15 Best Pizza Restaurants near Elba

“I have ordered from this place a couple of times already and me and my family have been stuck on there pizza. My wife loves it and so does my kids. The pizza is extremely good and the staff is amazing. Best pizza in the area for sure. Hands down. You will have a loyal customer with us. It’s worth the 12 min drive every time from Batavia.“

“I ordered a chicken finger sub last night. No lie, it was the best sub I’ve ever had. Great job“

“Great food & great service!“

“I LOVE ALL THEIR FOOD. MY BEST FRIEND JASON PANGRAZIO TOOK ME HERE IN THE 90S FOR FOOD IT WAS AMAZING 😍🤩 THEN I TOOK MY BABE BRUNO DURYEA THERE AND HE FELL IN LOVE WITH THEIR FOOD. HES FROM NUNDA. HE WAS SHOCKED HOW DELICIOUS THEIR FOOD WAS. COMING FOR FOOD THIS WEEK SHELLS. DONT LET ANY ONE BRING YA DOWN. YOU GOT THIS!“

“Love coming here. Really home town feel, lots of sports memorabilia on the walls, super friendly service and food is ALWAYS on point!“

“Wings are killer!!! Great hidden gem“

“I’ve eaten at many pizza places over the years, but ordered pizza and wings from Fullerinos today, and the pizza was the absolute best I’ve had to this date. They really made my day with the excellent care they took making this food for us. Thanks to the staff for such a great job!“

“Best Pizza in Batavia! Friendly service and great food!“

“It's a plain atmosphere with good conversation amongst locals and the interior looks the exact same as it always has. The sauce was delicious, the cheese was stretchy and melty. The crust had a nice crunch yet soft at the same time. The customer service was professional and helpful. My partner asked for extra cheese. If you want to eat the pizza from a Goofy movie, order with extra cheese, it looks the exact same! It's not really a necessity tho. I definitely recommend!“

“Best Pizza around hands down. We've had every slice from every joint around Genesee County. If you haven't tried Mattys, do yourself a favor and order one from them. You won't be disappointed.“

“I had my bridal shower here on the patio and it was absolutely perfect!! Mary grace was super helpful and easy to work with while planning. They allowed us to come in early to set up and were extremely attentive during the entire shower!! Food was absolutely delicious and everything went perfectly 😀“

“Every time I eat here the owner and their employees take care of every aspect of my order with care. I always receive the best service and always feel important every time I walk in the door. Thank you to to the owner and all your employees for your help.“

“We love Ficarella's. I can't recall any time we've had an issue because we keep going back. We got dinner from them 2 times this week and both times our order was 100% correct. Their online ordering is super simple and allows you to make almost any modification you want. They also have a drive up window if you can't/don't want to go inside.“

“The pizza flavor was good but the bottom and the plate itself was covered in carbon and burnt residue. I understand the concept of a homemade, and or wood-fired oven, but this is not a conspiracy or a suspicion; it is a confirmed fact that these black parts of food contain acrylamide, a confirmed carcinogen. Furthermore, the charring left a tar-like aftertaste.

Fix that, i want to con back with my family“

“We can't say enough good things about the young men that were running the store. Very pleasant, helpful, courtesy. Great customer service all around. Oh and of course Domino's pizza is always good. Haven't have their food in years and it still is one of the best. Thank you 😊“