“You can always depend on a great meal with Cookie!!!”
“Easy to get around with an electric cart.”
“What a vi ew! And the drinks are great too! Oh! don’t forget the food! Mushroom pizza and smoked wings! Ahhhmazing. Dog friendly outside is a plus!”
Customers` Favorites
“Although there was a benefit going on that weekend and they were extremely busy, the pizza and wings were perfection!!! We will have to get over that way more often. Absolutely recommended! Thank you”
Customers` Favorites
“Best pizza ..... period.”
Customers` Favorites
“The staff is always friendly and the Sunday Sundaes are delicious!”
Customers` Favorites
“I have the pleasure of eating here regularly during the summer months and they are the sweetest family. I'm Always met with the warmest of greetings. Not a better place in Trumansburg to fill your belly! Walk out feeling the love ♥️”
Customers` Favorites
“What a wonderful little inviting restaurant! Becky is awesome and greets you with a smile. She offers each person entering two options to sit down at the booth of their liking. I love the fact that the restaurant promotes locally grown and sourced foods and proudly displays the small farms and businesses' names on its wall. Copper Horse Coffee Roasters coffee is served and Mojo's Sauce is readily available on each table. The food is served hot and fresh and is very reasonably priced! Thank you Becky and The Ithaca Food Dude for your generosity for the gift card! I will be back!:)”
“What an amazing place. We had the best time with Russ. He is very knowledgeable, friendly, funny and just made our day. Unfortunately the deli was closed, but Russ referred us to Aurora Brewing, next door, who had a fabulous fire pizza. Delicious. Hard to pick a favorite wine, they were all absolutely wonderful at Long Point Winery!!!!!”
“Haven’t been in this space since it was the Rongo, but so glad to have been able to finally try it out today, and wow we were so happy we did! Friendly, helpful service, great beer, and amazingly tasty food!! Cannot wait for a return visit soon!”
Customers` Favorites
“Big portion salad with different kinds of local veggies.
Chicken and lamb Gumbo fit my mom’s Asian taste.
I also had truffle all flavor, orange type is should try.”
Customers` Favorites
“Fish Fry Friday, awesome meal cooked perfectly! Portion size is great as well. Best Fish around.”
Customers` Favorites
“We drive from Bedminster to this place every year and it gets better every time, we took the tour with Hannah and she made us feel the magic and love that this place puts in their Cider Craft. Try everything but make sure that besides the cider you eat here have the Board and the pulled pork! And take a bottle of Pommeau home”
“Just went there on Sunday and got the sausage, olive, and onion pizza and chips. It was one of the best pizzas I ever had! The chips were really good too! I highly recommend this place.”
Customers` Favorites
“The food was absolutely amazing and the service I received was even better. Food was fresh and cooked in a timely fashion. The bartenders were extremely nice. I would give them 10 stars if I could , fried pickles amazing , chicken park amazing , chicken wings prob best in town. Will be becoming a regular here !”
Customers` Favorites
“First time eating here and absolutely loved it!! Had the breakfast sandwich on a bagel. Huge portion and great price!! We’ll definitely be back!!”
Customers` Favorites
“We just had the best time! Capped off our Christmas Eve shopping at Rogues. Food was great! Crispy wings with mixed garlic parm and medium sauces and their steak fries! Nice beer selections and FANTASTIC service! Thanks for a great experience!”
Customers` Favorites
“Clean, good meals, fair prices, straightforward diner atmosphere.”
Customers` Favorites
“I grew up in New Rochelle, NY and thus got to go to NYC quite often. For me, NYC pizza can't be topped. This place and Franco's in downtown Ithaca are about as close to NYC Pizza as it gets without actually Being NYC Pizza!
A couple of bonuses here are:
-the house salad always has beautiful, fresh and crispy lettuce (I've experienced much of the opposite from multiple pizzarias out here) as well as the best variety of fresh veggies to go along with it
-the portions of the Tiramisu are for one, delicious but also Generous. Especially for $5!
Occasionally, they may be understaffed and there may be a wait. Stay patient and kind - it's worth the wait!”
Customers` Favorites
“We were the very first customers of the 2026 season and I was overjoyed that they had a vegan flavor (cookies and cream) and topped it with peanut butter and peanuts.”
Customers` Favorites
“Had the blue plate special, roast beef, corn and mashed potatoes. Apple crisp with vanilla ice cream for dessert. Very good family restaurant. Will return.”
Customers` Favorites
“excellent customer service 👏 hometown favorite and the food I'm top notch !!!”
Customers` Favorites
“As a vegan I don't usually F with places that serve animal parts, I don't trust cross contamination. However Angela informed me that they have a separate fryer for vegan and gluten free!! So I gave it a shot and was every pleased with Mt Nashville Hot Tofu sandwich and tater tots. Angela was a fantastic server and Todd, the manager, is a super cool guy!! I would definitely dine here again!! It's so rare that I can go to a trivia night as a vegan and actually eat anything.”
Customers` Favorites
“Random find as we were in the area. Very pleasant surprise as we popped in on “fancy dinner night”, so it was pretty packed but they found spot for us and we had a few beers and some delicious appetizers (Rueben tater kegs were delicious). Service was friendly and fast. Highly recommended!! Even got a hat!”
“We always love to stop in and play pool, thank you for the free birthday shot! 🥃”
Customers` Favorites
“My daughter and I love coming here and just sharing a delicious scoop of the best ice cream in town! Definitely worth it”
“I am proud to recommend Mrs Craig Vanessa for a selfless and reliable investment service. I was constantly looking for a reliable platform to invest and my friend introduced me to her platform and I realized this is the best platform to invest on because she maintains discipline in her investment relationship and strategies to ensure the complete transparency and credibility of her investors. She helped me gained $16,000 with just a capital of $2,000. If you want to be financially successful invest with her ASAP via WhatsApp through Facebook: Mrs Craig Vanessa”
“Cranberry Frost was a huge hit at Thanksgiving - good thing I had multiple bottles”
Loading...
“Fantastic customer service!! Greeted with big smiles…a thing of the past! Thank you!!!💕”