Bennett Shellfish

Name: Bennett Shellfish
Address: 2 S Debusy Rd, Montauk, New York, 11954, US
Telephone: (631) 903-5817
Rating: 4.7

Seafood, Bakery

Hours:
2 S Debusy Rd, Montauk
(631) 903-5817

About Bennett Shellfish

Bennett Shellfish provides a water-to-table experience rooted in 14th generation bayman traditions and sustainable practices. This family-oriented market offers friendly customer service, taking time to answer questions and give advice. Their menu includes fresh, high-quality seafood such as smoked bluefish, lobster rolls, oysters, and decadent lobster white pizza. The lobster roll is especially praised for its freshness and taste, with lots of lobster meat, a light touch of mayo, and subtle flavors. The potato bun and Cape Cod chips make it a perfect lunch. Many customers say the market is always clean, with seafood wrapped in ice for freshness and easy transport. They also sell homemade and flash-frozen shellfish cakes and pies, as well as desserts. Visitors often stop here before heading home, confident in the quality and fair prices. With great service, fresh seafood, and a welcoming atmosphere, Bennett Shellfish is a top choice for seafood lovers in the area.