Custom Cakes near Farmingville, NY

“This is about Tres Leche cake that I recently ordered. For full disclosure, I haven't tasted it but I am still giving this place a full thumbs up. Here is the context. We had our son's birthday and needed an urgent delivery order. He lives on Long Island while we are in Manhattan. He specifically asked for a Tres Leche case. I called Paisa Pan on the day of his birthday (around 11am) and asked if they could deliver it by end of the day. They promised the delivery by 2pm. It was actually delivered around 1:15pm. Our son absolutely loved it. These guys are terrific!!“

“Cake Fairyland did such an awesome job designing a Studio Ghibli birthday cake for me! When I saw the cake for the first time my mouth dropped and I couldn't believe how perfect it looked, it was even better than I could have imagined. The staff were very helpful and courteous and made my experience so memorable. Truly above and beyond! Will definitely order again!!“

“Every time I order anything, from pastries to event cakes, The Rolling Pin never disappoints! This past event was my daughter-in-law’s baby shower. I sent David a picture of what I wanted and it was better than the picture! My family will be a forever customer here! Paulette “

“Five stars definitely she made a beautiful amazing delicious cake for my daughter’s baby shower with macaroons and chocolate covered pretzels everything came out delicious. Everything was done perfectly in a timely manner. The lady that made the cake was just amazing and so polite and just as sweet as her cake. If you’re looking for a delicious beautiful cake or sweets , she’s the person to go to.“

“My husband and I finally got a chance to try this place today and oh is it soooo worth it! I’m pregnant (only 10 and a half weeks) and the strawberry shortcake cupcake is a cupcake version of the ice cream and perfect! My husband loved his chocolate overload cupcake! Now I have a new pregnancy craving that I need to get often! Definitely can’t wait to go back!!!!!“

“My Mom passed away almost two years ago. To celebrate her memory we ordered from her favorite bakery and they did not disappoint. I remember she loved coming here for our birthdays and holidays. As a young teenager it was always a special treat for me and my siblings when mom came home with boxes of Benkert's goodies.This bakery will always remind me of mom, and the joy we felt.Loving memories from the Myers family“

“This bakery is the absolute BEST!!!! The owner goes above and beyond for her customers. You will have some customers that will always leave negative reviews even though nothing was done wrong on the owners part. You actually have to take the negative reviews and let them go and actually see where they are coming from. It is usually a person that constantly leaves negative reviews for many places as to they are just a a complainer and maybe looking for items for free. This community all knows how excellent this bakery is and how hard the owner works!“

“Honestly the best frozen yogurt and the best toppings anywhere! Employees are nice and courteous!!!Kid-friendliness: Always come here after my son and daughter's school concerts. Filled with parents and a lot of kids. The owner and the employees are super professional even with 30+ kids running around .“

“Great froyo flavor selections. I went with the lf vanilla and strawberry. Was very impressed with the creaminess of the froyo, very tasty despite being low fat. Owner was very cool, helped my wife sample some ice cream flavors and was helpful with topping selections. Will definitely be going back. Prices are a bit higher than other froyo places I’ve visited, but I don’t mind paying if it’s worth it. Definitely worth coming here and spending a bit more.“

“Love this place!! From the moment you pull up, they have great curb appeal. Very cute place!! Inside is just as cute!! Clean and clearly lots of pride!! Ice cream was soooo good! Not overly sweet. Not too rich. And Good flavor. Lots of variety on the menu. Looking forward to going back!“