The Stuffed American (Hidden Gem)

$ • Cafe

Hours:
Lower Level of Building, 275 Broadhollow Rd, Melville
(631) 390-5912

About The Stuffed American (Hidden Gem)

The Hidden Gem Cafe offers a delightful dining experience with a fresh, high-quality menu featuring a mix of lunch, breakfast, and sides. The restaurant's selection includes starters like spring rolls and baguette, as well as main courses like a beef soup noodle dish and the popular egg coffee for dessert. Customers praise the cafe's cool, instagrammable decor and clean, welcoming atmosphere. Located in the basement of a bank building, this true hidden gem serves consistently great food, including the best egg sandwich in the area and crispy toasted sandwiches with fresh ingredients. With unmatched prices and amazing catering options, it’s a must-visit for breakfast and lunch. Many wish they had a location in Florida too!

Customers' Favorites

Recent Reviews

4.9
175 ratings
Restaurantji Rating
5
93%
4
4%
1
3%
Food
4.9
Atmosphere
4.8
Service
4.9

Share your opinion about The Stuffed American (Hidden Gem)

Restaurantji Rating

We worked the same event yesterday and I knew right away I would be visiting them for my lunch! So amazing and the ladies were super friendly! I tried the Taco, Bacon Mac & Cheese, Philly Cheesesteak, and Banana Nutella. I Hope to see them at another event soon so I can try the other flavors (I heard the spinach artichoke is a must have!)

We stopped by last night on a whim and boy were we blown away. We met Kerri & Kelly who were super helpful. We got the honey bbq chicken and fig, honey & goat cheese wonton to try when we got home and we bought a couple of frozen bags to have over the holidays.

Love the food. So creative. So good. easy to cook up. Delicious.

Read All Reviews(175)

Menu

Add a Menu
The Stuffed American (Hidden Gem) Menu
The Stuffed American (Hidden Gem) Menu

Photos

Add a Photo
The Stuffed American (Hidden Gem)
The Stuffed American (Hidden Gem)
View All Photos

Hours

Monday 8AM - 3PM
Tuesday 8AM - 3PM
Wednesday 8AM - 3PM
Thursday Closed
Friday Closed
Saturday Closed
Sunday Closed
Updated on: