7 Best Sandwich Shops near Ithaca

Gorgers Sandwich Shop • $
116 W State St, Ithaca

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch
Philly Cheesesteak
Bacon Cheese Fries
Chicken Sandwich
Buffalo Chicken
Coconut Shrimp
Pulled Pork Sub
Shrimp PO Boy
French Fries
Fried Pickles

“Best place for a sub!! We love it here“

4.5 Superb74 Reviews
Firehouse Subs Ithaca Sandwich Shop • $
740 S Meadow St #1100, Ithaca

Customers` Favorites

Firehouse Steak & Cheese Medium 7-8 Inch
Firehouse Meatball Medium 7-8 Inch
Grilled Cheddar Cheese Kids Combo
Smokehouse Beef & Cheddar Brisket
Firehouse Steak & Cheese Sub
Smokehouse Cheddar Brisket
Turkey Bacon Ranch Sub
Submarine Sandwiches
Firehouse Hero Small
Firehouse Hero Medium

“To be clear, this 5 star review is based upon the service of an employee named Skyler. The food is good (quite expensive) but good. This employee made everyone feel welcome from the moment they walked in the door, until the moment they walked out. In between orders, he was checking on the diners to see how they were enjoying their food. Great positive attitude and demeanor. I would hire them at my business.“

4 Good51 Reviews
DiBella's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
222 Elmira Rd, Ithaca

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich on the New Rye Bread Roll
Godfather Sub on Everything Bread
Grandma DiBella's Cookies
Deli Salads \u0026 Pickles
DiBella's Cheesesteak
Italian Meatball
Italian Assorted
The Italian Sub
Turkey

“for the love of all sandwich please open shop in Dansville ny. no good sandwiches in 50 miles any direction. save the stateworkers stomaches! this is no joke. these people need sandwich heros. they need people who care about food. I've read your requirements and I consider how it seems to you that the location is not qualifyable. I'm telling you though those numbers are meaningless along a state highway that holds the crossroads to the center of all directions the hungry deprived people will come. please help this neglected part of New York and revolutionize food for some of the hardest working men and women. it's a travesty what people slap as a sandwich here. a crime against humanity we need a godfather for food!“

3.7 Good64 Reviews
Atrium Cafe Cafe • $
Sage Ave, Ithaca

“? Yummy Alert! ?The crab and corn soup is soooooo tasty! Try it.Layout of the food area is a bit odd which creates a bad logistical flow for people getting food and those exiting with their food. Also, the staff are seemingly unfriendly and I swear I thought the guy serving in the hot food section was going to drip sweat into the curry. The older lady next to him served the rice so sloppy. The dish looked ugly because of how it was served and presented and so I left it. But, the crab and corn soup is fantastic!“

5 Superb2 Reviews
Jimmy John's Sandwich Shop • $
122 N Aurora St, Ithaca

Customers` Favorites

Gourmet Veggie Club
Real Potato Chips
Slim

“This is A smaller Sub Sandwich Shop on North Aurora and just around the corner from the Ithaca Commons.. The Sub's are made to Order right in front of You.. This is the one-way part of Aurora Street , so You will Have to get there on foot , after You park somewhere. Jimmy John's Does Deliver.“

3.8 Good9 Reviews
6

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
401 Elmira Rd Suite 1, Ithaca

“My daughter and I entered around 4:50pm to order a footlong baja chicken sub. Sierra was the only employee working. She immediately greeted us and let us know that she has 3 subs to make ahead of us. We patiently waited and the cashout was around 5:40pm. Her level of patience, and accuracy of my sub was nothing short of amazing. She maintained a positive attitude as more customers walked in and to-go orders were printing non-stop. Give this girl a raise. Sierra, the sub was delicious, thank you.“

3.3 Good16 Reviews
7

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
40 Catherwood Rd Space C16, Ithaca

Customers` Favorites

Subway Club
Cookies
3 Average10 Reviews

You May Also Like