Customers` Favorites
Customers` Favorites
“I grew up in New Rochelle, NY and thus got to go to NYC quite often. For me, NYC pizza can't be topped. This place and Franco's in downtown Ithaca are about as close to NYC Pizza as it gets without actually Being NYC Pizza!
A couple of bonuses here are:
-the house salad always has beautiful, fresh and crispy lettuce (I've experienced much of the opposite from multiple pizzarias out here) as well as the best variety of fresh veggies to go along with it
-the portions of the Tiramisu are for one, delicious but also Generous. Especially for $5!
Occasionally, they may be understaffed and there may be a wait. Stay patient and kind - it's worth the wait!”
Customers` Favorites
“We just had the best time! Capped off our Christmas Eve shopping at Rogues. Food was great! Crispy wings with mixed garlic parm and medium sauces and their steak fries! Nice beer selections and FANTASTIC service! Thanks for a great experience!”
“I stayed here at the Rogues Harbor Inn in a beautiful room in March with my daughter. We absolutely loved the place. The owner paid attention to detail with the pictures, furniture, room decor, etc. The place was so inviting! There was a most beautiful “ surprising” breakfast room when we opened the double doors to go in for breakfast! ( You will see when you go there… I don’t want to ruin the surprise)… Maybe my daughter and I are silly about things like this but our mouths dropped and we couldn’t stop smiling… Not to mention the best breakfast…Oh and there is a bar attached to the inn that you could only get back into the inn with your key card… The bar was a quiet bar, with great food and service, and we were so happy to get food after a long day of travel without getting back into the car! The history of this place was just so interesting, the place was impeccably clean and the owner was wonderful. We loved this place so much…5 stars all the way.. in fact we need to make another trip back soon!”
Customers` Favorites
“The food was absolutely amazing and the service I received was even better. Food was fresh and cooked in a timely fashion. The bartenders were extremely nice. I would give them 10 stars if I could , fried pickles amazing , chicken park amazing , chicken wings prob best in town. Will be becoming a regular here !”
“Just went there on Sunday and got the sausage, olive, and onion pizza and chips. It was one of the best pizzas I ever had! The chips were really good too! I highly recommend this place.”
Customers` Favorites
“Great ice cream and great service! They gave me a wafer cone instead of the sugar cone I ordered - no biggie - and more than made up for it with a little extra ice cream and one of each cone! This was unnecessary, but certainly appreciated! This is how you treat your customers. And did I mention the ice cream was great? Highly recommended.”
“We always love to stop in and play pool, thank you for the free birthday shot! 🥃”
Customers` Favorites
“Never had any issues here, workers are usually quick with getting orders out. Easy to use the drive through or walk inside, do recommend using mobile app to order ahead and you'll be able to redeem free food and drinks.”
Customers` Favorites
“I ordered a pizza a short while ago and it is OUTSTANDING! All the ingredients are very fresh, the sauce and crust are just how I like them and it looks amazing. I think this is the best pizza in Ithaca and it will be my go to place from now on! About a month ago I had an issue with a Door Dash order and Nate went above and beyond to make it right.”
“Arty, cozy, dreamy and elegant! Every corner of the building is bursting with tasteful character without an ounce of clutter. The shared spaces offer everything you didn't even know you needed and the guest rooms are spacious, private and luxurious. The bathrooms are well lit, stocked and feature showers that are not just beautiful but experiential. I loved the coffee and snacks near the front desk with their kind and helpful staff. It's high end without being stuffy and homey without being kitschy, the best of all worlds come together at Argos Inn!”
Customers` Favorites
“I got a maple flavored iced latte that was amazing and a super good blueberry hand pie that was flakey and sweet. Will be back!”
Customers` Favorites
“We've been going to Dolce Delight since they opened & have always enjoyed their delicious coffee & baked goods, as well as the easy & homey atmosphere. The whole Dolce crew makes you feel like family.”
Customers` Favorites
“Everything! The brunch options are delicious! The desserts are scrumptious and the service was stellar! Perfect for any occasion. I’ll be back very soon!”
Customers` Favorites
“We both really enjoyed the pizza. Love the crispy crust too! Toppings were fantastic! We will definitely need to come back! We'll spread the word!!!”
Customers` Favorites
“You have to park on the street and it's pretty busy on it. If you don't find a spot right out front you may need to walk a few blocks especially during busy times in Ithaca like graduation week. The tacos are great. The ordering can feel a little chaotic because the cooks may ask you questions as they make it so you kind of stand at the counter after you order while they cook it. It can get very busy especially for such a small building but there is outside seating and they make the tacos super quickly.”
Customers` Favorites
“Great food, fresh, & creative. Healthy choices which I enjoy!”
Customers` Favorites
“Such a little gem in Ithaca Commons!!! Our son brought us here on the graduation weekend as this was his most favorite and most visited restaurant during his 4 years at Cornell. And boy was it worth it! Everything we got was super flavorful. Our server Shell was attentive, courteous and made our time there special. Do not miss this place if you are in the area !!!!”
Customers` Favorites
“Lillyanna and I stopped to eat here in the Ithaca Mall the day before Halloween 😋 This pizzeria has been in this mall for as long as I can remember 🥰 The food was Amazing … but the Service and Customer Appreciation from this Man was unmatched by far especially these days!!! Made fresh food just the way we ordered … hand delivered to our table and the thankful hospitality was heart warming!! BRAVO Stefano 🙌 ❤️🇮🇹💚🍕🍝 🤌🏼🌹🌹 🙌”
Customers` Favorites
“Best noodles I've ever eaten. Medium spice level was too spicy for me even though that's the level I normally order at other restaurants. Would have liked to have more vegetables with my noodles and veggies dish.”
Customers` Favorites
“From the cocktails to the coffee wonderful. Had the bread basket loved it Prime rib was great. And the srver Blake was beyond good , great service. Will be back again”
“We stopped in while vacationing, and found the facility very beautiful, the wines very good, and the staff friendly and knowledgeable. We would highly recommend anyone in the area visit this winery!”
Customers` Favorites
“Enjoyed lunch here with my husband. Neither of us are vegan but we really enjoyed our meals. Quick service in a cute and clean atmosphere.”
Customers` Favorites
“Favorite place to stop in Ithaca”
Customers` Favorites
“best service and breakfast ever. we stop every march on our way home from the finger lakes.”
Customers` Favorites
“Great experience here the other night.
Stopped by on the way to Homer to grab dinner with my partner. There was live music inside and a huge outdoor seating area. The ladies who helped us were lovely. We ordered at the counter, splitting a brisket sandwich and Nashville hot chicken sandwich, plus a corn salad. The fries were so good. Their selection of beers is also insane - so many options. I opted for a local sour that was delish.
This is the first restaurant in the area that accepts inKind, and I was eager to try it out to get cash back rewards. The app was easy to use for payment and my food/beer was heavily discounted. Can’t wait to come back and use my cash back!”
Customers` Favorites
“Love this place and that I can walk here!”
Customers` Favorites
“Best place for a sub!! We love it here”
Customers` Favorites
“You will not find a better place or nicer people on the commons than this place. One of my fav places !”
Customers` Favorites
“best food I've had in a long time. Tender, delicious jerk and curry chicken. perfect rice and beans. I dont know much about Jamaican food, but this is outta the park good.”
Loading...
“What a wonderful little inviting restaurant! Becky is awesome and greets you with a smile. She offers each person entering two options to sit down at the booth of their liking. I love the fact that the restaurant promotes locally grown and sourced foods and proudly displays the small farms and businesses' names on its wall. Copper Horse Coffee Roasters coffee is served and Mojo's Sauce is readily available on each table. The food is served hot and fresh and is very reasonably priced! Thank you Becky and The Ithaca Food Dude for your generosity for the gift card! I will be back!:)”