Browse menus, reviews and photos of Delis near Middle Island.
Deli · $
1519 Rocky Point Rd, Middle Island
Customers’ favorites
“Omg this place was great. The food was delish. This is the cheers of breakfast spots. Everyone knows everyone and the are pure kindness. Kid-friendliness: They were Great to my Granddaughter. Even the other patrons were kind”
Deli · $
61 Half Mile Rd, Middle Island
Customers’ favorites
“Stopped for a quick bite on the way to an appointment. Let’s just say it was the best stop ever! Service was amazing! Food was amazing! Just was going to grab egg sandwich’s! Which by the way come with homemade ice tea, lemonade or oj, come to find out a very nice gentleman had come out from the back and said next time we come we need to try the empanadas! He had just made them and well we can’t say no to an empanada fresh made!!! Well let’s just say they barely made it to the car, had to go back in and let him know how good they were!! Everything was delicious and we will most definitely be back!! Filling and delicious!!”
Deli · $
908 E Main St, Yaphank · 3.46 miles
Customers’ favorites
“We had yaphank deli cater our Christmas Eve and Christmas day dinner. Everything was delicious! There was plenty of food and the pot roast was amazing! Thank your for making our parties a great success.”
Deli · $
1361 Lincoln Ave Suite 1, Holbrook · 10.09 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Bought a turkey club hero and was surprised at how big the sandwich was for the price. $12 and i almost had to unhinge my jaw to fit it. Service was prompt not only for me but every who came thru the door. No one waited to be served. The restaurant was clean and well organized. Plenty to chose from on their hot buffet .. and fresh too. Good spot.”
Deli · $
450 Main St, Yaphank · 2.88 miles
Customers’ favorites
“We had yaphank deli cater our Christmas Eve and Christmas day dinner. Everything was delicious! There was plenty of food and the pot roast was amazing! Thank your for making our parties a great success.”
Caterers · $
52 Old Dock Rd, Yaphank · 4.67 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Busy place when we visited for weekday lunch. What a selection of sandwiches. Fast service, fresh ingredients, great tasting hand-helds. Even the small sides of fries & tots are large servings. Mostly take-out orders. Couple of tables in and couple out. It's going to take a while to sample even half of their extensive menu, but I look forward to it.”
Deli · $$
375 Boyle Road, Selden · 5.76 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I just ordered the Ballfield-Chicken Cutlet, Bacon, Melted Swiss, Onion Rings, Russian dressing on Garlic Hero , It was the best Hero I have had in a long time. It was packed with Cutlets and was so filling I ate half then a few hours later ate the other half. I will def go back for another order soon.”
Deli · $
328 Mastic Rd, Mastic Beach · 8.77 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Called Friday: "are you open Monday?" "Yes til 3pm". On Monday: check Google, open til 3pm. Drove 25 mins one way, get there at 2:21 to find a lovely hand written sign "closing at 2pm"... 8 people very disappointed ? you can have the 5 stars back the next time I'm able to make the long trip.”
Deli · $
740 S Country Rd, East Patchogue · 8.84 miles
Customers’ favorites
“There is a great family and crew operating this deli. They are local to the area and know the people. The food is great and prices are fair. I can't think of a deli who's egg sandwiches can top theirs.”
Deli · $
1100 Portion Rd Suite 2, Farmingville · 7.09 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I've been getting my salads from Lake Deli for many years. I use to live in Medford now in Bohemia. It's over 45 minutes round trip but this is the only place that has the best salads I've tried other Delis. Just not the same. My sister loved them too whenever I went to Pennsylvania I had to bring 2 or more lbs.of potatoes”
Deli · $
737 Hulse Landing Rd, Wading River · 8.72 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Great convenience store/ deli. They have a little of everything in there. Delicious sandwiches with generous portions on fresh bread and a wide selection of snacks and beverages, including wine and beer. Staff is friendly and service was fast.”
Breakfast · $
6324 NY-25A, Wading River · 6.71 miles
Customers’ favorites
“We ordered a 3 ft hero, the presentation was fantastic! All cut up in a basket. The bread was so fresh and tasty! Will differently order from them again.”
Deli · $
451 NY-25A Store Suite 12, Miller Place · 4.68 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Awesome variety of food and service always with a smile. Would definitely recommend ❤️”
Deli · $
600 Montauk Hwy, Bayport · 11.29 miles
“I can't say enough about this deli and the family who have been running it for years. Hands down the best egg sandwiches and my mother absolutely loves their potato and macaroni salads. They always go out of their way to get to know their customers and have gone above and beyond for my elderly mother on many occasions. They are not just a deli, they are an important part of the community.”
Deli · $
234 William Floyd Parkway Suite 2, Shirley · 9.39 miles
Customers’ favorites
“A+ Award Winning Team Working holidays. Quality eats. Heroes on point. Just a welcoming spirit. Diversity in ethic background. Meet neighbors from church. Fine people. Array of selections. Primo coffee & Teas available Sovereignsfor passerbysrs & or homeland proud Americans. The proudest of people to serve you. Clean & Freshness ⭕️ Food Service Atmosphere kind, share a great laugh Love this place”
Deli · $
248 Union Ave, Holbrook · 8.96 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Oh my God we just finished the best breakfast sandwiches of our lives. We ignored our mother's training to not moan and grown as we ate our food because it was so good. So good in fact that we went back inside to thank the owner Muhammad for one of the best breakfast sandwiches we ever had and trust me we're professionals. If you're in the vicinity of Holbrook market and deli don't pass it by. Thanks again Holbrook Market and Deli.”
Deli · $
45 Ramsey Rd Unit 3, Shirley · 4.08 miles
Customers’ favorites
“What can I say this is one of the better delis I've been to. Good quality food, the chef knows what he's doing, the prices for some things are above average and for some things it's below average but it doesn't matter. When the food is this good, you don't mind paying a little bit more.”
Salad · $
508 East Main Street, Patchogue · 8.49 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Italian hero delicious thank you so much that was so good 💕”
Dominican · $
2229 NY-112, Coram · 3.33 miles
Customers’ favorites
“So nice inside and the food is great!! it's about 10-ish bucks for a salad, and it's so worth it. I've gotten salads from the Pop salad section and i just tried a quesadilla with steak (omg soooo good, the steak is soft and juicy and seasoned just right). the salad is always fresh and tasty and the portions are big!! My quesadilla meal was about 13.50 without the drink but i have leftovers and I always have half a salad left so it's like 2 meals for 10-15 dollars...so worth it. The people that prep the food in the back are so nice too. Idk where they found these employees but they are just so genuine and friendly. Love this place. I recommend it to everyone lol”
Deli · $
23 River Ave, Patchogue · 9.23 miles
Customers’ favorites
“YUMMERS breakfast sandwich”
Deli · $
18 Weeks St, Blue Point · 10.07 miles
“Just moved near here from Brooklyn. Amazing fun staff. amazing menu selection... great atmosphere ... awesome tasting food. SLAM DUNK wow I'm picky but this is great. I'm literally in the parking lot eating and couldn't leave without raving about it.”
Deli · $
260 Moriches-Middle Island Road, Manorville · 5.36 miles
“We had our sons graduation party catered from here and everything was delicious!! Everyone raved about how good the food was … the owners are super nice and great to work with.. would Absolutley use them again ..”
Deli · $
525 Neighborhood Road, Shirley · 9.32 miles
Customers’ favorites
“This place has really improved with the cooking and with the layout of the store the owners seem to care but the location is just a poor location because you always find riff raff throughout the store that seems to be the case when I go anyway I used to go to store all the time but not anymore too many badd people come in-and-out I try to stay away if I don't have to go..”
Deli · $
374 Mooney Pond Rd # A, Farmingville · 5.65 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I've been addicted to their homemade macaroni salad since the late '90's at the Middle Island store. The Selden store is the same. Don't know how they make it but it's honestly, the best I ever had. I've told them, PLEASE do not change the formula or i'd have to go to Macaroni Salad rehab. lol”
Deli · $
205 Waverly Ave, Patchogue · 8.89 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Delicious sandwich’s and potato salad Chicken was great as well”
Deli · $
3316a NY-112, Medford · 3.96 miles
“The most amazing BEC in a roll, seriously! Traditional deli. Family-owned deli. Adore this place. If you want a timeless bacon egg and cheese sandwich. You can't miss out here. The ultimate morning treat. Flawless. Simple yet scrumptious and attentively managed. A spot where they'll recognize you. I'll continue returning. My toddler had his inaugural BEC here. Grateful for the kindness and acceptance. Kid-friendliness: Ideal for kids.”
Deli · $
711 Horseblock Road, Farmingville · 5.93 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Whenever it is takeout the food is DELICIOUS, even though the owners are Dominican, the cooks are from Hidalgo, Mexico and their Mexican food is top quality and good seasoning and the price is regular, it really is not that expensive for how delicious it is. this!!! ??, I RECOMMEND IT!!!”
Deli · $
1133 Montauk Hwy, Mastic · 6.98 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I went there around 12:30 or so. The food looked delicious. The fish, the chicken, the beef steak, it was all fresh and well made and smelled really good. Their pupusas are good too. $3.00 compared to some other places where they are $2.75 the size of the pupusas was decent too. It didn’t fit properly in the container because it was larger lol.”
Deli · $
691 NY-25A, Miller Place · 4.56 miles
Customers’ favorites
“The Bagel sandwiches were delicious. Our order was forgotten about and we just watched people come and go. We finally asked someone to check on it and got the order. Worth the wait though! Delicious. Salt bagels on hand and delicious fresh lox. Yum”
Deli · $
204 Blue Point Ave, Blue Point · 10.47 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Firehouse Deli is one of my go to stops every time I visit home. BEC on a roll w/salt & pepper/ketchup!”
Meal Delivery · $
151 Middle Country Rd, Ridge · 5.34 miles
Customers’ favorites
“The roast beef supreme hero is great. Also I like all the Islander photos and baseball players on the wall. The outdoor bench is great for nice weather. Good counter help as well.”
Deli · $
704 Portion Rd, Lake Ronkonkoma · 8.16 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I was skeptical at first but seeing how clean the place was i was intrigued to try it out. Not really knowing what to order i took a chance and was pleasantly surprised how delicious everything tasted and looked especially from the buffet. This place is a must in lake ronkonkoma. So glad I walked in and will be back to try other things on their menu.”
Deli · $
15 Carman St, Patchogue · 9.25 miles
“I always loved the food here, especially the banana pancakes with a side of scrambled eggs. The coffee and omelets are also terrific. Homefries are tasty too. I was very sad when Danny's Deli a.k.a. Carman Street deli left doordash! I hope so much you guys will return to doordash so I can order some more super yummy breakfasts!”
Deli · $
205 Waverly Ave, Patchogue · 8.05 miles
“Bought chopped salad here two days in a row and they were both amazing!!! Fresh ingredients and made exactly how ordered!! Very well run, friendly staff and great food!!!!”
Deli · $
60 Washington Ave, Patchogue · 8.38 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Food was great as expected. I thought Tj Hero here and in Mastic Beach were associated but was told they are different owners. A little confusing since Mastic Beach is Tj hero s and Patchogue is called Tj Hero II. Was disappointed that they dont honor the specials of the Original but live and learn.”
Deli · $
331 Rte 25A, Mt Sinai · 5.6 miles
“Pete the owner is probably the nicest guy you'll ever meet. Always says hello and wgats going on. He make the absolute best chicken cutlets anywhere. The breakfast sandwiches with bacon are hands down the best I ever had. Due to his deli, I cant leave long island.”
Deli · $
1387 Montauk Highway, East Patchogue · 7.76 miles
Customers’ favorites
“They have a better cook now! Oxtails are great! Fresh fried chicken is good! Love the fact the greet and we get our Spanish speaking on so I can stay of my P's and Q's. My son's nick name is bacon egg and cheese for good reason.”
Deli · $
14 Sawgrass Dr, Bellport · 5.31 miles
Customers’ favorites
“My Husband bought me a bacon egg and cheese on a roll. Eggs were scrambled bacon well done and the roll was fresh, DELISH! A must try!!”
Deli · $
461 Station Rd, Bellport · 7.55 miles
“Stopped in for lunch and walked out impressed. Their sandwiches are made fresh to order with quality ingredients, and the service is fast even when it's busy. Great selection of deli meats and toppings. Prices are fair and the spot is clean and well-organized. This is a solid neighborhood deli—definitely coming back!”
Deli · $
25 Patchogue-Yaphank Rd, Patchogue · 8.18 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Food is excellent. Prices are great. And the staff are amazing. Nicest place to go for a freshly made meal or snacks.”
Deli · $
53 Broadway, Rocky Point · 4.66 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Food is delicious and so is the price !!! Highly recommend 👌”
Deli · $
525 Neighborhood Road, Shirley · 9.32 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Got turkey cheese hero. Ham n cheese hero . Both were awesome. Suggest asking for extra lettuce if you actually life lettuce on the sandwich it was like 3 scraggly little strips of lettuce but other than that they were super nice people and the sandwich tasted amazing. Recommend”
Deli · $
1088 Mastic Rd, Mastic · 7.65 miles
Customers’ favorites
“This place prepares meals all day long and serves them from a hot steam table. They have all kinds of items from yellow rice, Spanish rice, chicken, wings, egg sandwiches, regular deli sandwiches, french fries grilled cheese sandwiches, steak and cheese sandwiches you name it pretty much they’ll make it for you. They have a small Mini Mart. There are Spanish oriented items there but everything looks fresh. The produce looks great. The shelves are fully stocked, and the floors are all clean. The staff is very friendly and they speak English and Spanish. I stop at this place every time I take the Port Jefferson ferry over to this area.”
Deli · $
1315 Middle Country Road, Centereach · 6.33 miles
Customers’ favorites
“We catered my son’s Graduation party and the food was absolutely delish! Good portions, kind friendly staff My only disappointment was that when the food was delivered the eggplant was not hot at all … just barely warm, however it was tasty even if it wasn’t hot!”
Deli · $
623 Horseblock Road, Farmingville · 6.11 miles
Customers’ favorites
“As soon as I walked in, I was immediately welcomed and helped very attentively. Amazing customer service and environment is very comforting. Store is very clean and upkept. And food is even better. I mean they have so many cool creations. Definitely recommend choosing this as your go-to bagel spot if you’re near by!”
Deli · $
148 Hallock Ave, Port Jefferson Station · 6.58 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I dont know if its their signature sandwich but my folks have been taking me to The Wunderbar for breakfast sandwiches for years. I always get 2 eggs over medium with bacon and cheese. They are very consistent, always delicious and use about a pound of bacon per sandwich. I look forward to it every time I visit.”
Deli · $
2554 Montauk Hwy, Brookhaven · 6.62 miles
Customers’ favorites
“The food here is delicious. I ordered a pastrami sandwich and my partner ordered a monte Cristo sandwich. We both thoroughly enjoyed our food. We ordered some of the salads on the side. I wouldn't really get those again but those sandwiches were perfection. I will certainly be back.”
Deli
1600 Main St, Port Jefferson · 6.9 miles
Customers’ favorites
“So nice inside and the food is great!! it's about 10-ish bucks for a salad, and it's so worth it. I've gotten salads from the Pop salad section and i just tried a quesadilla with steak (omg soooo good, the steak is soft and juicy and seasoned just right). the salad is always fresh and tasty and the portions are big!! My quesadilla meal was about 13.50 without the drink but i have leftovers and I always have half a salad left so it's like 2 meals for 10-15 dollars...so worth it. The people that prep the food in the back are so nice too. Idk where they found these employees but they are just so genuine and friendly. Love this place. I recommend it to everyone lol”
Deli · $
453 Medford, 5 De Mayo, Patchogue · 7.73 miles
Customers’ favorites
“The food here is consistently amazing and prices are reasonable. My wife and I have been here about a dozen times since moving into the neighborhood a few years ago. We usually get a few tamales (green, red, and/or rajas) and they're always hot, fresh, and delicious. I've also gotten a few breakfast sandwiches here (bacon, egg, avocado) and they're also great.”
Deli · $
753 Montauk Hwy, Bayport · 11.07 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Angel, Jose, Norma, Karen are alway very good”