter/server and he was just so personable and efficient. Like other reviewers, we didn't have a reservation but Patrick welcomed us as tho we did. As business picked up there was no change in his excellent service. Shout out to the classy soundtrack playing throughout our dinner too. Sinatra, Louis Armstrong, Dean Martin...it was all there floating in the background, never interfering with our conversation. The food was SO good too beginning with the artisan bread & oil that was warm and tasty. I had the salmon with mashed potatoes and steamed broccoli. It was superb. My hubby had the baked haddock also with mashed potatoes and broccoli and he loved it. We had pistachio cake for dessert with espresso which topped off our meal perfectly. I wish we lived closer...but next time we are anywhere near beautiful Cooperstown, we'll head over to Toscana's for another great dining experience.“

“Just had dinner after seeing the Glimmerglass lights with my Husband and 2 boys (5 years & 6 months) we walked right in to a table at 730pm on a Saturday, great cocktails, the antipasto board blew us away and the strip and seafood risotto were to die for. Great portions, the renovations are beautiful it is so cozy, yet modern and the different salt and pepper shakers on every table are such a cute touch! We will definitely be back and frequently!! Caesar was an amazing waiter, the service was incredible. Can’t wait to return.“

“We dropped in for a slice after visiting the Hall on 9/5/25. Excellent East Coast pizza served in a restaurant that’s incredibly clean! We’re from Michigan, where pizza is served by the pound. Sals was a welcome change in both style and quality.“