6 Best American Restaurants near Henderson

“Had a great breakfast at Cherry Tree Inn. It was packed on a Sunday morning; lucky for me I was dining solo and could eat at the counter. Had a great pancake and eggs breakfast cooked perfectly. My coffee cup was never empty. Price was reasonable ($13.50 plus tip) considering what restaurants are charging now. I probably will be back again tomorrow for breakfast.“

“Dinner on a Friday night was amazing! The restaurant was slammed but we scored a table for 2 on the patio. Our waitress was amazing and our drinks and food were delivered quickly. The food was delicious!! I was amazed that as busy as they were we got steaming ,hot food with seafood that was cooked to perfection! The staff there are just on fire! Highly recommend!!“

“We stumbled upon this charming spot in Sackets Harbor during our travels. We treated ourselves to a delightful selection of coffee, including drip coffee and iced coffee, paired with a scrumptious muffin. Although we only indulged in the muffin, its freshness was unmistakable. While the prices for the coffee were on the higher side, the quality certainly did not disappoint. A lovely spot to savor freshly brewed coffee and immerse oneself in the surroundings. Additionally, there are cozy seats available to unwind and relish your coffee to the fullest.“

“First, it is a diner. It has cute diner atmosphere. Good food, decent selection, great bullhead fry in season. Great breading on the fish fry, which is the 'make-or-break' for that dish. Desserts are also a decent size. One note- coffee is weak (Jan.2024).“

“This place is so perfect!! We came to visit our son and decided to try this quaint restaurant and we were so happy we did!! The service was so welcoming and the food was absolutely delicious!! We are definitely going back before we leave Sackets Harbor!!“

“As others have said, this is a place with a beautiful spot for a view. We visited in high season so we went early for dinner and were able to get a great table with a gorgeous vista. The food was decent but not what I would call "special" or gourmet but combined with the excellent service and view, we enjoyed our experience. We asked for a few minor modifications to our meals and they were happy to oblige. We would definitely go back.“