New American Restaurants near Mendon, NY

“Great food and service. Ambiance was spoiled by some large garish paintings which seemed out of place in this old restored building. There were no beef entrees! With low ceilings in what was once a house, the noise became a nuisance once most tables were seated.“

“We visited the restaurant with our daughter and 4 friends for Easter Brunch. The location, food and service were terrific. Service was great (always had someone at the table before our water or lattes were done), the food was worth its cost (portions were large and we all had leftovers for later in the day). Will definitely be back next time visiting our daughter in Rochester.“

“If you're looking for Great food and Excellent Service in the Rochester N.Y. Area. Be sure to check out McArtle's, a family owned restaurant in the Fairborn area. They make excellent cocktails and we enjoyed a delicious dinner of Prime Rib and Beef tenderloins with bay scallops. The service is great and John the owner, personally delivered our food and did a follow up to make sure everything was first rate. They have a robot server named "Rosie" that assists the servers by bringing your food to the table for your server to serve you. This works great as it allows the server to spend more time serving the customers and avoids those large trays that clutter up the aisle ways in some restaurants. It's also a great conversation piece and it shows off the food as it passes your table. Everything looks great. The prime rib was cooked perfectly and the beef tenderloin was so tender you didn't need a knife. The Chicken French was also very good. The Haddock was perfectly cooked and they went the extra mile to handle our special carrots request. Our party of seven were very pleased. The also have excellent menu items for the Vegan members of the family The tall wooden booths give you the" Irish Tavern "feel while allowing you to be able to carry on a conversation at your table. The portions are generous and fairly priced. We didn't try dessert as we were comfortably full. But the desserts that went by looked yummy. Service was great, they make you feel welcome And want you to come back. (You can join their loyalty program for additional savings.) The restaurant is very accessible allowing seniors to get in easily.“

“We are always so welcomed and feel at home when we come here. This is our place to go after a long days work. The food is always solid. Amazing beer selection.. and best of all amazing service. Our Bartender Julie is so personable and real. We had the French dip tonight and it was amazing!! Wings great as always!!“

“Service was excellent. The server was friendly and extremely knowledgeable about the food and offerings. The atmosphere was also was lovely. The building was very old and quaint. Beautifully decorated. I you need accessible entrance I would check. My friend struggled with the old and uneven stairs, but there was just a couple at the door and one off the porch. Vegetarian friendly. I had the cauliflower toast which was quite good and plenty for 2 to share for an appetizer. Black bean burger for the main entree was delicious and made there. I had crème brûlée for dessert, it was a little runny but flavorful. A nice dinner.“

“This place was absolutely incredible. Great atmosphere with wonderful service and the food had so much depth and soul when it came to flavor/quality. We had the octopus and bone marrow appetizers, sweet potato gnocchi and duck breast entrees plus grabbed the cheesecake and German chocolate cake for desserts. Had the Hemingway drink with the appetizers and it was fantastic as well. I highly recommend checking this place out ?“

“I came in for dinner with some coworkers and truly loved my experience. We came in right at the end of Happy Hour and our server rushed to get our first wine orders in so we could make the special. I ordered the Ceasar salad with shrimp and it was quite possibly the best Ceasar I've ever had! It was incredible and filled with plump, perfectly cooked shrimp! I also ordered a side of fries because, girl dinner lol, and they were just what I wanted! Everyone else in my party enjoyed their meal equally. The restaurant was busy but we had quick, friendly service throughout our meal. It was a fun place to grab a meal and drinks after a long day of work!“

“My server Emily was AMAZING. She was professional, courteous, personable, and an excellent server. I had a particularly difficult moment the other night, she noticed my distress and asked if I was okay. That attention to detail of a customer's experience is what made my dinner at Irish Mafia exceptional that night. Thank you, Emily, for a job well done.“