12 Best Pizza Restaurants in Jamestown

“Pizza and wings were delicious. Prices were great too.“

“They've got the best pizza and wings hands down! The service could be a little more friendly, but it's only a takeout place and they're super busy. On a Friday, we waited over an hour for a large pizza and 20 wings. But if you have the time (we always call ahead ) then go with Lena's!!!

Parking: Off street free parking right beside it or you can street park for free directly in front of Lena's.“

“We've been coming to Pace's Pizza for many years. It has always been great, but since new ownership has taken over, it is even better! Great staff, owner (Joe) always stops by the table, and the Pizza is by far the best around. We are summer residents and drive in from Mayville many times each summer, as Pace's is a family favorite for all of our visitors. I highly recommend you give it a try!“

“First time trying this establishment. We ordered the 2 pizza, and 50 wing special. We ordered extra so to have for the playoff games today as it happens to be our only day off.. well I do healthcare so do have to work a couple of hours.. but anyway.. The wings and service were both excellent… as for the pizza it looked great but will have to wait for my son’s family to attest for the human taste buds because we also bought enough to share with his family - I CAN say tho that my dogs thought the pizza scrumptious as they pulled ours off our back table overnight and devoured the entire thing. So much for for our meals today… & we are both bummed. 🤷🏼‍♀️ We wouldn’t hesitate in the future purchasing dinner at Perfect pizza.“

“One of the best pizzas I've ever had. Just the right amount of sauce to cheese. Crust was perfectly baked. Service was terrific. The server was very responsive and accommodating, but she also knew when to stay away and let my party enjoy ourselves. It's a small place with out a lot of pizzazz, which was perfect for our group. My conclusion is that yes, Honest John's is an honest place.“

“We had a wonderful meal! I appreciated that they were willing to make a vegan pasta dish for me at my request. It was delicious! We will definitely be back!“

“Ordered a chicken finger sub with jalapenos and it was awesome! Very happy with it! Also has deep fried pickles that were great too! Will order from them again!“

“I would recommend trying Wicked Warren. The pizza is usually very good. However, I just picked up a pickle bacon pizza which I usually love and it raw in the center, the pickles cold, and it had no spices or taste of being baked in a wood fire. I've had their pizza many times and never had one made like this. I almost called to have it corrected but have other plans. the bacon appetizer is just fat and had to be tossed. I'm not sure if this was a new cook, but it was very disappointing.“

“People in Olean want a Wegmans, but Olean apparently can’t even sustain a Park n Shop anymore as of the past year. So we just go on over to Jamestown to go to Wegmans. There are several different Wegmans to go to in this particular federal probation district so I will inform the rest of my fellow undercover agents where to find potential probation violators if they go to a Wegmans outside their probation region.“

“Our first time trying Sauce we got a takeout. I love a proper neapolitan thin crust pizza and theirs is amazing, we had the prosciutto one and it is now probably my favorite pizza place in town. It was very large too. My husband got himself a chicken parm which he thoroughly enjoyed as well. We will be coming back for more for sure. Would love to dine in next time instead. Only thing that's a little inconvenient is the fact they're only open 4 days a week (closed sundays) and they close already at 7:30 PM.“

“Using pinpoint delivery was Great! Let you know when your pizza goes in the oven when it's out and when it's out for delivery and then you can track it all the way to you. The delivery drivers I've had were helpful. Respectful and professional. They make good pieces, I've always liked Domino's and the only issue I have is without any promotions or coupons? It's just way too expensive For one large pizza for one person, let alone an entire family. The only time I order from Domino's anymore is if they have coupons and promotions.“