24 Best Italian Restaurants in Utica

“I cannot say enough good things about Joey’s @ 307. From having dinner there for the first time about a year ago, to falling in love with their food and having them cater my wedding, everything they do is amazing. Truly the best chicken parm and chicken marsala I have ever had. They made the entire process easy and stress free (which if you’ve ever planned a wedding you know does not happen often!!). They made sure my husband and I had our own food first to make sure we ate, and made us out own to go meal at the end of the night. Every person I spoke with there was incredibly nice, helpful, and funny! Matt and Kathy helped make our wedding day perfect! Thank you guys again ?“

“Hidden gem! Delicious food & great service. Choices are endless, they work around your eating restrictions that you may have and provide you with suggestions. Owner is friendly and wants you to feel welcome which is very appreciating. Will be back and recommend it to everyone!“

“Food was out of this world. Always the best. Thank you!“

“Love this place!!Another fine tuesday meal at Joes!Thank you all!!!“

“Old school Italian restaurant. Perfect in every way. The service, the food, the atmosphere. If I lived in Utica, these folks would know my name. Was in town for my son’s college graduation and we went on recommendation from my college roommate who grew up in Utica. Can’t wait to come back. Do yourself a favor and memorize the name Ventura’s for when you’re in Utica (especially if you’re a Yankees fan). I am not, but hope they will forgive me!“

“What a nice surprise! Out to dinner for my husband's birthday; Danny did not disappoint! Eight course meal; bean soup, bruschetta and bread, antipasto salad, mussels in garlic wine sauce, greens with beans, eggplant parmesan, sausage in sauce and pasta with meatballs! All so good!! Danny and staff were accommodating and welcoming. We felt like we were having Sunday dinner at Grandma's house. Highly recommend!“

“My family and I loved this little place. Stopped by here on a whim traveling through town, and were pleasantly surprised. Subs, pizza and pasta were all great, and the staff was excellent, especially the front of the house. Inside was small, but clean. Only knock is no public restrooms, but I get why they wouldn't be open. Would definitely recommend this place!“

“We just had an outstanding Dinner with Appetizers ... huge portions with excellent flavor! Excellent service! Very clean and comfortable We would highly suggest having dinner here, I know we will again!!!“

“My friends and I had the most delicious lunch and best service we’ve ever encountered. We get together twice a month and try out different places. This will definitely be a regular for us now! Thank you!!“

“We had a great experience here! We were a group of ten, traveling together, and some of us struggle with speech or physical disabilities. The server was so kind, she took time to understand everyone, explain the menu items. The food was AMAZING!“

“I got the best pizza! My neighbor got gluten free, extra cheese garlic and she said it was the best! My mom and I got dairy free cheese and it was the best! The kids said that it was the best also! Our favorite pizza place!“

“Amazing pizza. Love this place !!!“

“Best Italian sub my husband and I ever had. We are hooked! We got the Italian mixed, fully loaded, and the flavors were incredible.“

“Another fantastic dinner at Nostro! Our 3rd time (We would come more, but we're from CT). Lovely service from Kelly this evening. Very attentive, made good recommendations. We had to get the White Truffle Garlic Bread...Delicious. I went with Spaghetti e Polpette (meatballs). Tasty thick house made spaghetti with a rich pomodoro. The veal meatballs were excellent. Great flavor and super tender. A simple dish that was one of the best I've had. I love Nostro for their focused dishes that don't have to throw the kitchen sink into them to be great. Try the Rigatoni Alla Panna side dish. Amazing! Pair that with their scrumptious Crispy Garlic Brussels Sprouts and your tastebuds will reach nirvana. We finished our meal with the Vanilla Meringue Cake which was fabulous. Just an A+ experience. Thanks Nostro! Wish we lived closer, but we will be back!“

“I have eaten their food for years! Always a worthy stop. The best Tomato Pie.“

“I live in NC these days but whenever I’m here a dinner at The Willows is mandatory. Not only is the food exceptional but the staff is great.“

“Friendly staff and awesome food. Luv this place.“

“I ordered a tray of chicken francaise and hats/broccoli for an 85th birthday party, the chicken was amazing as was the pasta. I highly recommend Rosa’s for your catering needs! Thank you to Rosa’s!“

“Never a bad meal at Ancora! I brought my aunt and uncle from out of town there for dinner last night and they said the food was amazing and it’s the best restaurant in Utica! They can’t wait to come back to town to be able to go!
I also had my bridal shower there last month and everything was perfection. The food, the service, the atmosphere. Just perfect. They were very accommodating. My guests are still raving about the food! Thank you Ancora!“

“The pizza, fries, and garlic bread were all delicious. The staff was very friendly and the overall feel was very comfortable with everyone in a good mood. On top of all that the prices were good as you get alot of food for your money, I'll have leftovers for a while. Thanks again!“

“Asked if I'd recommend. Well... I didn't want to hit no because maybe it was just an off day with the chef. Everybody has one. Husband enjoyed his Chicken Parmesan, Utica Greens were good (1st time eating them). My Chicken Salvatore was dry and hard. Not enough sauce to even try to soften it up to make the dish enjoyable. Way overcooked. I guess the green beans and mashed potatoes were good. Might go back to see if it was just a fluke. Might not.. who knows.“

“We ordered the pizza and wing special, it was excellent!“

“Sat at the bar because I was traveling for business. Good atmosphere at the bar. Great attentive service and the food was fantastic.“

“Lunch @Babes today. Exceeded expectations! Patio service was very pleasant and professional. Unfortunately extremely long wait time for food assume due to number of customers. Most striking was the cleanliness of everything….Silverware, tables, glasses. Food was fresh, hot - plated properly and neatly. Would definitely visit again.“