12 Best American Restaurants in Alexandria Bay

“🍦 5 Stars – Amazing Ice Cream & Even Better Service! Gal’s Place Ice Cream is the perfect spot for a sweet treat, but what truly sets it apart is the incredible service from Emmy Claire and Josie. Every time we visit, they go above and beyond—friendly, fast, and always with a smile. They make the experience so enjoyable and memorable. Honestly, they’re the kind of employees any business would be lucky to have… and they definitely deserve a raise for all they do! Thank you, Emmy Claire and Josie—you make Gal’s Place the best around!“

“Warm, friendly atmosphere with welcoming people made the visit special, and the Toasted Caramel Apple Butter Latte was cozy, and absolutely delicious today!“

“Quality food and excellent service staff. The staff were knowledgable about the menu as well as friendly and engaging. Food was cooked exactly as requested.“

“I had a mixed experience at Windows on the Bay. The biggest highlight is definitely the view, it's absolutely stunning. .
We had a bit of a delay when they couldn't find our dinner reservation on their list but the staff ended up handling it well and found us a great outdoor table. The service throughout the evening was friendly and pleasant, although it was very slow. Since it was a busy holiday, we understood and were happy to be patient.

Unfortunately, dinner itself was just okay. My meal was average, the fish was a bit overcooked and dry. The biggest disappointment was the music. There was a DJ when we arrived but they ended the music much earlier than expected, and once it stopped, the energy completely disappeared. It felt like the evening lost its momentum. However sitting outside overlooking the bay as the fireworks began over Boldt Castle on the Fourth of July ended up making for a perfect evening.

Breakfast the next morning was a completely different experience. It was quiet, peaceful, and relaxing, with beautiful views of the boats passing by on the bay. The food and atmosphere were much more enjoyable and made for a wonderful start to the day.“

“Theeeee best poutine! OMG, it’s sooooo delicious! 😋 The waitresses/bartenders are super friendly and efficient! I highly recommend this restaurant when you’re in the Alexandria Bay area!“

“This place turned out to be a blast, Great service from the staff especially our waiter Chris. We were a rowdy crowd and he took it all in stride! A great time was had by all!“

“Nice place, accommodating of families. That had indoor seating with window A/C. The food was good and at the price point I would expect in a tourist town during the summer. I found the service to be good. I recommend them and would definitely go back.“

“They have yummy ice cream and every kind of candy you can think of. They are usually very busy. We only went there once this trip. Most trips there are daily visits. This trip we stopped at a different ice cream shop once or twice! Is it any wonder that I bring some extra pounds back home with me?🍨🍦“

“The Food is Amazing! The price is fair (better than average for Alex-Bay), the service is great, and the atmosphere is perfect! This is the best place to eat in A-Bay!“

“The old Hampstead restaurant in Alexandria Bay was superb. The staff is most friendly, and great address immediately. We ordered the lobster with spinach, lobster Florentine I believe, and it was absolutely delicious. We substituted rice for mashed potatoes. It came with a salad. We ordered bread and had a delightful dinner. We did sit outside and it was a lovely evening. When I visit Alexandria Bay again, it will definitely be on my list of best restaurants to revisit.“

“😊I have eaten here many times, especially summer and deep into fall. We bring family. We bring friends from out of state. We find the menu consistently creative, lots of choices, many things to like. Hard to pick a favorite, but like fish tacos and paninis, plus apps. Some of the desserts can be just awesome. I'll be there again at least several times this summer. Always find the people nice and welcoming. I have had lunch (mostly) and dinner, and even met for business of a non-profit there. It is a favorite place on the river.“

“We had a wonderful time. we are coming back for the Duprees.“