Restaurants near Lyndonville

“Ordered 2 hot subs and waffle fries. Food was delicious and hot, nice portions about a 10 to 15 min from order to eating. Friendly folks, a few tables inside , mostly take out orders.”

“Love the Full Rack of Ribs, Brisket Sammy and Fresh Cut Fries.. OH!!!SO!!!YUMMEE!!!!”

“Best place in Medina to visit for a coffee break. Latte was excellent pastries are wonderful. Great service and nice atmosphere.”

“Had lunch at Rudy’s today with family and everything was delicious! Service was great!”

“We hired Zambistro to cater our wedding. The food was absolutely amazing, our guests are still talking about it, especially the steak! The servers the day of were so sweet, and Summer kept checking in on my husband and I to make sure we had everything we needed. She truly made us feel cared for. Mike and Kara were also wonderful throughout the planning process, always quick to answer questions and make sure every detail was perfect. We couldn’t have asked for a better catering team. Highly, highly recommend!”

“The food is fantastic! Fresh! I love their breakfast food ! Eggs are huge and always cooked perfectly! Hash browns and bacon crispy ! Perfect customer service every-time! Very friendly !”

“Delicious! We will be back again!”

“Great ice cream and friendly staff. Love this place!”

“Fitzgibbons is like a woodworker’s art museum, but with a well-stocked bar amidst its unique carvings and decor. It’s worth lingering for the atmosphere alone. Their standout dish remains Shepherd’s Pie — it’s simple and hearty. While I chose to nurse a Jameson’s whiskey the night of a recent visit, the intriguing beer menu here always tempts me. The staff are duly welcoming but maybe a bit overworked when it gets too crowded. It’s never a dull night when one stops by Fitzgibbons though, unless it’s a Sunday, Monday or Tuesday when the place is closed.”

“Great place to eat , large portions great prices, always busy”

“We decided on take out today. The food is tasty. Just very very light on the BBQ sauce which was disappointing. Very quick service and very pleasant on the phone. We will definitely try it again but ask for far more BBQ sauce ( more than one squirt)”

“Just had the chicken corn chowder on 4.19.2025 @ Lockport Community Market - absolutely special and delicious!”

“Orleans county hidden Gem.
You would expect this type of service and atmosphere from a big city restuarant. Completely unexpected, completely satisfied. Highly recommend this establishment.”

“I really like this place. I looked at all the previous reviews and realized a lot of them haven’t figured out the best way to order. Go in to order, pay for food, leave, go somewhere else for drinks, go back food is ready. I have never had an issue.”

“Sicilian style pizza is worth the price. Cup and char, sweet sauce with garlic crust. Seasoned well so if you’re not a garlic fan go with regular crust. Eggplant parm sub is great, like the steak and cheese. The Royal will be the next one I try. Always have my order ready on time. Thanks Tim”

“Poler's Pub Best Burgers 🍔 in Medina. 👍👍
Very good Service. Friendly Atmosphere. The owners are very nice, friendly, down to earth people. Not to mention a veteran. My wife and I frequent often. If you're looking for an ice-cold beverage and lunch or dinner. This pub is highly recommended!👌”

“I stopped in yesterday for lunch and had an awesome time! Great food, great people. Definitely looking forward to my next visit.”

“this place is amazing I love the sweet sauce they use I do wish they had delivery service for those that live close by I would get it more often walking isn't easy for me.”

“The corn chowder today was just perfect. Didn't need anything else for lunch. Awesome!”

“There is no place like home... that's what they always say but let me tell you.... if there was any place like home this would be it. These people treat you like family from the day you walk in and it is one of the most down to earth places I have ever been.”

“It is a fun place to hang out with friends have tocos night Friday”

“Super authentic and delicious burrito. This place is just off the Erie canal, totally worth the detour. Servings are HUGE!

Vegetarian options: We also asked for a bean burrito, also delicious”

“We have used Case Nic for the last 3 of my daughter’s birthday parties and the cupcakes are fabulous every time! Not only are they beautifully decorated, they taste great also!! Thank you again!”

“The fall menu is my favorite. The butternut toast is amazing! The boozy milkshakes are fun and different. Always a great place for a casual night out with the girls.”

“Cozy food oasis, most flavorful subs/pizzas in town, great value/service. You want the absolute best sub in Medina? Or a classic pizza? It’s made at Doug’s Pizza, a virtual hole-in-the-wall operation in a tiny strip mall on the outskirts of town that all the locals know about. Totally ignore the corporate-run, overpriced fast food chains and other restaurants along Maple Ridge Rd. Doug delivers such awesome food value he doesn’t even need to advertise. He’s a hardworking machine with a ready smile, and the nicest guy you’ll ever find behind a food prep counter.

For a healthy and filling lunch, I highly recommend Doug’s All American sub (the whole size) featuring quality turkey, roast beef and ham. I get it with provolone cheese and ALL the side toppings plus mayo, oil & vinegar and a little salt & pepper. The generous portions spill out & you can barely close the sub sandwich! Doug’s pizzas are still among the tastiest in Medina, with a recipe going all the way back to the 1970s when this local spot first opened up as Mary’s Sub Shop. The fish fry here is also consistently good, and comes with freshly made cole slaw and awesome golden fries.

Parking: There are plenty of places to park in front of Doug’s, as well as nearby.

Kid-friendliness: Kids love pizza. Doug’s pizza is awesome!

Wheelchair accessibility: It’s a ground floor location at same level as parking lot, so easily accessible.”

“Prices were really gouging and I was shocked to have to pay nearly 10$ for 4 pizza logs. I went around the corner and got 4 pizza logs for a quarter of the price. I drove 2 hours for there special chicken fingers. They're specially sauced not specially affordable fyi. I went here as a kid around 15 years of age now I'm into my 30s. I'm not shocked the prices obviously changed. But I went a few years ago and they weren't that bad (prior Biden economics).”

“The girl who was working the pay here window on Easter at approximately 8:30 in the morning was an absolute joy. She was very warm and inviting and had the greatest smile. It is great to see customer service like this. The manager could take tips on this !”

“thank you Cusimano's for the awesome service and fixing us up with a few slices to go! you made my pregnant wife very very happy as always! highly recommended if you are in the area.”

“I stopped in yesterday for lunch and had an awesome time! Great food, great people. Definitely looking forward to my next visit.”

“Went to Crosbys to see if they had pizza but they didn’t have what I wanted, 3 minutes to closed and the lovely woman at subway took our order, very pleasant experience!”