10 Best Italian Restaurants in New Hartford

“very slow lunch service.“

“Dave Morgan is #1 in my book. Catered my daughter s wedding on October 9, 2022. Not one stone was left unturned. The food was dead on and the service he provided was fantastic! You will not be disappointed when Dave Morgan and his crew roll in! Dave is all about what you the client wants. Just say it and he does it to a T! Thank you Dave for all you did for us❤️“

“First experience here and it’s a go to! Started with the very tempting desserts and coffee while we waited for the birthday company. O M G the customer service, loved the staff!“

“Visited with family a few weekends ago..
Ordered veal piccata, fried scallops, and chicken Marsala. Each dish was outstanding. The veal and the Marsala were easily the BEST we’ve EVER had while dining out! The service was outstanding as well. As far as we’re concerned, Cafe del Buono is the greater Utica area's finest Italian restaurant- and that’s really saying something considering the wealth of excellent alternatives. Highly recommend!“

“Great Pizza“

“Had a great experience at Olive Garden, the waitress were friendly and served with a friendly smile. Thank you Alyssa H ., and Theresa for serving us. The food was great especially the steak! And my drink was awesome. Great service, great food, and clean. Olive Garden is a great place to dine with your loved ones. Thank you again Olive Garden !“

“I just learned about how with the restaurant full of customers while the power went out. They comped every meal. Small town values right there“

“I haven't been here in 10 years, and I just so Happened to Pull in today, and it is just phenomenal, Ive had Haddock from Just About every Restaurant, Ive been too, and this is 100% the Best.
We Orded the Chicken Ann Marie , Haddock Au Gratin , Risotto Bites and the Bruschetta. And Every is Amazing, the Risotto Bites and the Bruschetta, was Some of the best Appetizers I have Every Had.
The Haddock was Just Great, you didn't even Have to Chew, it just Melts in your mouth. And the Chicken was also Great, Very Tender and Flavorful.
Atmosphere and Service was also very Good.
Price is Normal nothing to Crazy. For the Atmosphere, it is definitely a Sit Down Type of restaurant.
All in all, if your Looking for a GREAT Italian Restaurant this is the Place to go.“

“The food was amazing and hot! i had the alfredo it was really good !“

“All-you-can--eat pasta on Monday nights is amazing...any type of pasta and choice of sauce! I love the oil and garlic, or their marinara sauce.“