Restaurants near Elma Center

“Omg, this is such a total hidden gem of a place! Don’t let looks fool you - Marty’s has some amazing food!! The fries were fresh cut and so delicious, and the pot roast sandwich really is great! Definitely don’t drive past this place if you’re in the area! Our server was super nice and attentive too.”

“Amazing 🤩 😋”

“Best Pizza in the area. Tastes like the way I remember pizza to tast.”

“Outstanding from beginning to end. Best food I've ever had. Service was wonderful too. Highly recommend the short rib and calamari.”

“Maybe we were overhyped. Everything I heard and read said this place was legendary. But the menu was limited: beef on Weck and buffalo wings... or if you want a pizza, you can get the same options but on a crust with cheese. Otherwise, fairly standard sports bar apps.
The inside seemed too dark for a lunch, and the 'outside' area with lots of snow was crowded. Service was polite, but slow for such a small menu. We're told the place always gets a wait by noon and yet it takes 25 minutes to get your food even with so few options for entrees seems uncalculated and unnecessarily slow.
Food was good, but I'd say I've had equal quality wings and sauce at a bit fairer price. And the beef on weck seemed on par with Charlie the butcher, but comes with a handful of chips, not fries, at $15 for just the sandwich? I couldn't go 5 stars. Cost of business, I suppose

Parking: Big lot hidden behind the snow bank, but the access wasn't easy to locate.”

“95Nutrition always has a good selection of meals in both large and small portions, the menu rotates, and they make great protein shakes in store. The only complaint I would say is that many of the wraps or flatbreads lack filling or protein where more could be added so that it’s an even ratio. Friendly staff and they have specials and happy hour sales regularly. 4 stars”

“The best coffee/menu, plus they have the biggest hearts and are always giving back to their community!! 🫶🏼🫶🏼🫶🏼”

“Best BBQ I’ve had by far! The menu is amazing and I’m sure ALL of the food on the menu is delicious. However, being one with Celiacs Disease I’m only allowed certain thing. Im here to RAVE about the Brunswick Stew and the loaded brisket nachos. The portions are generous. I order the stew every time I stop in. It’s that amazing!! IF you’ve not ever been to TSG’s I would highly recommend you stopping on over there. In my opinion they blow BW’s away!”

“Amira is so friendly and the food was excellent- fresh and hot. We tried the baba gannouj, maakeesh zaatar, kibbie and shawarma roll. Highly recommend”

“Very good tacos amazing staff.”

“We just ordered a wonderful take-out dinner from Mario’s! His homemade meatball bomber was satisfying and bursting with Italian flavor and creative touches…it was also packed with meatballs from the first bite to the last! We added homemade minestrone soup and cannolis to our order and both were comforting and satisfying. We’ll be back! There’s no reason “not to go to Mario’s”!”

“Great food - Great service - and amazing remodel of the Country Peddler!! - highly recommend!!”

“Great hospitality and great people!!!”

“Just looking for an Almond Ring in Western New York. Found Eileen’s…oh my they did not disappoint! It was made just how I remember in my youth. When entering the bakery, the choices were bountiful. Peanut sticks, pastry hearts, bear claws, oh yum. Next time I’m in the area , it’s straight to Eileen’s. The location was easy to get to and hop back on the interstate or 400. Kudos to the friendly staff too.”

“First off, I just want to say I do love your pizza and it’s refreshing to see a local restaurant that doesn’t sling the same style of Buffalo pizza that so many others do. I really think you guys need a full-service bar with taps and interesting cocktails. I feel your business would skyrocket if you had a larger building that could accommodate a big boy bar. I’ve lived and traveled all over and one place that would be worth a visit for you is Savoy in West Hartford, CT. They nail the business model of artisan pizzeria and cocktail bar. Either way, decent attempt at an operation and happy to have you in EA.”

“Drove from New Hampshire today with family on a continuing mission to explore strange new burgers. Rock Burger has to be at least tied for my favorite burger to date. Perfectly cooked, seasoned, absolutely delicious. And how do they stay in business giving these masterpieces away for next to nothing?”

“Good food and consistent. Nice service in addition. I recommend trying them, you will not be disappointed!!”

“Best Eggs Benedict in the area!!! I dined today with my toddler and appreciated the new (?) high chair. The straps were tight and the y-buckle was more secure. We love Poked Yolk 😁”

“Was there for a date night on October 12th and dinner and dessert was fabulous as always and after dessert my boyfriend proposed to me so it was a great date night!”

“Excellent food, perfectly cooked, generous portions!! Well priced . Pleasant surroundings and very well maintained facilities. Ample space and easy accessible for handicapped.”

“wow! there is no other Mexican good in WNY that is this good or has such an extensive menu. Nopales, sopa, tongue. it is very popular too - we got the last table on a Thursday at 545 - line out the door when we left. Efficient service, cold Modelos...HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!”

“It took 1hr to cook wings &salad? Bill was 37$, gave bar dude 50$ ask me if I needed change? 13$ tip wtf”

“Fresh ingredients, good food, and good service ❤️”

“We come from Lancaster(I know, not that far) But, my little girls dentist is out in EA. When they have their appointments, we make it a treat to stop in at BEB every time. my girls LOVE picking out 2 Macarons each and eating them asap. Staff is always friendly and the facility always clean. We look forward to these visits and will continue to stop in for a special treat. Oh, and they love the little kitchen play area.”

“Very delicious, clean and friendly atmosphere.”

“Sweet Jenny’s is a staple for our family. We never have a holiday table without chocolate from here. Teacher gifts are a must. Summer ice cream trips making memories! Everything here is amazing, including the owners. If your visiting the Buffalo area this place is a must see, we always bring out of towners here! Thanks for being such an awesome part of our community!”

“Walking into this bakery and seeing that I could eat ANYTHING that I wanted -- that I didn't have to be scared that I'd get sick, that I didn't have to limit myself to just one or two items that might not even be what I wanted -- y'all, I almost started crying. Just the relief of it, and knowing that someone cared enough to turn their entire bakery gluten-free. That means so much more than you can imagine. And the food was so good that we went here three times during our week-long stay in the area. In fact, we plan to order from them and have it shipped to us now that we're back home. Highly recommended!”

“Our daughter’s 50th birthday tea party was everything she hoped for, and we planned for during the last month. Her choices at Ginger Snap Patisserie catering we couldn’t have been happier. The food and service Sara and Cassidy provided was perfect and truly special. Affordable for how good of quality they are. The process was easy to order, and it was ready exactly when they said it would be! Thank you to the catering staff!”

“I love going to Nanas because their food is legit and always fresh. I feel good being there because it is very peaceful. I feel good leaving because it is healthy. And their Baklava is the best!!!”

“I found this Mediterranean restaurant on the internet. I enjoy Lebanese, Greek, Turkish, Syrian and Indian cuisine. The food is healthy and delicious. I called in for take-out and every was ready in 30 minutes. Very busy and that's a good sign. I'll be back>”